Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
1995-03-13 Council Packet - Work Session, Sand Dunes
Kenai City Council Joint Work Session March 13, 1995 Kenai City Council Kenai Planning & Zoning Commission Parks & Recreation Commission Kenai Bicentennial Visitors & Cultural Center Board of Directors Protection of Sand Dunes Policing and Preparation of Park and Beach Facilities Sanitation of City Parks KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION OF MARCH 13, 1995 KENAI CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS 7:00 P.M. The members of the Kenai Planning & Zoning Commission, Parks & Recreation Commission and Kenai Bicentennial Visitors & Cultural Center Board of Directors were invited to the work session. COUNCIL PRESENT: Williams, Bookey, Smalley, Measles, Monfor and Bannock. Councilwoman Swarner arrived at approximately 7:30 p.m. PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSIONERS PRESENT: Mahurin, Werner-Quade, Walker. PARKS & RECREATION COMMISSIONERS PRESENT: Gifford, Castimore, Hultberg and Sandahl. KENAI BICENTENNIAL VISITORS & CULTURAL CENTER REPRESENTATION: Kim Booth, Executive Director; Ron Malston, Board Member and Ron Rainey, Board Member. STAFF PRESENT: Freas, Kornelis, Graves, McGillivray, Morris, Burnett (arriving at 7:30 p.m.) and Manninen. OTHERS PRESENT: Bob Peters, Dr. Peter Hansen, Loretta Breeden and Amy Gill (Clarion). OPENING OF WORK SESSION: Mayor Williams welcomed persons present. Councilwoman Monfor informed those present she requested the work session because of her concern for the Kenai beaches and use they receive during the summer, especially during the dipnet fisheries. Use will probably increase this summer due to the closure to fishing of the Little Susitna and Alexander Creek. Persons who would have used those fishing areas have been told by the Department of Fish & Game to fish the Kenai River instead. Monfor added she believed if they met together they might develop ideas of how to protect the beaches which include the sand dunes. Monfor stated she investigated how other areas protect their beaches. In Oregon they have developed an ordinance to keep off - road vehicles off of the beaches. People wanting to use the beaches must park and walk to the beaches. Monfor asked why there is a road to access the river mouth. Williams answered it is there to access private property on both sides of the river. Those pieces of property are either owned by the City or are privately owned. Williams requested a map showing the properties on the beach area and a list of its owners. KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 2 Monfor added the City has about four months to get ready for the summer influx of users. She would like the City to be proactive in order to handle the activity. Monfor added Cunningham Park and the land across the river should be included in their discussions as they are affected by the summer activities as well. Monfor suggested that since the City has a fund balance, it may be necessary to use some of it to handle the summer activity. She did not consider the placement of trash facilities and proper sanitation as frivolous. The City has done a lot to encourage tourists to the area and now it is necessary for the City to accommodate the visitors. Monfor stated she would like the Council, Parks & Recreation Commission, KBVCC and Planning & Zoning to do something that is cost efficient and do -able and can show, again, that the overlay ordinance is not needed. Whatever is done will be newsworthy statewide. Williams suggested forbidding the use of the area for dipnetting. Smalley stated the Oregon Parks used to rent wheelbarrows to persons wanting to take items onto the beach. They also assigned certain beaches for use of motor vehicles, others not, and all were patrolled by the police. Smalley added he agreed with Monfor and suggested both sides of the Spruce Street beach be closed to motorized vehicles. Williams stated there were two items needed -- one, a color -coded map showing ownership of the property from Spruce Street on; and knowing what to do with the vehicle traffic parking when there is dipnetting activity. Loretta Breeden stated she mostly agreed with Monfor. If the sand dunes are lost, the other bank will probably be lost as well. She understands there is a problem with the private property. Breeden stated she spoke with representatives from Fish & Game. They indicated the salmon allocation in Kenai may change, allowing more red salmon escapement. This may bring on more dipnetting and more fishing activity. Breeden suggested some of the problem could be alleviated if dipnetting by boat would be allowed. Breeden suggested writing to the Fish Board in and requesting a change. KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 3 Williams stated the only boat ramp close by is the City's which could be a problem. Breeden added to remember that there are commercial fishermen who use the beach to get to their sites. Monfor agreed, but they drive to the right. The left side is to be closed to vehicular traffic. Breeden added she believed it would be bad if the beach were closed to all vehicular traffic except the commercial fishermen. Breeden added she believed fencing off the beach road would be good. In regard to Cunningham Park, Breeden stated in the summer it is not unusual to see 90-plus people fishing along the bank. However, it gets really messy when the guide boats are launching, pickup trucks are backing down the bank, etc. Breeden suggested the City discuss the problem with Fish & Game. Teresa Werner-Quade noted the difference between a beach and a dune, reading from Design with Nature, by,Ian McGard, 1971 copyright. The point being a beach is tolerant, i.e. the tide cleans it. A dune is intolerant, i.e. if they need to be crossed, there should be bridges to go over them. There should be no development on them or walking on them. Williams stated a problem is the fact that Fish & Game opens the area to dipnetting, knowing that 500-1,000 people may show up to do it. The question is how to control the dipnetters when the State has allowed the fishing. Should the City take control of the property or accommodate the fishermen. To disallow fishing, the City would have to block the road. If the dipnetting is allowed, the City needs to make a way to access the beach. Kevin Walker suggested the road be blocked off to vehicular traffic. Williams asked Attorney Graves who owns the properties and how much is in private hands. Graves stated he would have to review the plat maps and see how much value would be removed from the private hands. The road could be cabled off or parking could be prohibited in order to channel pedestrian traffic to the beach. Bob Peters suggested if the road is closed, close it all the way and only allow access to the beach by walking down the beach. Peters added he believed enforcement would not work. Everybody ignores the signs that already exist. KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 4 Dick Hultberg stated that the Parks & Recreation Commission have discussed the problem for years. Hultberg suggested (1) whatever is done, it will have to include changing habits of the users of the area and this will make some people unhappy; and, (2) it will cost money to enforce the changes. Karen Mahurin stated she thought they all agreed, the dunes need to be saved. A number of suggestions have been made, i.e. to stop fishing; keep people out. What is the Council aiming for? Williams asked how the fishing industry views the dipnetting. Should it be allowed? Dale Sandahl reported he asked some of the store owners in the area how the dipnetting openings have impacted their businesses. He was told the stores do more business during the dipnetting openings than for all of the rest of the fishing from May through August and September. He believes the dipnetting openings have a significant impact on the area businesses. (NOTE: Councilwoman Swarner and Fire Chief Burnett arrived at approximately 7:30 P.M.) Sandahl continued he did not believe they could close it to fishing as it would have a very large impact. Instead, they need to find a way to accommodate the users. Sandahl suggested: a. Encourage boating for dipnetting; b. Cable the road off; C. Develop bridge access for pedestrians but consider realistic needs in order to access the beach, without walking or shuttling people from up on the hill. Karen Mahurin stated she felt it would be a real disservice to the local people if the area is not allowed for dipnetting. Many local people dipnet. It's a family affair. Many people don't have boats. Dipnetting is used as subsistence. However, the dunes need to be protected. Ron Rainey agreed with Mahurin. The red salmon season is not predominately a tourist fishery, but a local fishery. However, there are many people that come to the area to fish the red season. It is a big fishery. The area needs to be kept open for dipnetting, but not a tourism thing. KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 5 Loretta Breeden noted dipnetting is allowed for Alaska citizens only. A way needs to be found to protect the dunes. Councilwoman Monfor added enforcement and sanitation need to be upgraded. Also, they need population and traffic control. More garbage dumpsters, etc. Plus, don't forget the other side of the River. Kevin Walker suggested another possibility -- the City could acquire some of the property on the beach sides of the dunes and make a permanent asphalt parking area. The City will either have to keep people totally off or acquire, develop, and utilize the property. Something will need to be done. A large parking area wouldn't hurt much either. Monfor stated she believed there was a spot for parking now. Walker stated it would be to the left. Some of the dunes would have to be taken out in order to place the parking lot. Councilwoman Monfor suggested additional dumpster(s) be placed along the beach area and they should be there all year round. If port -a -potties are placed, they need to be cleaned often, maybe twice a day. Cunningham Park is the same. Measles stated the rental company will clean them as often as you say and pay to have them cleaned. Dr. Hansen stated a group of approximately 250 physicians will be meeting in Kenai during the summer. Hansen suggested placing a sheltered picnic area on the beach for use for cookouts, etc. (rough -cut pavilion with picnic tables). Monfor asked if he had investigated using the Municipal Park for such a cookout. Hansen stated he had, but you couldn't see or hear the ocean from there. Monfor suggested more underbrush be removed in order to be able to see and hear the ocean from the Municipal Park picnic area. Williams asked McGillivray how bad of shape is the restroom at the beach? How much will it cost to fix it? Can it be added to? McGillivray answered the present restroom does not meet ADA requirements. There is no access for wheelchairs, etc. unless the walls would be knocked and the facility enlarged. McGillivray added the facility can continue to be used. Also, grant applications have been sent in for funding to replace that restroom. It was his and the City Engineer's recommendation that the present facility be torn down and replaced. KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 6 Smalley suggested the restroom be placed closer to the mouth of the river. McGillivray stated most of the activity, all summer long, is at the place where the restroom is now. The activity at the mouth of the river is for short periods during the summer. The new restroom would be the size of the restrooms in the other park areas. Port -a -potties would be placed, as in years past, when additional facilities are needed. Sandahl stated enlarging and replacing the restroom facility will encourage more use of the dunes. Williams asked Council if they were in agreement that the restroom at the Spruce Street beach should be replaced? Council consensus was yes. Williams requested the engineering department draw up a plan to allow blocking off of vehicular traffic on the beach road and find out the ownership of the properties along the beach. Hultberg asked if this would include placing bridges over the dunes. Williams asked how keeping people on a walking area would be enforced. Kim Booth suggested placing educational signage in order to inform people what the effects are of walking on the sand dunes. Sandahl agreed. Councilwoman Monfor suggested soliciting help from service organizations like the Lions Club, Rotary, Boy Scouts, etc. for placing of signs. Williams stated he didn't believe the signs would get people to physically stay off the dunes. Ron Rainey suggested roping off the area, along with the signs. Karen Mahurin stated this is a serious situation and that the City should take the steps to place the signs now before the season begins. Mayor Williams requested Kornelis have the Engineering Technician develop a master plan incorporating the placement of a parking lot, roping off of the dunes (the whole way down to the mouth of the river), and educational signs. KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 7 McGillivray added a lot of people use the dunes for sunbathing areas. Williams asked if Council wanted to incorporate a pavilion into the plan, placing it further down the beach and away from the fishing area. Sandahl suggested the signs to be placed at the beach have information included as the one on the bluff regarding the mountains, fish, historical information, along with the educational information regarding the dunes. Williams suggested the signs be placed in a kiosk around the restroom area. Jack Castimore suggested sea grass could be transplanted in an area (about 401x401) to show people how the dunes can be restored. Monfor reminded Council all this cannot be done this year, but the basics can be placed, i.e. the restroom facilities, dumpsters all year long, etc. The same can be done for Cunningham Park too. Bannock stated he didn't think the signs would work. More important that the signs and fence is the practicality issue -- what can we do to formulate a plan? Bannock suggested a parking lot be developed at which vehicles can be parked, but allow the road to be used as a loading and unloading zone. If the plan is to make people walk to the mouth of the river, they will walk on the dunes because it is the shortest way. With allowing the road to be used for loading and unloading, the people can be accommodated and the dunes can still be protected. Bannock suggested the use of a shuttle service or a drop off zone. Williams suggested that if the road is blocked off to vehicular traffic and there is a parking area, people may decide not to use the area. Bannock stated he believed there would be more people using the area this year. Kelly Gifford stated she agreed with Bannock, she doesn't think the signs will work. Also, she did not think people should park along Spruce Street. Ron Rainey didn't agree with Bannock that people don't care and won't pay attention to the signs. There is a change in philosophy on the river in regard to habitat protection. KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 8 People's awareness helps. If the City wants to spend a minimal amount of money, the signs, ropes and bridges need to be placed. If they want to spend more, more can be done. Sandahl stated he totally agreed, adding he felt strongly about the educational aspect. Williams stated a plan should be developed, along with funding, to place a new restroom facility, more dumpsters and port -a - potties. As a temporary measure, they will have to try to block off vehicular traffic and try to cause people to be careful of the dunes. Smalley asked Kornelis if he could price out and develop a couple bridge access points where paths are already existing. Kornelis stated there are already paths between the dunes. Was Smalley wanting the bridges placed there? Smalley answered yes. Kornelis reminded Council there have been parking areas made along the road (pull -off spots). Williams stated the road will be blocked off. Hultberg referred to a comment made earlier and agreed that public should be made aware of the changes coming through public service announcements, etc. Monfor agreed that coverage needs to be started. Monfor added she would like to have Channel 2 News come to Kenai where they can be taken to the dunes. Have them say why the City is making these changes -- trying to save what we have. Councilwoman Swarner asked if the City had the plans for the restroom facility at the dock? Kornelis answered yes, however, that facility cost approximately $100,000. Bob Peters requested the old bridge now existing at the beach be revitalized as well. A bridge should be included in that area to cross the dunes as people walk down over the bluff from Mission Avenue. Peters also requested something more permanent be done to keep people from driving and using Mission Avenue. Williams suggested signs be placed there saying public access is not allowed. Peters added there are many people that use a path from in front of the Kenai Bible Church to access city property. KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 9 Dr. Hansen stated he thought Bannock had a good idea about the parking. If there was a paved parking facility with a restroom and an individual to work 16 hours a day from June 15-August 15, it could be a drawing card for people. Williams stated he was concerned that there would not be enough room to park some of the RVs that would want to park. Councilman Bookey stated it would not hurt the local RV park business if overnight parking was not allowed. Bookey suggested a fee situation. Mahurin suggested marking the RV spaces and if the RV is too big to fit in it, they won't be allowed to park there. Breeden asked Rainey if he too believed the allocation of red salmon into the River for the sports fishermen will increase the amount of dipnetting periods. If there are more periods, the user problem will increase as well. Rainey stated he believed Fish & Game will allow 100,000 more fish in the River for sports fishing. With that many fish, there will probably be more dipnetting periods. Breeden suggested the City lobby Fish & Game to allow dipnetting by boat. Williams stated he would write a letter to the Fish & Game Board requesting they allow dipnetting by boat to alleviate the impact of dipnetting fishermen on the beach. Kornelis noted that people may use boats for personal use dipnetting. Boats are not allowed for subsistence fishing. Measles stated he believed the changes to be made should not be just geared toward dipnetting. There are other uses for the beach as Dr. Hansen had mentioned and it can be used substantially by non -fishing groups. Williams stated stream rehabilitation could be incorporated into the master plan. Two phases = long term and short term. The plan should start with the restroom upgrade, additional dumpsters and roping off the dunes. Kornelis reminded Council they needed to plan for the addition to the Sewer Treatment Plant. The addition would be built in about three or four years. However, where it will be built is where discussion had been about placing a paved parking lot. KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 10 Kornelis suggested a circle might work as the one at the Russian River. When it is full, it is full. Kornelis added, the pull - off parking spots along the beach road could be encased. However, if they want to protect the dunes, the road needs to be blocked off to vehicular traffic. Measles suggested the road should no longer be graded. It was noted that if there will be dumpsters, etc. closer to the mouth of the river, the road will need to be graded in order that the service vehicles can have access. Werner-Quade suggested the road be used as a service road only. Measles agreed. Sandahl asked where the parking lot could be placed if the right side of the road will need to be kept available for the sewer treatment plant addition? Kornelis suggested the left side of the road. Smalley suggested the right side of the road be used for a parking area this year only during dipnetting and see what impact that has. Williams stated he believed there would be less impact with not walking on the sand dunes. Williams suggested creating an ordinance that would prohibit persons from accessing the beach from the bluff above. Rainey stated he agreed there is a need for a master plan and it should include how much each item will cost. The plan, as he understood from the discussions, would include the new restroom, additional dumpsters and port -a -potties (with additional dumping), walkways, roped -off area, signage, an ordinance and enforcement of the ordinance. Monfor stated they are discussing a once -a -year situation for a specific amount of time. Monfor suggested, for information only, placing road counters over the road as she would like to know how much traffic does the area receive. Monfor asked what the time line would be on this project. Monfor added this project should take precedence over some others. Williams stated work could begin right away if McGillivray and the Planning Department are comfortable with the restrooms identified and with the overall cost in putting them in place. KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 11 CUNNINGHAM PARR: Smalley suggested shutting the boat launch down. Williams stated his concern with shutting it down is that it may be impossible to get it reopened and re -permitted. Williams added he thought it better, at this time, to clean up the park and add another restroom (costing $30,000). BALLPARK AREA: Kornelis stated the restroom to be placed there will have running water because there is water/sewer service to that area. Cost for that restroom is estimated at $40,000. Monfor remarked that it is costly, but with as many people that use the facilities, it will be paid for. FINDINGS: Council reviewed the Parks & Recreation Department's five-year plan for capital expenditures which was included in the packet. Monfor suggested the restrooms all be placed this year. Williams asked if the materials could be purchased locally and built here. Kornelis stated the tanks are included with the restroom buildings which would be a problem. McGillivray stated the tanks can be bought separately, however the whole restroom is basically pre -built. McGillivray was asked to find out how the restroom packages are sent. Bookey asked if the cost for these improvements would be placed in the 1995-96 budget. Williams stated three restrooms would go in this year from this budget, appropriating the money from the fund balance. Manninen stated Kornelis was told leftover monies from the Thompson Park project might be able to be reappropriated for sanitary facilities. If that is possible, Council may want to place a fireplace/pavilion on the beach. Williams suggested Administration can work those details out. Williams requested the basic master plan be brought back to council for the April 19 meeting. Kornelis stated that could be KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 PAGE 12 done. The same information should be forwarded to the Parks & Recreation Commission and the Planning & Zoning Commission for their review as well. PARRS & RECREATION CAPITAL EXPENDITURE PROGRAM: Williams suggested the following: 1995/96 - Add one more restroom bringing total for the year to $150,000. McGillivray stated if the Public Works Department receives a new pick-up, they will get a hand-me-down pick-up and will not need funding for one in their budget. Also, the riding mower is essential. McGillivray asked if Council was aware of the information forwarded by the Engineering Technician regarding the Cunningham Park grant application? Manninen stated it was included in the council meeting packet. There has been no further information about it. Bannock asked McGillivray if he was comfortable paying $30,000 for a restroom. McGillivray stated someone could probably be found to do it cheaper, but he was looking for the sturdiest product with the most features to protect from vandalism, etc. and had the outside tanks. Bannock asked if McGillivray thought buying them was a better bargain that building them in-house. McGillivray stated yes. Walker added there needs to be an architectural stamp on the design which escalates the cost (if done locally). ADJOURNMENT: The work session adjourned at approximately 9:10 p.m. Notes transcribed and submitted by: Carol L. Freas, City Clerk 3/15/95 KENAI CITY COUNCIL JOINT WORK SESSION MARCH 13, 1995 "TO DO" LIST KK - Have a basic master plan developed for the beach area off Spruce Street. Include in the plan a paved parking lot, new restroom, additional dumpsters and port -a - potties, bridges, roping off of the road (to be used as a service road only), and possibly a picnic pavilion. Have the basic master plan brought back to Council for the April 19 meeting. The same information should be forwarded to the Parks & Recreation Commission and the Planning & Zoning Commission for their review. KO - Have port -a -potties and dumpsters emptied numerous times a week and/or day during summer. Find out how the restroom packages are sent. ADMIN - Find out if leftover monies from the Thompson Park project can be used for placement of new restrooms at Cunningham Park and the Spruce Street beach area. Do a color -coded map indicating Spruce Street beach property lots and owners. SIMAGING 10576 KENAI SPUR HW Y #8 KENAI, AK 99611 907-283-6300 POLICE DEPT 233- 7'b?9 , 26 10 : -'7 1nr ,- Affirlim 2022 ANCHORAGE LAB USE ONLY ,, I t � :Jt11" CHECK CHECK CNECKpoft [;] Pfkb Photo Oakq Album of prints available for 36mm, disc and 110 color Double prints avelleble for 35mm, disc, 126 or 110 color print film print film (C-41 process only). Not available for 120. GbW finish only. (C-41 prose only). 4' prints 00say only. DEFT, 158 DO NOT COVER OR WRITE MOW UNE Iln@INIIhIIIIIIaIIIIIIU�IIN Sl'd: i6 J 11�J �3 VOU an Rum dbv6—u erg use Mpw4pYMre J tie09 - Not all photos are created equal. Some use processing that isn't up to Kodak standards. Carrs uses Kodak paper and chemicals, and the Colorwatch system. WORK SESSION NOTICE The Kenai City Council will convene in a joint work session with the Kenai Parks & Recreation Commission, Planning & Zoning Commission and KBVCC Board of Directors on Monday, March 13, 1995. The work session will be held in the Council Chambers at Kenai City Hall and will begin at 7:00 p.m. The purpose of the work session is to discuss the following: PROTECTION OF SAND DUNES POLICING AND PREPARATION OF PARK AND BEACH FACILITIES SANITATION OF CITY PARKS The public is invited to attend and participate. Carol L. Freas City Clerk DATED: March 7, 1995 Publish: March 10, 1995 Community News: March 13, 1995 WORK SESSION NOTICE The Kenai City Council will convene in a joint work session with the Kenai Parks & Recreation Commission, Planning & Zoning Commission and KBVCC Board of Directors on Monday, March 13, 1995. The work session will be held in the Council Chambers at Kenai City Hall and will begin at 7:00 p.m. The purpose of the work session is to discuss the following: PROTECTION OF SAND DUNES POLICING AND PREPARATION OF PARK AND BEACH FACILITIES SANITATION OF CITY PARKS The public is invited to attend and participate. Carol L. Freas City Clerk DATED: March 7, 1995 Publish: March 10, 1995 Community News: March 13, 1995 1791 -1991 CITY OF KENAI . m Cgdat 0( ifhzkd FAX TO FROM 04 e4owl, 210 Fidalgo, Suite 200 Keaai,.Alaska 99611-7794 ^" Phone 907-283-7535 Fax 907-283-3014 Date 3 / -7 /��si Number of Pages .2 1791 - Ml CITY OF KENAI . "Ocl Capciat 00� F,kX FROM ems; dl �� 5 210 Fidalgo, Suite 200 Keaai, Alaska 99611-7794 f- Phone 907-283-7535 Fax 907-283-3014 Date 6T / 17 / i�� Number of Pages 1-:37 Gli�i- �G��-gym �, ,�� �'�'� � /��%� moo• H/ CITY OF KENAI It Gdtz" 4>a, * 210 FIDALGO AVE., SUITE 200 KENAI, ALASKA 99611-7794 TELEPHONE 907-283-7535 FAX 907-283-3014 MEMORANDUM 1 I I I 1992 TO: Tom Manninen, City Manager DEPARTMENT HEADS Kim Booth, KBVCC Executive Director FROM: Carol L. Freas, City Cle k City of Kenai DATE: March 7, 1995 RE: MARCH 13, 1995 WORK SESSION At their meeting of March 1, 1995, the Kenai City Council set a work session for March 13, 1995 (notice is attached). The work session was set to discuss PROTECTION OF SAND DUNES POLICING AND PREPARATION OF PARK AND BEACH FACILITIES SANITATION OF CITY PARKS In order for Council to review information you may have in regard to these subjects prior to the work session, please forward it to me by NOON, Thursday, March 9, 1995 for dissemination to Council. Thanking you in advance for your attention and cooperation. elf CITY OF KENAI it cd 4 Awl"„ 210 FIDALGO AVE., SUITE 200 KENAI, ALASKA 99611-7794 TELEPHONE 907-283-7535 FAX 907-283-3014 bW*v%4 WAW,e Cft MEMORANDUM 111119 "Z TO: Planning & Zoning Commission Members Parks & Recreation Commission Members KBVCC Board of Directors FROM: Carol L. Freas, City Clerk, City of Kenai DATE: March 7, 1995 RE: HARCH 13, 1995 WORK SESSION At their meeting of March 1, 1995, the Kenai City Council set a work session for March 13, 1995 (notice is attached). The work session was set to discuss PROTECTION OF SAND DUNES POLICING AND PREPARATION OF PARK AND BEACH FACILITIES SANITATION OF CITY PARKS Council requested members of the Parks & Recreation Commission, Planning & Zoning Commission and KBVCC Board of Directors attend the work session. elf WORK SESSION NOTICE The Kenai City Council will convene in a joint work session with the Kenai Parks & Recreation Commission, Planning & Zoning Commission and KBVCC Board of Directors on Monday, March 13, 1995. The work session will be held in the Council Chambers at Kenai City Hall and will begin at 7:00 p.m. The purpose of the work session is to discuss the following: PROTECTION OF SAND DUNES POLICING AND PREPARATION OF PARK AND BEACH FACILITIES SANITATION OF CITY PARKS The public is invited to attend and participate. Carol L. Freas City Clerk DATED: March 7, 1995 Publish: March 10, 1995 Community News: March 13, 1995 Kenai City Council Joint Work Session Monday, March 13, 1995 7:00 p.m. Kenai Council Chambers Item 1: Notice of Work Session Item 2: Spruce Street Beach Photographs Item 3: Parks and Recreation Information a. Five-year Projection b. Restroom Grant Information Item 4: Budget Information a. Parks and Rec b. Public Works c. Police CITY OF KEI i It 210 FIDALGO AVE., SUITE 200 KENAI, ALASKA 99611-7794 TELEPHONE 907-283-7535 FAX 907-283-3014 AF1..�oaq MEMORANDUM 111110 1"2 TO: Tom Manninen, City Manager DEPARTMENT HEADS Kim Booth, KBVCC Executive Director FROM: Carol L. Freas, City Cle k City of Kenai DATE: March 7, 1995 RE: MARCH 13, 1995 WORK SESSION At their meeting of March 1, 1995, the Kenai City Council set a work session for March 13, 1995 (notice is attached). The work session was set to discuss PROTECTION OF SAND DUNES POLICING AND PREPARATION OF PARK AND BEACH FACILITIES SANITATION OF CITY PARKS In order for Council to review information you may have in regard to these subjects prior to the work session, please forward it to me by NOON, Thursday, March 9, 1995 for dissemination to Council. Thanking you in advance for your attention and cooperation. clf CITY OF KENAI It GdCapdcd 4,4&44a It 210 FIDALGO AVE., SUITE 200 KENAI, ALASKA 99611-7794 TELEPHONE 907-283-7535 FAX 907-283-3014 Cky MEMORANDUM III 1s 1"2 TO: Planning & Zoning Commission Members Parks & Recreation Commission Members KBVCC Board of Directors FROM: Carol L. Freas, City Clerk City of Kenai DATE: March 7, 1995 RE: MARCH 13, 1995 WORK SESSION At their meeting of March 1, 1995, the Kenai City Council set a work session for March 13, 1995 (notice is attached). The work session was set to discuss PROTECTION OF SAND DUNES POLICING AND PREPARATION OF PARK AND BEACH FACILITIES SANITATION OF CITY PARKS Council requested members of the Parks & Recreation Commission, Planning & Zoning Commission and KBVCC Board of Directors attend the work session. clf WORK SESSION NOTICE The Kenai City Council will convene in a joint work session with the Kenai Parks & Recreation Commission, Planning & Zoning Commission and KBVCC Board of Directors on Monday, March 13, 1995. The work session will be held in the Council Chambers at Kenai City Hall and will begin at 7:00 p.m. The purpose of the work session is to discuss the following: PROTECTION OF SAND DUNES POLICING AND PREPARATION OF PARK AND BEACH FACILITIES SANITATION OF CITY PARKS The public is invited to attend and participate. Carol L. Freas City Clerk DATED: March 7, 1995 Publish: March 10, 1995 Community News: March 13, 1995 v i I Vr I �' �— — � � _ — � .a'� �,�� ,.�+�.....�pw. i �� •��• � .� �f �. ems_+ ..�- _/��' ":® ��r,�.. 1 s i r � � 1 a ilow WM5 ,.� w� tom+►_ =^� i �.�-�� i � � / jj , ' � � ` � I � ,` � � ` ' ! � ,P �� � ��. ?a �, 10 /y, 0 CITY OF KEf It cd eaniW 4.1z 210 FIDALGO AVE., SUITE 200 KENAI, ALASKA 99611-779-1 TELEPHONE 907-283-7535 FAX 907-283-3014 !-4*L v CITY OF KENAI PARKS & RECREATION CAPITAI, EXPENDITURES EXCEEDING FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS (5 YEAR PROJECTION) NEAR DEPT. DESCRIPTION EST. COST 1995 - 1996 PARKS Used 1/2 ton Pickup - to replace $125000 Ford auctioned in 1994 (may be able to acquire through a Departmental transfer). PARKS Riding Mower - 20 H.P. with 54" 9,000 mowing deck. , PARKS Restroom - install © Softball Greenstrip. 40,000 PARKS Restroom - Replace existing restroom @ 30,000 Cumunghain Park. 17,gkAed t PARKS Playground Equip. - replacement for (22,000 existing equip. @ Softball Greenstrip. Z,,�v Gow Y&wn PARKS Porta-Path - required for ADA play- 6,500 oe-r4v PE ground access. 1996 - 1997 PARKS Utility Tractor (to replace 1981 Kubota 20,000 tractor). PARKS Riding Mower - 20 H.P. (to replace 9,000 1986 Kubota riding mower). PARKS Restrooms - Replace existing restroolns 30,000 Q Municipal Park with one new. CAPITAL EXPENDITURES CONT. YEAR DEPT. DESCRIPTION EST. COST -ZYWarEA45� PARKS Playground Equip. - replacement for 10,000 existing equip. Gov Beaver Creek. PARKS Basketball Court - Municipal Park 9,000 1997 - 1998 PARKS Riding Mower - 18 H.P. (to replace 8,000 1987 John Deere riding mower). r.�.rse PARKS Playground Equip. - replacement for 14,000 existing equip. Q Little League fields. PARKS Restroom - replace existing restroom @ 30,000 Beach. 7 PARKS Playground Equip. - Section 36. 159000 1998 - 1999 { Playground Equip. - replacement for 6,000 existing equip. © Cunningham Park. PARKS Riding Mower (to replace 1988 Honda 81,000 riding mower). PARKS Restroom - replace existing restroom @ 30,000 Beaver Creek Park. 1999 - 2000 PARKS Pickup (used) 121,000 PARKS Restroom- replace existing restoom Q 30,000 Spur Park. Oi!'&aa spz� PARKS Playground Equip. - replacement for 10,000 existing equipment @ East Kenai Park (Oiler Field). 5 Year Estimated Total = S360,500 NOTE: If Exxon Grant is approved for Cunningham Park, this would take care of' replacing the restroom there and other restroom replacements would move up one year. PARKS AND RECREATION RESTROOM UPGRADES RomTEC SST Restrooms S 16.850.00 Concrete and Forms I S2,000.00 Sitework ( S2.000.00 Toilet Paper Dispenser I S100.00 Signage I S200.00 Construction S4.850.00 Administration S 1.000.00 Shipping S3,000.00 TOTAL COST - ONE RESTR0011 $30.000.00 TOTAL COST - FIVE RESTROOMS S 150.000.00 CONTINGENCY (15rO S22.560.00 TOTAL DIRECT COSTS S172.500.00 +1517c STATE ADMINISTRATION S25.875.00 TOTAL PROJECT COSTS $198.375.00 SPONSORS SHARE $99.187.50 FEDERAL SHARE $99.187.50 y W = ( Q � Q V U _ Z �..� W oa W m!- o� Ntn Y¢ E= c ccc r3 r. cc 1Z3 a woo L6 4c Ua N W m~ W Y o �- G V k 13381S :�.IJM1S3M v s i _La L LW rLai v x m W / 1 ` 1 > I /, 11 I SST Double C� The Romtec SST Double Rest Room includes evervthing you need for a permanent. odor -free, handicap - accessible rest room building with two private toilets. Available in Three Models J Standard SST Double Rest Room (shown at right) has two separate enclosures with separate vaults and vent ,ystems. Features an attractive, durable exterior, sided with T-1 1 1 and cedar. Available roof styles are cedar shakes (shown). anodized metal or three -tab shingles. J SST Double Rest Room with Privacy Partitions (,shown above) includes all standard features, plus sturdy exterior T-1 1 1 and cedar partitions for privacy. J SST Double Rest Room with "All -Weather" Porch (shown on brochure cover) has all standard features plus a large roof extension with heavy-duty trusses for locations where added weather protection is required. SST Orig inai (�, Romtec SST Original, the first pre -fabricated outdoor rest room to incorporate the "sweet-smelling toilet" (SST) ventilation system. deshaned by the U.S. Forest Service to eliminate odors inside the building. All Romtec SSTs have this unique odor -free design. Practical - _affordable - Durable J One -Piece Cross -Linked Polyethylene Roof & Building cannot leak. Weather and temperature extremes will not affect this remarkable material. J Durable T-111 Exterior Siding, in earth tone (right) or forest green (below), is easy to keep looking new. J Super -Fast Installation. In just 1-2 days, two workers with a backhoe can install the complete building with underground vault. concrete floor and exterior slab. J Low -Cost Shipping. Six SST Originals with roofs ship on a standard -lS' enclosed or flat-bed trailer. r.�lj1j J SST Traditional &� Under its attractive exterior siding of treated T-1 11 and cedar. the SST Traditional Rest Room has the durable Romtec cross -linked polyethylene structure. Includes 750-Lallon vault and SST ventilation system. Designed to Stay Looking Great • Treated Exterior stands up to the harshest weather. • Cedar Shake or Anodized Metal Roofing. Choose the stvle that matches your area. • 200 Lb. Per Sq. Ft. Gabled Roof. Handles even the heaviest snow load. • Smooth Interior Walls and Sloped Concrete Floor make cleaning a breeze. • Handicap -Accessible: l 8" toilet riser. stainless handrails, safety -lock door handle. 3 6" steel door. • Optional "All -Weather" Porch (shown at right) for added protection and comfort in all weather conditions. SST Sandstone The tough exterior of the SST Sandstone Rest Room will not fade or discolor in even the harshest conditions. It's at its best wherever a textured stucco exterior is required. Neither sun nor rain can damage the outstanding appearance of this durable rest room. Many Colors & Textures to Choose From :1 Durable exterior Thorowalll Panels are available in a variety of sixteen colors and six stucco textures. Custom order the color and texture you like best. :1 Anodized Metal Roof (also available with SST Traditional and Double) keeps its luster under the harshest sun. Available in sixteen colors. The SST Sandstone Rest Room can also be roofed with optional three -tab shingles or cedar shakes. Choose the roof style and color that looks best in your area. 7 Cross -Linked Polyethylene Building Interior is equipped with standard handicap -accessible features: 18" toilet riser, stainless handrails, safety -lock door handle, 36" steel door. Includes 750-gallon vault and SST vent system. °°•r°z Here's What Makes the Romtec SST So Great! Romtec SST Vault Toilet Systems include everything you need for permanent, odor -free rest rooms in any outdoor recreation area. The Romtec SST is widely used by the U.S. Forest Service, Bureau of Land Management, National Park Service. U.S. military, and numerous state and local park and recreation agencies... wherever easily maintained, wheelchair -accessible restroomsare required. Buildings & Roofs Are Completely Preassembled. All materials are included as standard items, except the following: • Concrete & Forms C • Toilet Paper Dispensers • Signage • Construction Tools & Equipment J Optional Accessories & Replacement Parts Are Available. :1 Shipping is Low -Cost & Convenient • Six Originals per standard 48' truck. • Four Traditionals or Sandstones per truck • 2 Doubles w/o roof extensions per truck. • 1 Double w/ "All -Weather" Porch - 2/3 truck. • One building per pallet. • Vault shipped inside building. • Six Original roofs per pallet. • Two TraditionaUSandstone roofs per palle • "All -Weather" Porch packaged separately • Freight quotes available. • All shipments F.O.B. Roseburg, Oregon. SST Features A Gabled Roof. SST Double, Traditional & Sandstone available with cedar shakes, anodized metal or three -tab shingles; SST Original roof not shown. B Pressure -Treated Posts anchored in concrete slab. C 12" Diameter Black ABS Vent Pipe with black steel convection shroud SST Double has two vent pipes. Installation Is Quick & Easy • Original. Traditional & Sandstone: I - 2 workers. 2 days. • Double: 3 workers. 3-4 days. • Equipment & tools required: forklift. backhoe. standard carpentry and masonry tools. 1 � LE. J Custom Buildings Available on Order • Siding Available: Cedar, Thorowall". Stucco Panels. Painted T-1 I I (all colors). • Roofs Available: Polyethylene. Gabled Cedar Shakes. Three -Tab Shingles. Anodized Metal in a variety of colors. :1 Design Your Own Building. Use the SST vault, vent system. hardware and liner. J Romtec SST Vaults & Buildings Can Be Sold Separately Heavy -Duty kick -Proof Floor Vent (14" x 18". 1 1 1 sq. in. free area). Lexan- Windows (2) with extruded aluminum frames. K 36" Baked Enamel Steel Door (black) with stainless -steel kick plate & safety -lock handle. (SST Double doors have Lexan= windows). L 750-Gallon Cross -Linked Polyethyl- ene Vault Reinforced, one-piece design is tested to - IO0°F; good for 11,000 uses. (SST Double has two D Cross -Linked Polyethylene Building polystyrene seat & lid. vaults.) with durable siding. SST Traditional H Form Pan. Sets drainage slope of floor. M 24" Cleanout with sealed, cross - and Double cedar siding (shown), SST SST Original. Traditional and Sand -stone linked polyethylene cover. Original has forest green or earth -tone N Vent Pipe Sleeve. Fits 12" vent pipe. T-11 1 siding; SST Sandstone has use /h-3 cubic yards of concrete min.; Double uses 5-6 vards minimum). O Toilet Riser Sleeve. Fits Romtec riser. Thorowall" stucco panels. E 42" & 36" x 1'h" Stainless Handrails F Molded Back Rest G 18" Handicap Riser. White cross - linked polyethylene) with heavy-duty For Orders and Inquiries Contact: ROMTEC, NC 18240 North Bank Rd., Roseburg, OR 97470 Phone: 503-496-3541 Fax: 503-496-0803 Call today for a FREE VIDEO showing all the features and benefits, plus a complete installation of the Romtec SST Vault Toilet System. All prices F.O.B. Roseburg, Oregon. Specifications and prices subject to change without notice. All pnces subject to the terms and limitations listed on the Romtec quotation and purchase order forms. ot jAs -Ak" Al • Concrete Single & Double Restroom Structures • Matching Wood -Design Buildings • Odor -Free SST Vent Design 9 • Choice of Roofing & Exteriors • Many Floor Plans Available • Cross -Linked Polyethylene Underground Vaults • Universally Accessible ,SST 14'f104 by ROMTEC Concrete & Vinod Design Restrooms Built To Last • tROMTEC SST 0 Odor -Free 0 Pern=ent 0 UniversAy Accessible SST Aspen Concrete Double Has Two i 00"al. Crossm nked Polyethylene Vaults SST Aspen Concrete Double The SST Aspen Concrete Double Restroom kit includes everything you need for a permanent. odor free accessible double restroom building. Ships to your site by standard freight. J Dual 1000-Gal. Sealed Cross -Linked Polyethylene Vaults are completely separate and sealed from all concrete and soil. 20' x 20' Steel -Reinforced Concrete Pad provides easv- to-clean interior floor and exterior entry areas. 8" Thick Walls Are Steel -Reinforced Solid Concrete to meet current earthquake & hurricane requirements. • Dry -Stack Interlocking Blocks go up easy. Choose rustic earth -tone split -face concrete or smooth -face concrete. which you can paint any color. • Graffiti -Proof Structoglas' FRP Interiors look great. No toxic epoxy. Hard surface resists scratches. paint. & ink. :1 Proper SST Venting through walls. Not in doors. Choice of Floor Plans g STA ARD Strong 200 lb. Steel Roof with Steel, Cedar or Composition Shingle Roofing SST Aspen Concrete Single The SST Aspen Concrete Single Restroom is designed to stand the test of time. This affordable solid concrete building is available in earth -tone split -face concrete for a rustic look, or in smooth -face concrete. which you can paint any color. J Sealed Cross -Linked Polyethylene Vault is separate from all concrete and soil. Environmentally -safe, one-piece molded design eliminates odor absorption and leakage. Choice of Roofing: metal, shakes or three -tab shingles. J 8" Thick Walls Are Steel -Reinforced Solid Concrete to meet current earthquake & hurricane requirements. :1 Dry -Stack Interlocking Blocks go up easy for a great - looking building. J Graffiti -Proof Structoglas ` FRP Interior looks great. Non- porous surface resists scratches, paint. & ink. No toxic epox, . J Choice of Floor Plans: both provide wheelchair access. Extended floor plan hay - 60" diameter area for full Og wheelchair rotation. S AND D SST Aspen Single & Double Wood Design The SST Aspen Wood Design Restroom is pre -assembled for low-cost installation on the concrete pad in just one day. J Wood Frame Construction features pressure -treated posts and sill. Bolts directly to concrete pad. Steel -Reinforced Concrete Pad is easy -to -clean. • Graffiti -Proof Structoglas' FRP Interior looks great. No toxic epoxy. Hard surface resists scratches. paint. and ink. • Proper SST Venting through walls. Not in doors. :1 Available in Both Single & Double :Models J Cross -Linked Polyethylene Vault is sealed from all concrete and soil. Environmentally -safe one-piece molded design eliminates odor absorption and leakage. :1 Choice of Floor Plans. Both provide wheelchair access. Extended floor plan has 60" diameter area for full wheel- :1 Custom Exterior Siding Packages Available. SST Aspen Wood Design fits in any landscape design. Choose T- I I I (above) in your choice of color. or select the optional custom cedar exterior siding package (top right). or our tough ThorowalP stucco exterior (bottom right). available in sixteen colors and six textures. chair rotation. Tborowalr Stucco Single Double +--� 4' 141fby SST ROM20TEC Concrete &Vinod Design Restrooms Built To Last Non -Porous Structoglae Interior. Bright, Roomy,Tough. SST Aspen is Tough Inside. Stainless steel and polyethylene hardware. Structoglas' wall and ceiling surfaces handle the harshest use and abuse. Won't hold odor. Can't scratch like enoxv, 42" Stainless -Steel Toilet Choice of 3 Roof Styles All Romtec SST Aspen Restrooms are available with your choice of three attractive roofs —metal, cedar shakes and three -tab composition shingles. ❑ Sturdy Steel Roof Structure rated for 200 lb. per sq. ft. ❑ Meets Earthquake & Hurricane Codes ❑ Galvanized Rafters won't rust. ❑ Pre -Assembled Roof Panels lift in place with j a backhoe, bolt to walls. ❑ Structoglas® Ceiling stays looking new, needs no paint. Totally Accessible Design SST Aspen Restrooms Are Accessible To Everyone. Floor plans, doors and hardware meet A.D.A. requirements. ❑ All Romtec SST Rest- - ❑ • O 0 O rooms provide easy ■ wheelchair access. � • ❑ Extended Floor Plan ■ 6011 sa' has 60" diameter area for full wheelchair rotation. 0 EXTEND D • FLOOR N ❑ 18" Toilet Riser height. 88" safety -lock door handle. p ❑ . p two 42" grab bars, 36" \ Smooth door, smooth threshold. Concrete Threshold, 36" Steel / Floor & Entry Door with Safety -Lock Privacy Handle Wall • ❑� OOO GOOD Meets ALL SST Criteria Odor -Free Romtec SST Outdoor Restrooms meet ALL SST (Sweet-smelling Toilet) design criteria. D Non -Porous Vault & Interior can't soak up waste and odor. ❑ Top of Vault is NOT Building Floor. Odors can't seep in. ❑ Sealed Vent, Toilet 0— Riser & Cleanout keep odors in vault. ❑ Vent Design Flexibility. Vent installs in any wall, not in door/entry dead -air space. Environmentally-SWe Cmss- Linked Pblyethylene Vaults 750 Romtec Vaults Are Better Than Concrete. Gallon ❑ Reinforced Cross -Linked Polyethylene can't crack 92&1ft and leak like concrete. ❑ Tested to -100°F to take on the toughest conditions. ❑ One -Piece Design seals odor and waste away from concrete and soil. ❑ Vault & Pad Are Completely Separate. Odors can't seep into building. ❑ Smooth Interior & Sloped Base make cleaning easy, resist odor build up. 1000 Gallon Herels What Makes the Romtec SST Aspen So Great! Romtec SST Aspen Outdoor Restrooms include everything you need for permanent, odor- ee toilets in any location. The Romtec SST is widely used by the U.S. Forest Service, Bureau of Land Management, National Park Service. U.S. Military, and numerous State and Local park and recreation agencies... wherever easily maintained, universally accessible restrooms are needed. The SST Aspen is available in many models to meet your restroom needs: J SST Aspen Concrete buildings are delivered in kit form. After burying the supplied vault and pouring the pad, the building is assembled on site using dry -stack, interlocking concrete blocks. Choose either rustic split -face or smooth paintable block. Single and double buildings come in standard or extended floor plans. Walls are steel reinforced and filled with concrete. Steel door and kick -proof vent are installed in walls. Structoglas" FRP interior, fixtures and pre -assembled steel roof are easily attached. SST Aspen Wood Design buildings are delivered pre -assembled to your site. Just bolt the building to your concrete pad, attach the roof and install the kick -proof vent, toilet riser and vent pipe. Custom exterior designs are available. �.w :1 Buildings are Complete. All materials are included as standard items, except: concrete, forms, steel rebar, toilet paper dispenser, gender signs. Optional Accessories & Replacement Parts Available. :1 Quick, Easy Installation. • Aspen Wood Design: 2 workers, 2 days. • Aspen Single Concrete: 3 workers, 3 days. • Aspen Double Concrete: 3 workers, 4 days. • Equipment & Tools Required: forklift, backhoe, standard carpentry & masonry tools. J Shipping is Low -Cost & Convenient. • All models ship by common carrier, F.O.B. Roseburg, OR. • Freight from YV per mile. Quotes available. n n 60-1 SST ASPEN DOUBLE EXTENDED FLOOR PLAN SST Aspen Features A Choice of Roofing Steel roof & trim in choice of colors. Optional cedar shakes or three tab shingles. Galvanized steel rafters. Non -porous Structoglas-1 FRP ceiling. B Lexan Windows (2)1/4" thick C 12" Diameter Black ABS Vent Pipe (1 per vault) 0 14 SST ASPEN SINGLE CUT -AWAY VIEW G \B G Wall Construction: SST Aspen Concrete is steel -rein- forced, concrete -filled, dry -stack block. SST Wood Design is 4 3/8" wood frame with pressure - treated posts and sill. Choice of colors and exteriors. H Heavy -Duty Kick -Proof Floor Vent (111 sq. in. free area). 1 42" x 11h" Stainless Grab Bars (2 per room) J 18" Handicap Toilet Riser. White cross -linked polyethyl- ene with heavy-duty polystyrene seat & lid. K 24" Cleanout with sealed, cross -linked polyethylene cover. L 5 '/z"Thick Steel -Reinforced Concrete Slab D Privacy Wall M Cross -Linked Polyethylene Vault. Single: 750-gallon. E 36" Baked Enamel Steel Door (black) with stainless -steel Double: Two 1000-gallon. Reinforced, one-piece design is kick plate & safety -lock handle. tested to-100°F; 750 gallon good for 11,000 uses. 1000 F Non -Porous Structoglas� Interior Liner is permanent. gallon good for 14,500 uses. For Ordws and Inquiries Contact: ROMTEC, ' ��� 18240 North Bank Rd., Roseburg, OR 97470 Phone: 503-496-3541 Fax: 503-496-0803 Call today for a FREE VIDEO showing all the features and benefits, plus a complete installation of the Romtec SST Aspen Outdoor Restroom. All prices F.O.B. Roseburg, Oregon. specitications and prices subject to change without notice. All prices subject to the terms and limitations listed on the Romtec quotation and purchase order forms. 750-Gallon Underground Vault a 900000 • i a• i � 9vs•� { �I X- 1 .9.t r,�•. .. 1000-Gallon Underground Vault Design Your Own Environmentally -Safe Sweet -Smelling Toilet with Romtec Vaults & Hardware *AIL - A �:rROMTEC 1000-Gal Now there's a cross-1 fits aU rest room desig safe 1000-Gallon Undf your best choice. Fits Any Floor P The toilet riser, vent pi positioned in. a wide vane vault. Romtec's custom in face perfectly on the large the floor plan below for d: Easy Handling 8 Our most popular vault Quick installation takes ju 1 Excavation is only 8' x 8' x 4'6" deep. Vault buries directly in the grounc 2 After backfilhng and co pacting the soil, the top of tl is marked for locations of tk riser. vent pipe and cleanoui 3 Holes are cut into the tol vault with a sabre saw. The riser. vent pipe and cleanoui are attached over the holes tapping screws and plastic c 4 The vault's center colu with concrete to form a so post. A reinforced concrei over the entire vault to fora 1000-Gallon Va Patented Design U.S. N Material Black C Thickness ale" ave Dimensions Top Su Mid Poi Depth: Volume 1000 p Weight 450lbs Installation Fittings Cleanoi (include Riser A Vent Ac 12" AB; 72' 78" R,OMTEC Features & Benefits Fits Any Building Design. Custom installation adapters can be installed in a variety of locations to adapt to any new or existing rest room design. Reinforced Cross -Linked Polyethylene Structure. Center column is filled with concrete during installation to form a solid support post. ❑ Virtually Indestructible. High tensile strength. Tested to -100° F. Will not crack and leak like concrete or fiberglass. J Impervious to Chemicals. Resists etching and damage from cleaning fluids. Easy to Maintain. 24" covered sewage cleanout. Bottom of vault is sloped for easy cleaning. Smooth interior surface will not support bacterial growth. ❑ Black Color. Reduces visibility of waste inside. D Fast Delivery. In continuous production. Can be shipped from stock to any location. Order a single unit or a 14-unit truckload. J Heavy -Duty Kick -Proof Floor Vent. The best vent you can buy! A '/8" heavy-duty black steel frame and expanded mesh welded to galvanized louvers and fine mesh screen. Size: overall dimensions, 181/4" x 223/4" x 2"; fits into 141/2" x 191/8" hole. Free area: 11 I sq. in. Weight: 18 lbs. 12" ABS Vent Pipe (not shown). Your restroom design is complete with this high -density vent pipe. Can be cut to custom lengths. up to 20'. Romtec Hardware Completes Your Design Romtec manufactures a complete line of rest room hardware and accessory items. Be sure to specify Romtec when designing your own environmentally -safe sweet- smelling toilet. Hardware items are pictured below. J 24" Cleanout Adapter & Cover (left). Cover seals tightly with four stainless -steel bolts. Black cross - linked polyethylene. 24" dia. x 61/2" high. Weight: 18 lb. Vent Pipe Adapter (center). Fits snugly inside stan- dard 12" ABS pipe. Black cross -linked polyethylene. 1 V/2" O.D. x 02" high. Weight: 5 lb. J Toilet Riser Adapter (right). Fits Romtec handicap and standard toilet risers. Black cross -linked polyethylene. 201/4" x 167/s" I.D. oval x 6" high. Weight: 7 lb. J Toilet Riser With Seat & Lid. Thousands in use since 1977. Riser is white cross -linked polyethylene. Seat and lid are high -impact polystyrene. Includes stainless -steel hardware. Two sizes: 18" (handicap), 15'/4" (standard). Both available with optional stainless -steel safety bans. wo-�adon Underground Yaud Romtec's 750-Gallon Underground Fault is a great choice if you design vour rest room 1Dtlllding5 around its fixed floor plan. The toilet riser, vent pipe and cleanout fittings are molded right into the top of the vault. J I,o%% Cost. lnexPell sIye shipping (I h unit'- per truck load i. quick installation and low maintenance co <. J Molded One -Piece Design. No joints or "Cams. J Pre -Formed Fittings for t,:)ilet riser. 'gent pipe and cleanout. Ease Handling & Installation. Weighs oniv 325 lbs. Can be buried directly in the Around without an excavation liner. Reinforced Structure. Center column is tilled With concrete LIL11111g installation to form a,olid support po,t. Concrete slab extends over entire Vault., J J "ill Not Crack & Leak. One-piece ,, ault is manufactured fi-om rugged cross -linked poivethN lene. Tested to -1(X) " F. Will not crack and leak- like concrete and fiberglass. Cleaning is Easy. Pumps out quickl from the 24" covered sewage cleano Bottom of Vault is sloped for easy cleaning. Smooth interior surface will not support bacterial growth. 750-GALLON VAULT " "LOOR PLAN • SCALE: =1 PO"TEC[ Romtec Vaults Are Used & Approved By: J U.S. Forest Service J Bureau of Land Management J National Park Service J U.S. Military J U.S. Bureau of Reclamation State & Local Parks J Fish & Game Departments J Private Campgrounds J Golf Courses & Recreation Areas 750-Gallon Vault Specifications Patented Design U.S. Patent No. 4231482 Material Black, reinforced cross -limed polyethylene Dimensions Mid Point: 84" x 64" Depth: 48"-54" (bottom has 1 "/ft. slope) Volume 750 gallons (approximately 11,250 uses) Thickness 1/8" average Weight 325lbs. Pre -formed Fittings Cleanout: 24" diameter x 61/2" high (includes cross -linked polyethylene cover) Riser Stack: 201/8" x 161/2" O.D. oval x 6" high Vent Stack: 12" O.D. x 61/2" high (fits standard 12" ABS pipe) For Orders and Inquiries Contact. �0����' �� 18240 North Bank Rd., Roseburg. OR 97470 ■ Phone: 503-496-3541 Fax: 503-496-0803 Call today for a FREE VIDEO showing all the features and benefits, plus a complete installation of the Romtec SST Vault Toilet System. All prices F.O.B. Roseburg. Oregon. specifications and prices suelect to change without notice. All prices subject to the terms and limitations listed on the Romtec quotation and purchase order forms. ROMTEC SINCE 1977 Manufacturer of the SST "Sweet -Smelling Toilet" Rest Room Hardware • Handicap & Standard Toilet Risers • Urinal • Riser Safety Bars • Graffiti Repair Kit • Toilet Paper Dispensers • Handicap Handrails • Heavy -Duty Kick -Proof Vent • Toilet Cleaning Brush Romtec. Inc. supplies a complete line of high -quality hardware components tor all kinds of rest rooms. Romtec products are desiL)ned to stand up under any level of use or abuse. Thee are proven in thousands of parks and recreation facilities throughout North America. Handicap & Standard Toilet Risers Romtec Toilet Risers are designed to tit in am new or existing vault toilet building. The smooth. white cross -linked polyethylene material is easy to keep clean and stands up to any level of use or abuse. Two models are available: the 15'1;" high Standard Riker and the 18" high Handicap Riser. Both include a heavy-duty, high -impact polystyrene seat and lies with stainless -steel mounting hardware. Risers are in continuous production and can he shipped to any location via U.P.S. J Interchangeable —Easily replaces stainless -steel riser without modification. J Virtually Indestructible —Tested to resist severe abuse. Impervious to Chemicals —Resists staining. etching and damage from cleaning fluids. Will Not Support Bacteria —Made from inherently resistant material. Easily cleaned. smooth surtaces. J :Molded One -Piece Design --No joints or seams. J Tested By U.S. Forest Service —Proven in the most ngorous testing. Thousands in use since 1977. J Low Cost—[nexpensive shipping, quick installa- tion and low maintenance cost. Specifications Materials Riser: white cross -linked polyethylene Seat K Lid: white high -impact polystyrene Dimensions Handicap: 1 S" high. 5" flange "skirt'. 20'4" x 16'/," oval Standard: 15 /," high. 5" flange ",,kirt". 20'/�" x 161/," oval W'eiuht Handicap: 1-0lbs. Standard: 17lbs. Urinal Riser Safety Bars The Romtec Urinal fits in anv outdoor rest room building! Mounts securely to the wall. Made from smooth, white polyethylene for durability and ease of cleaning. Specifications Size: 10" x 16" � Weight: 2 lbs. �r Romtec riser safety bars are designed to tit any new or existing Romtec toilet user. They restrict th� opening inside the riser to 51/,". Minimizes the enm- of large objects into the vault. Specifications T��o J," stainless steel bars. 5'/ center -center. Six stainless steel rivets supplied. For Orders and Inquiries Contact: ROMTEC ' NC 18240 North Bank Rd., Roseburg, OR 97470 Phone: 503-496-3541 Fax: 503-496-0803 Call today for a FREE VIDEO showing all the features and benefits, plus a complete installation of the Romtec SST Vault Toilet System. All prices F.O.B. Roseourg. Oregon. Specifications and prices subject to change without notice. All prices subject to the terms and limitations listed on the Romtec quotation and purchase order forms. Use Romtec Hardware For The Complete Restroom. SST Graffiti Repair Kit Ev crything you need to repair Specifications scratches. gratliti. impact damage. Kit includes:.Adhesiye Caulking, gunshot holes. etc. A\ ailahle in Romtec Pofvurethane Filter K Paint. Epoxy green. hrown and traditional. Putty. Touch up Paint. and more... Toilet Paper Dispenser Designed for economy and durability. Specifications Holds two or three standard rolls in a Material Steel or Stainless Steel heavy-duty locking fixture (lock not _ Size/Weight 2-Roll: 13" x 3" / 4 lbs. included). Defies vandalism and theft. _ - 3-Roll: 1 S" x 3" / 5 lbs. Mounts easily to anv surtace. Six models available: Two or Three Roll Standard (painted). Stainless -Steel. Free-Rolhno Handicap Handrails Handicap access is more than just convenience. It's the law! Romtec handrails ttre made i*rom l'L" 11161J diameter stainless steel. Available in 24 36" � and 42" lengths to tit ariv location where handicap access is required. Each rail includes two stainless steel Ilan -es. ft. Heavy -Duty Kick -Proof Vent The best vent you can buy! This heavy-duty vent is made from (,alvanized screen and louvers sand�� iched between two lay ers 01' super -heavy /," expanded steel mc,h and a steel trame. Gloss black. Fits in plastic. %food or metal framing: concrete block or poured concrete. Toilet Cleaning Brush No longer will maintenance personnel be required to clean toilets with their faces just inches from the opening of the toilet. The Romtec toilet cleanimi brush features a 5 ft. handle so the user stands Upright vk hile scrubbing toilets and hard -to - Jean comers in restrocxns. spas and pools . The injection molded brush head pivots for superior contact with the surtaces. Bristles are densely packed polypropylene for superior scrubbing action and durability. Specifications \ ent Size 15 ;," „�/,'' x 2" outside 14 L" .x I91," inside Free Area 1I xLin. \laterial Black Painted Steel \Veight 1 S Ihs. Specifications Handle Heayv Wall Metal Tubin,_. Black Powder Coatin«. Plush Handles Brush 7". Polypropylene Hardware Stainless Steel Length/Weight 0 )" ? 5 Ihs. For Orders and Inquiries Contact: ROMTEC, �C� '' 8240 North Bank Rd., Roseburg, OR 97470 Phone: 503-496-3541 Fax: 503-496-0803 Call today for a FREE VIDEO showing all the features and benefits. plus a complete installation of the Romtec SST Vault Toilet System. All prices F Q.B. Roseburg. Oreeon. Specifications and onces s__ ect to cnange without notice. A orrces subiect to the terms and limiter ons listed on the Rc^,�.ec cuotation and eurchase order ?=s ROMTEC, INC. 18240 N. Bank Rd., Roseburg, OR 97470 (503) 496-3541 Fax (503) 496-0803 ROMTEC PRICE LIST (Revised January 1, 1995) COMPLETE SST TRADITIONAL RESTROOM FACILITIES NON -AGENCY GOV'T. AGENCY SST Original Restroom (Green or Brown) __ _ . .. .. ..._._ $ 6,585 $ 5,985 SST Traditional Restroom _ __ _ .._ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _. . _ ... 7,685 6,985 SST Sandstone Restroom _ _ _.. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 7,685 6,985 SST Traditional Double Restroom.. . __._._.18,536 16,850 SST Traditional Double Restroom w/privacy partitions _ _ _ _ .._ _._ _ . _ 19,871 18,060 SST Traditional Double Restroom w/all-weather porch & partitions __._ _ __ 21,835 19,850 SST Sandstone Double Restroom __ _ .. . _. _ ..... ........ .. 18,535 16,850 SST Sandstone Double Restroom w/privacy partitions .... __ ..... _. - .. 19,871 18,060 SST Sandstone Double Restroom w/all-weather porch & partitions .. __..... 21,835 19,850 All complete SST restroom facilities include the following: The building(s) assembled, a roof, 750 gallon vault(s), handicap toilet riser(s), handicap grab bars, vent pipe(s), sewer lid(s), wall vent and all necessary hardware. The complete restroom facilities do not include toilet paper dispenser(s), concrete forms, concrete and signage. COMPLETE SST ASPEN STYLE RESTROOM FACILITIES SST Aspen Split Face Single Restroom ... _ ... .... _ _ _ _ _ _ ... _ _ . _ _... _ . _ 7,685 6,985 SST Aspen Split Face Extended Single Restroom __ _ _... _ 8,785 7,985 SST Aspen Smooth Face Single Restroom _.. _... _ _ _ __ ........... 7,485 6,785 SST Aspen Smooth Face Extended Single Restroom ........ .... _ _ . .._...__ 8.585 7,785 SST Aspen Split Face Double Restroom _... __.... __ ....... _ ....... _.... ........ 18,535 16,850 SST Aspen Split Face Extended Double Restroom _ _... _ ..... ... ._ 20,735 18,850 SST Aspen Smooth Face Double Restroom ...... _. ... .. _ .... _........ ..... __ 18,095 16,450 SST Aspen Smooth Face Extended Double Restroom .... .... _......... _. ............. 19,940 18,450 SST Sierra Wood Single Restroom .___ . ........ .............................. .... ............. 8,785 7,985 All SST Aspen restroom facilities include the following: Prefabricated roof, 750 gallon vault (come with singles), 1000 gallon vaults (two come with doubles), structoglass liner kit, toilet riser(s), grab bars, vent pipe, kick proof vents(s), sewer lid(s), all necessary concrete blocks, alignment templates, windows, door(s), and all necessary hardware. The SST Aspen restroom facilities do not include concrete forms, concrete, rebar, 6" wire mesh or toilet paper dispensers. BUILDING ADDITIONS AND SUBTRACTIONS Single Traditional All -Weather Porch __. _ _ .. _ _ ._ _ .__ .. 1,815 1;650 Double Traditional All -Weather Porch w/partitions ............ .._... ....... __ ..... 4,240 3,855 Single Privacy Partitions _ _ __ _ __ _ ___ ... ......... __... _ 985 895 Double Privacy Partitions. _ _ .. __ _ ._ ..._ _ . _ _ 1,815 1,650 Complete Facility above without 750 gal. vault _ _ _ _ . _ . deduct 1,210 deduct 1,100 Upgrade single facility to 1,000 gallon vault.. . _.... ..... .... __ ... _ 1,045 950 Custom Exteriors and Roofs can be engineered and quoted, call for more information. UNDERGROUND VAULTS / COMPOSTER Traiiside Composter _ _ __. _ ___.. . __ _ _ .. _ . . _ 1,098 995 750 Gallon Vault (adapters molded in place).. .. ..__ _ _._ . _ _ 1,865 1,695 1,000 Gallon Vault (adapters not included) __ _...__ _ _ _._. 2,085 1,895 Adapter Kit, complete..__ __ ___._.... _ __ __. .... _ _ ....... 220 200 Cleanout Adapter w/manhole cover only _ _ _ . _ 163 148 Toilet Riser Adapter only _ _ __ _ _ _ __ .. . _ . __. ... __. _ 64 58 Vent Stack Adapter only _ _ . __ .... __ . __ _.. . . _ ... 64 58 RESTROOM ACCESSORIES Handicap Toilet Riser w/heavy duty seat and lid .. $149 '2 Roll Stainless Steel Toilet Paper Dispenser ____ 50 Standard Toilet Riser w/ heavy duty seat and lid.. 139 Free Rolling Rubber Sleeve . . .............................. 7 Handicap Toilet Riser wr/seat & lid and safety bars 244 Urinal ....... ._.....- _ _........ .. __...... ._ _ __. 38 Standard Toilet Riser w/seat & lid and safety bars 234 Cleaning Brush . . ....... ...... _ .. ......... ....... .......... 48 Heavy Duty Toilet Seat and Lid __ __ _ ._ __.. . _. 37 Graffiti Repair Kit.. - .............. .................... .. 85 Riser Safety Bars __ __ __. .....__ 85 Kick Proof Wall Vent (standard) ............... 120 42" Grab Bars _ _ _ 50 Kick Proof Wall Vent (masonry) ... .......... ....... 120 36" Grab Bars _ _. _ _. __ _ _ _ __ _ 45 Lexan Window (48" x 7")........ ............... ........... 50 24" Grab Bars ._... __. _ _ _ _ ._. 40 Lexan Window (34" x 10").._._ ...... _.. 50 "3 Roll Steel Toilet Paper dispenser _._ _ .. ..... 25 12"x20' Section, ABS Pipe ...... ......... ..._....... ......... .. 300 '3 Roll Stainless Steel Toilet Paper Dispenser ... 60 Extra Charge to Cut Pipe (per cut) .............................. 20 `2 Roll Steel Toilet Paper Dispenser.._. _- _..... _. 20 `Available in either Free Rolling or Restricted Roll ■ Government prices apply only to orders received by Romtec directly fr govemmentagencies on their purchase orders. a Non -Agency orders for SST buildings, building additions and/or underground vaults must be placed on Romtec purchase order forms. ■ All prices subject to the terms and limitations listed on the Romtec quotation and purchase order fbrms. ■ All prices are F.O.B. Roseburg, OR and are subject to change without notice. a There will be a 1 MA restocking fee on all returned Items. r Pf�l-f0 -mf, 00TN PTGN0 I w T-IA 0rP tD O I T I I N C t�I -PPO-RIOT TrtD T-tOrO 1 0 mOJa! PNN P O I O 1 I r q0 1 I I I W -ON V 0 CTC It tD N-MMM 1 0 WWW MN- - O 1 N 1 O0: T0)mTT 1 w TTT r N- m I UI I 1 t0 WW ZE I U WW OW V WMNOOWMON-NOO W NOR1 I r RItO-O ONMOOOO 10 00 I O I T Wu Omt000T01 DIDC91ANotOTTO T 1 W -- t0-r00OUI00 I N 00 1 0 1 Ul O: Z I I 1 I WQ OIAtORItOtDNmtDNN( O6 Ot 61 (R 1 t0 t0Mwm omootno o I h OP i T I — mJ NORIOOTIORIt OMMOMMNO W I m RIMMMMUIMOW 1 0 0M I T I t0 EC NmTR1UImr TtOtDPUI--OID - 1 0 lD MkcvN PN r ON I N I - 3RI 1 1 Rl rM 1 ID W N T T I T 00 1 0 I IO u I N 1- O ITI T I O Z W I 1 I f7 Z I I I I 3 t7 to O O O I O M O O I RI 1 Z w P W O I O r 0 O I N I M U I I I O Z N I m 10 T O I I Z Q P W ? I P W Y I N I c 0: m t7 N H 0] 1 �• 1 I n E I 1 I 3u OZ I w I 1 I Wtn to Prr0%A PIAMtoMM 0NP0r I -+ hPM 00r I N I h-W 0►-+t'1000 OtiNNPr tntAt00 O I O t'1mN O-0] 1 1 IA I Q 0: 1 I O3 P-+t'1Mw-IAOOOrr -0 TMW 1 t0 OMN (r)rP 1 t'I I I F NMWN=O- TUfr-P O -NT- 1 m RIr0) -m- 1- 1 0I-1 PNr h0)-OTtONN Ln TIn 1 U1 NN- TIAFI 1 IA I 0-0 -- PP--tO - NTN T 1 N 01 I Z - 1- - I N I m W O C 0. I 1 1 DUI }W I I t Q O W UI Cl) T O W IA T N RI M f-w - T r10 N-N IA I t0 I I W W Qm I I I ZO 03 r T r% CD Nr0 UI 1 0 1 1 w 1 H - N t*1m rPN m 1 ItI 1 V to O ►+ N Ln - M N N I tD I C N O 1 t0 I I I Z I I I I I H CL I OW I I E I I T.. OOOOOOOPt'1 O O O O O O- O O I m 0000 0000000 0000000000010 00 1 0 O W O O O O O O O N W O O O O O O t0 00 w 00000000000 i O 00 i O ►+(n U1r00000)C W, C; in 1 0 rm-O*RIP 00006 1 N OP 1 P /-►+ TRIOr-OrI N-T0000-TOO N V MMIM V MOOOOO I Q 0M I T Q� w0rry ON m0tO-Om-OmOTO 000NN N0M1r0NRI 1 fD ON 1 N MW NN fA tD-TON-- (TINT O 1 N T - -fDNP T 1 M 00 1 0 m Q - N l r - i T O P I T O 1 I m 1 I a C U1 W to W W M 3 N ►+ W In O ►i :. N►wiJL mwWw"I.-0 ¢ 6.4 ►� WT N M "JI-Q Z r- O 0 0 -1 0 Mu A r u J O (CI- " T O W to W to Z 0. 0 .a to z 0 i W US wZa0um UIw.5 W T W M Q ►+0_F- UI T zw N i CO I 1-O ZIIL 0:J .a O Iru \ ¢NJ► <1 Z O u\ 1- .CM-13NM1•+► c. 0 c " c M JQFU u •" u "QIn J 0_IY JEZ W JcF-UI W JGU UU WECILZ U1 W mF- W 0 U M U U Q a. W ECEC= ►mILZUIU N Q W"w \ a.4z W w" N UZ N W al WUI \ W 3d.6romaHwI"c wr-u w300 wmmE z0 - E ti a. w 3 2 N o m w u P c b m Z E E fY a: ►+ U w O - C,O . . . IL . . . . . . . . . . . IL IL NtANt U1tAU1NNNNNNtfINU1NN YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY In = 3» 333333= lfi W w N J Q �0'QD.'Q.' OCQ R'Qd'QQQ QQQ 0 J ¢ QQ Q Q cca Q Q Q J II J CQQfIQQQQQQQQQ¢QQQC C W1.,W W W W W W W W W C �� C aILA.a0.a.0.O.0_a4aaa0.alia MMMM< MMMMMM oo - o O O F- r F- I m I 1 'con I M I m I IP O Z M IL J W Z W 0 O W In J Q I— O n n vu Inminm mmm�lAmolnUl^�mPrn I N �cm P mm(')N'r('lmoo�nom t�1 1 � Q)P In1nm C ('1TO�P-�w»Q��+101AOOrmNf'1(�lm IN WN W 0- f ONWMOW WWO (71 1 Ill WIA TWW m Q . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . . W tDOMLI) WLn ^M--MOm(')U) NWWM 1 O tDIn LD PUIONrlmmoo omv v 1 O (-1P --U)v W W V --0ID PIAvm NOO V mWMWM 1 W WW W WmWNPmPOWPWW W 1 h WM lD W In 11 Z L n W3 1 I O CLU ' I X z 1 I I QW morl OOOv----oo Ovrlwov v0 1 ^ W V ODIOOWMONOW WW V vOm I o PP oU)m0 ZZ V WNPOONr OWO N('IIDU)Q1m^0 1 m ('IOOWOo_No_WM Q)PPN0M I U) NIf) 0mM0 W Q U)U)-CnMNr, W U)mP f' M0N0In00 1 (11 m1AmmN V MWMM --O V MONOO 1 m m NPP�1---- DiJ a)omtovmQ)UlU)Pin--OPIAO)U) O I m P--^pm-+Q1tOm10P-- Ol cow minm I O W It) MP 00 LQ -- V V V--NMP1MWM 0)- N---- U) I N--N^1`)PONI`-MNOm M Q)PmNN 11l NNI N W M 3W I U) M----O(n-- N m 1 0) m --N mP ^ Wm-- In(n N 1 O U) fl mm U I -- v .- N I v P -- 1 z 1 -- I .. W I I z 1 I Hz IIIV U) n IA I m NmmO MOO 1 (9 Qz o c°) 1 �� ooUi o i r IQ- m N -- I v U)O^(I'l�ln0 U Nm In In � 1 Om1 U) 01 IT -- -- I N Ul L I N 3 U OZ I I W I I Wm m01n0 0wmmOmOPWPV0WW I Q) V W O V Pm0MM0 VmWW m I m W(9 IA NO ¢ Wm vvr (m Or'--WM I U) W(n M 0MNmI'1m1DU)O mNP v I U) Pv 0--0 123 IA IA U)N NNIP W--N 0mlDPIA(nM(14 I v W V I I- m0 V P OONIA"- M W"NNOOP I -» {Am -• (110MLf)--r-WM0^t010 Cl) I m P v f*Imm OH U MW W -MT- VPOWTN--MN IN M V W V WI- mONNWMOP MIM ON NMW HZ l0 V NN-- N-+-+ Fl 1 m W v 0 M N -MNM N- N 1 M mN --W V 7 >WX W I 1 I I I I I I I (co WUI Omv V m0 WN UI I N m (') LA W Vm O OW N 1 0 W0 MM IY F- W V -- U) m m 0 W N P I V IA U) m P Q) N O v w U) In 1 0 P m m V •W LL 2m . . . zO QO Ul V m I. P)D WU) In I W v v N •- PU)m -- In N I V N-- -+W W 1 F- Om V Ill ON NW m I Pm (nPT a% N-- W 1 () (A to PU) u cn O O m m v P -+ IA N I In 0 U) N N O v ort m lir N 1 0 W N -- m ('1 to I I N I z 1S- a I i z x I I W 1 O' = I I I Ul- O O O O O O O O O O O O N O v O O O O O 1 -- O O O O O O O O O v P O O O O O O O^ I N O O O O O O OZQ W O O O O O O O O N O O O N O N O O U) O O I N O O o 0 0 0 0 0 0 P r Oo o o o o o o o 1 o 000000 HUI O^hNQ) V Ol0m000POmQ)OPC)O I UIOmmN1A000mNf'1N0 vOlAOUI 1 Q)- OPm�Om F-H O^h V vm0 mvQ1U1mPN0)tDOU)P O I m (T10^Nm0000mmmMOMWOU)U) I N v00)Omm Q> VNO--^MNPOtOPP-f,vl MTr, 0 1 M 0rl" N0 V IA0W VPNOMO0NN 1 0 M InW0v - j aWZ I`o^U)M0M --NNM t' m I m _P m P W mP v ('1Pm('1--MNW W I N PNPN0-• 1 0) v ^ mW I O-. ., O I N I IT N ) (L I I Q 1 I W U1 u z Ul W W Z S 1- H zU1J QW WWCL : n r-"a zo �z WJ3 OH WH O� H W ELMWUl III J "(L dr_ 3 M C _jma-Cz Ft3' T) F_ muJOUIQ►¢_m cn WmZCLcDUmW4 (N•1 ►W-� X Wu W W mZ0> UQLm04 W O 0 3 W Ci HQ.I-WHOH IA 3 Q >HU1 x ► I._m"OHZ Q S W I- Z0-F-H(t U W H S WI-3 ZILI.-Q:J U JI-QQmU .d WU r- .UQJ -3N�F-HU1 U) of W H •UQ VIJ • 3U1HH¢ Q > (n JG. Hn JILLz JQHU W N Q\ W W W U1 UIOJLIL W W 3HUI -1ILHD:JILLzIII z¢YUS 1-QQIYUUQILW W Q OL X>HILaMU Cr JF-QtYUUQIL4.W LQOLQHa zm \ W W W m\ wmwa.=moxmm W OH Q O Q\ W W UI \ W 3IL0-.dLXOXr W WH UIOJCL W3xmoc m(LuU _mmxr O mmmmmm Q OJL D_ W 3SmOO UIa U F-Q It mmLL If LL, 0.-1. f..H l.-� W Q Q Q Q Q Q Q 6 Q Q Q Q¢ Q Q Q Q¢ Q Q N J IL IL IL a. 0. cL IL d n. n. IL C. IL n. 0. IL 0- O. IL 0000000000000000000 U1 J W W W W W W W W W W W W tY mm w m m r 33333332333333333333 U) 0.0-ILIL(LILIL IL(LaILaAILILILILa.I14. Q = S S=_= S S=__= S S= S== S ¢ r H H H F-� r O U1InIIIU1NUiN intnU1U1U intn(1NU1U1tn O UIUI(AinInv) In n n vk m0mmm 1 In MkD(nMWU)TOOrrm0Omr0r0) 1 0 -Nv)lD -mm0WW m 0 m W m I .- m -� c 0 0 W N I r mm0-r 0)00)MWOMmOV,WON - 1 0 r M-r 0)-TN%DN POTmin I -• w w m0IAU10) 1 N -a)Na) r N- cn-- vmmmvm 0-)D I- w mOr r o w v m r- Inmomm I v U) WW WOmmm I r WWm OW wotDom-mTm O0)M W WmN1D w0wmr`m wwr m I w w I I Yil om z L i i I 0 0.0 WWI 1 Qw O 0NLn I m Omwvr mwom-oomoOm r0 1 0 min0N00T()00)-OT00In0 1 r -- wu v -InT I r -r r PQ)Nmor,c4wo o m w m0 1 T U) 0NT00WNMTr0N0M00 1 m T WQ O mT0) I N rmm -T mtDOTWmm0NN- w0 1 m mmNmU)0)m01PNNr-TTT- 1 0 W MJ W TIn0 10) 0N--rCD0MMMkD T -mN Om 1 0 MN-MMWOWWM-mNmmm I In - L¢ IT WW I N rTr T-MWTON- tD D mm 1 m O mmNT W-M W-TW V -m I U) 0) 7W N I r m-Nm-0- NT - m N I T U) U)- In - I m N O - N I r N I T r Z I m 1 I W I I 1 Z I I I :3 t!UI wO 0 1 U) W Oro 1 m CD O 0 1 T too 0 0) 0) ONm 1 0 In O O m FZ•IU 1 I a rN N I N U) wOU) I m lDr O U) I m Z¢ r0 0) 1 m v mN O 1 w N v m 0 1 W (E Ix -• r O 1 v m Ti U) - I m m -- - I W L N I N I m I Ln W I I 1- N I N 1 I 3 u I O Z I 1 1 w I I I I I I WUI Ovomin 1 - O hTWmU)T0-0)N0-00Nmm0 1 0 r-00m 0W-N00 00000 1 0 0) 1-W WMMVIn 1 W (nNNInOr00NNCri000-mr00 1 0) vTmU) OmNONN r 0 N T 0 1 N U) ¢ m . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0M M N T T M I m -W0TPO)N()InWrlNO)mrN V WLe) I v WON W -V 0 0 N M W 0 0 M I m W 1 F- 0rP0Tm I N mrr P wo m-mO-m oomwoo o D 1 m r PT0) -0NmNr CO W m-0) I U) 0 0" M 0 N M N I N 00 V Co D- MMCD0N0 r,W -T 1 m - - min PTT Pr OQ)m T 1 - N Pa U)- N m 1 w IDmN--0) m1D-T - 0) mm 1 0 O T -N - ID - T - - 1 r m - m r - N - N r Q I r I N I A C } W I 1 I I I I ¢O WUI ONOOr 1 w T Om r0) NT NO 0M I in T O w NO -0) O O 1 N N 0100)Ow i m m in O mm N0) r0 Om 1 0) m m m o+r mm 0) N 1 0 P •w W ¢w ZO A=1 0TT01N I IT N -W (4- Q1r NU) 0)ID I T r 0 N W0 O m N N I t0 P w I I- mNv)hr I U) U)In0 m- Om mP Tm I - W- m -In 0)T r m I N m ULn OH NN - 1 0 -0)N -- U)m m r I r Nr m rN O T - m I m lD ¢ o - - N I T w - 1 0 r I Z 1 0 N I N I I W I- I I I- w I I I Z X I I I O W L I I 1 UI- O O O O O l y OOCCOOOOOOMOOOOOOMOIM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 O Z o O O O O O 1 m O O O O O O O O O O U) O O O O O O m O I m 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 HUI 0000- 1(D M0 V W N M T 0) 0 M N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 W moms onov OOU)r00 U)00 I m m F-- N 0 0 m m 1 0 0)O0r mNNNOU)r-000ON-O 1 - OOONmm00)mOmmOON00 I r (cO mrOina) 10) r 0-N r 0 W v V 0 0 N N N - v - 0 M I N N OWMT OWMTNmTm T WTO I m N -W rN -mm I r TTOO N T--W-NTT- In-mm I v mown N-N W -- - I - N it m - 0) 1 U) m - N - T- N I in r d N i v N I P 1 -- N I I 7 (L I I I w m m • In U o~ Zz ` Daoui F-- W J O - . Ul �- >- CX a-0- - 7 Q ►ar w 0.NUU)) �-Lr) • OZ N IL F-00¢r•. O IL x w P •u J •3U1mU1 ¢ 7 Ui w W wOumm.L w Q 7M JQ.►+D_JwLZ W YU L Q N W >- D: (I:F- -O- Ul m JF-amuu¢D_ILw¢OL ¢❑Om m w N .. Q Q S W ZIL M-1 .5 N Q\ w wM \ w=Iw(LrMcIYGO- N •8 � Aw U 1- •UJ=)tnM <[ U)OJD_W3xwoowD.uF-QWL _ U) .d O 2 r+5 "in JD_ - JLZWQF-UI 7 O (n CYJ U JI-J¢ 0muu<10_iL¢L¢OD.ZUIU u • • • • • • • • • • • • • • . • • U w -QUI • W S \ Oww WUl \ w=W LOM0W W-¢ W • • • • w - Ul NOIJ LILW 32NOU)UF-QMMLL Ul F- rrH- F- f- F- -F- F- F-I-F-F-F-F-F- U7 il �ZOIu:z zzzzzzZZZ I 00000000000000000 d ¢ m L L O O U u u U u u U U u u u U u U U u u O Q lL ZZZZ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ U_ U_ U) ❑ O O O O>» 3>> O O O O 3 O - W W W W W Ul LLLLL UI .1.1 (r 0: IX it Q -1 -i-�-L-L -L— Q - «+ --- ¢ 0000000000000000000 ¢ " Z Z Z Z== Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z `¢ `¢ „J Ji U. U. IL W (L 0 u u u u u u u u u u u u u u u u u u u ¢¢¢¢ Q¢¢¢¢¢¢¢¢¢¢ . CL O o f' F- 1- n 1) pat I f'1 mmnn�p�t�1�Om1DnTPOUlnf�lmf�ml�ltAlGmQ1 1 - 01onNOMIXIMN1A[* MOOm-m (TIP z C 1 a . . . . . .U. rmNhr-Pmt'. . . .. . . . '. . . 1 m NOmt�OI. . . . . .O . -•t. . . -. O W I m C')0ht00M(y)-M-PmPOt'!U)-M00TONf+IO 1- wm ONNn P-•IAww IMAM ooM OM O0 I N 101Amt'11Dh91m111 0000tOQIt'I0P0rl0rl0nm I w �D10mt'Ih�OI')nlnUln�OmtDmmm ml0 WW I O Da I 1 �1 Z r 1 1 M W 3 I I 7 Cl. U I I XZ I 1 W W I I OW I- -NMMWm-NO PmnmNPO PMOONPOmO 1 P U)m0 mTwooU)wfr NOU)wM_OmO WU I m 1 m O CD V f mM D000>10111 00Nr%(9(v)0nm W Q I r P--mhnmlDNif) tO('1I0-N- W- NMMNm -P 1 n NT-0W0mMWf%r ClNh M-m0hm D1J 1- OMPI W 0mOMNW-N-mOONW I N-NN NO I r -mU)-tom Nlrlf')hPfr)t0 h m 0-Ohr =Q I N MOm-M OMVrP r%NmMNnwW-mr(*1mW 1 M COWOmmNrrNOW_ mPOPN :)M 1 - Pn1AmN tD MVO-(,) U)M w -(DM Pm 1 O U)mf')U) NNWWM W P N- W Z 1 N f0�1 N M - _ P- - 1 N N- m m - - w I I Z I 1 3 OUI 1 N m0 000 tD U)N -O 1 N tD 0m0 U) ZW I r -O 000 r m%Dm0 1 M m O -m Na Z 1 0 PO MNO m mrtDM 1 U) O ONtD m ZQ 1 m m0 mmN M 0MtDCr) I m M (D%DO N Q� 1 O PPI V W0r- 1 U) IA POP N L I N N - N I (*) I- 3 I I 3 U I I OZ I I W I I I I WUI I- mmNNP-mmOW-OnMW OPhOPmmm00 I m U)-0-t0PO01AP000U)omm WO I-W I N nP)mrl'101A00P-WMOWN-NONIAN-n0 1 0 O-WN-MOOOOmmOmNN W mN q3 I r(*ImmU)mN(VOIPPmMIAmNinN0N-OPP-T 1 0 NOmmTU)PPt')l0mmmm4O- f'1P I H I P tD-(r!0)U)hhmml'1h0f�0-OP-Ot'It0-f'ItDh 1 0 tDOr-NV W W W-mmmNmNP mn O►. I tD m-IANIANh TMOmr-MmmmPWNOWM-m I f'1 rPtr)tDN1APtOmmmmNtDmOr Pm HO 1 0 mh mNM h P O W N-P N-MM NMWNINn I m M-O mNU)-N P--O-O f' Mn -l'1 I zyJ i M NNMN N MV- •• - 1 m P?1')- N TV- 1•• O Q a 1 1 Z wx I 1 Lai11) 0 }W I I Q O WU1 I N MintD m U) TMMONOOWWON-rm- 1 M OMMOW- mrf+ ulmo Omo hh :Ix F_w I m M0%- P 0koM-ONPf7f'f Om0 -N 1Z0 03 1 (n mP0 t*I U) IAmmfit'IOOhci tci4 -PtD 1 m Nm,Oc l ) NU)m-('ImrUlO m- IW I I- I U) V o- P O t MWM Now-WTO W Nm 1 N PmPmmm rm(T)—mtDmtO0 Nm :0 Ln 0" 1 r mlDU) P m-- W m U)tD t'ImtDM P 1 40 OtDONN- -- ONOWVM -m Q i.Z 1 M NNN M TN - - - I CD I IT mU)l*1P M U)N t'1 I I I F d I I Z X I I O W I I in- IT O O O O O O O O O O O N N O O O m O O O O r O O O zo IN o 000000000001*)OOOU)000ONoo O ►.tn I ^ mo-U)t00-OtD 6tir 000(7r C; 0' 0'tD H►r 1 W WM-WWf,- W W WOmNPONOtDmOOrPOU)- Q� I m N- PPmt*1 r mmmtDmU) O-U)0] ^tDmmtD(') ON ►4W IN PP IAOU) I* VMNMNO—mmr m (r)-NP mf7 cr d� 1 IA NNW)T%D P PmN M N- -P O I � I (_ I IL I Q P O O O O O O O O O O r m O 0 0 0 m 0 0 0 rn o0000000001')(*tOrOmO0o0 . .................... m U) OOI)t ko,NNOPtii r, Mw1%oot') t0 r-OM ImNPNOmMWOOMM W OOU) N OOPU)OmNPNmtDU)MWMOU)NW- tD m0 MIAMr Pm -ON h-ONIflW -O t.0 Mt0NN m OWN - ••••• N In 0 Ln w W UI Z f- • ►+ 0_ Z O Z Z UI J G) W 3 U) O O ►+ a W W 0. N Z Z n .J } 0:0_UIW U) «+1-0Z ¢ ►+ r"CL ZO " «+ ►r 0. H J • I- Q Z ►+ S O W J 3 In O ►+ m T (_ O I-3C7 JON Q I-•+mU) Or } MCLMw J 0) U) W inW N Z IL O O U Z N W .d W - Q 1-QZ.t) J - W } ZQ 0: U) N 0. I`3L7JONQF-«+ U) ►+ Q Q O S W F- O Z IL I- I- O: J •d U) W W W Z O_ O O U M w uw ^) 3 (X GW u \ UQInJ •7N0=F-"o4c O W } 0_ 0: ND_HU1�-10►+Z►+ p u ¢ ► 5" c in J D_ ►+ M J W E Z W Z J Q r- U S u - ¢ Q S W O Z tL I.- .. � W JI-J QOUD:UU QD.LLWZC0Z ¢0► "CLZMU W M 0 W u r U QU)J •3WO:N► UI Q \ OW W"WUI \ W3WlL4r :OD:00:HW W•`•Q UI ¢ -45"tn JIL"M JwrzwzJ W NO=JrWIL W3xw000:U1D.U1-QCl. MMMrr J H J aQMuu0D.Ii WLQOEQ3► "_ M w Q\ O W W Ww \ W3Wa4r0:OD:0MI. S O ` • ` - ` - - - O U)OxJLa.W 3 xinOOixUIauPQO_S Li W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W lL LA u u U u U u u u u u U U u U u u u u u u u U u u U' ►•. �+ .+ a. w rr .r .•r . ►+ ..� �•�. ►+ ++ ►+ ►+ �-..•n ►+ .+ .•+ ►+ .•+ rr .•+ U) W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W w J JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ r Q 000000000000000000000000 O Q �+••�►+►+r.fry.►+«+..r+.,ar«...+n•�►r�.....+ U) 0.0.0_0_a0.a0.a.IIci.0.0_0_O.IIIa.0.aa0_0. n LiLLLL W LL.IA. LLti1LLj. LA. IA. 4.Lr W LL.LL.LL.LLLi In En vx MON m-mvnvmmvom-- 1 0 0 0 N 0 0 1 0 1 mm?( mr-movnm NNn 1 - •ar C m-N - O- mmt MwVNm- 1 m NOm-O 1 N WNOWNGMON-N N-•P 1 N M 00 q W ('INN N MInMCD W f'1- kD -PP 1 N 100mNO I m ta wV)-NPUl0M0- NM - I N �0 N10 Rz ' (D- to tDn1D-NPMmn-n 11D N010m0 1 In 1DtaWTNin%a0-mm mNto I N to %at0 W W •- I - - 1 1 J a' R m I I 1 win 1 Wm I 1 I :3 a U 1 I 1 X Z I 1 I W W f I I a mO-wmOOPmmOmf%w000 1 In N O 1 m 0kD000nO Wnm0mPO I m In0mIn0 W U 00001000Mrl N-ONO000 1 N N Nun I P 0P.0M0 O- n TTOMmo I N r%0W, WQ Nvom- mmmmNPmNmwoo I m N n0 I m OInm00N0 1 N ONNOm Mj T- I mNmNmr010P NmNnP I W N m0 1 0 0- O W NNN W OMOm010 1 O -mmN- LQ mIn I MN omww?NnmN P I N m 0 r) I N O -NtD N- mm - - PP O 1 Q m710m1D 3 Im T N - - 1 ID I W m W N - m - U m I- fri (•) Z I w z 3 (3 En O P000 1 P Pt00 1 0 O O 1 0 z W O W O In n I 1D 1D W In I m 0 m I m a N tDnnm I N l0P- I N O In I N ZQ n In -N In 1 0 t0mm I P O P I P 7 cm - NO -- I N %aV) 1 0 O Ot 1 01 r Rl N - 1- m N - mI L I N I N i 3 u I oz I w t Wm NO - min OWNOOI'%MOO 0 1 m M0rl00 1 - OPOOOOOOPnO - too 1 W In Nn S r W - O O m P 0 W N N m m N N 0 O 1 m N M N 0 0 1 P O N O N O M M O P n 0 O W O I m N P m d R3 mnPnN (rinm0 I N ONNNmOtDONIrftD -NO 1 m O Pn 1 r NNMmm NO0Nmn-10 JD 1 n NM01V)0 1- 0MNNN1%N0MTkD mmm 1 N N -(n !t OM PP 0-Nml'1t01'I(D0 M 1 - NMV)T0 1 tD ONMP Nmw--O 0 0 W I P W -W al f R P1') - f'1 N 1 O -mmwo 1 M W P MN m-- 1 In 1D -(*1 I (9 1 f) 1'1-' N I N- N N 1 m N Z W I I m3Ln >-w 1 1 1 1 z a 0 wW N 0 wfNw0m0w 1 O WNm0 1 N 0m0n O(Dm - I t0 In -P yw I w w t0 PtDMONOM 1 P wWTLo I m 00V)w t00NN N 1 O N mm :nz0 Q3 w a; rt 0('1 1 m PtOmm 1 C;OmtOT n0P m - 1 ('1 0� Olm W W 1 0.-- Ol 0 W W-nMV I N mtDmv I N ONrn r%0m1D P I In - M0 ZL9In OJ-+ O - M- N P 1 N -N M 1 0 O 0 m P I N W -P Q r A P I In P- I N N N I Z I I ^' I -• .. x w I I z z x 1 1 O W I ' X W In - 000 O O O O O m O O O m O O O I m O O P O O 1 P O O O O o 0 0 0 0 o m O 0 0 0 1 m 00000 LL Z A 000 O O O O O P O O O m O n o I m 0 0- 1n 0 1 tD O O O O O O O O O O P O m O O I m 00000 O ON W001 0101n00-000N000 1 N 00n-0 1 to 0mNtn1n00000P0N00 1 N -Nr-W0t rH NOIN WMMOOmOOm-Or w 1 M 0 0 w 0 0 1 - OPN P 00000-1 OMOn I N MtD00- z C:> CD 0) 0 N N M 0 mNmU170m01 1 W w0N0O 1 P oM n--00MOON-00rN I m PPNIn 1D W ►"W mkv) N In--(Vl N?N I U) -00 O In 1 N P - N-WN P-N I f' Inm-U1 L tt In I m nN -N 1 0 N P N- W a-- r O (n a 0 r C a z z a C z ►" z •• a to En ." a Z ►+ W In G �D W C C 3d(n rr"m L7Q Lw En Zr Inln1"L WwLn In3:> mtn \ W W" Z O r" Z r W ce Q In to • o ►+ .a ►+ aJ 0 " mh" . ".a MCC w zAL .a •"a 0r0-0 Q QIiJ U a'U \ U • 3UIDL 1- In w ►+ ra rCZ.ar- W0 (Ltn Co-deW ►"W ILLZW ZUUS W m C W 31n Q r- - (L(X w►" I•) JAUIxULA. W O LQ=�►"InUlu - ►" Q N WU1 MMDUMM 04 O 0IL ML O C W►" W \ IL ad' 0M0Cl "►4 C - XW U W M Q N4.+O�+Z WZLLIL300aU1-CaLLL CD f"UI QO 2• W Zal--Ct 3 • 3 3 JQRm U 0 CWU \ rJU • 3U lz�-- U �d'd'�OY U • • • • • • • • U QW W W!n 41:1►"ctn Ja"WEZWZCU W rrrf-r W WWWW W WW W W W W WWW W W mjrCLW JCQUXUUCIL W CrC:> "(LW N UUUUU N »»»»»»»> In 1 W CWWMW N\ W mWmo Qm W a" MMM/I M M.. M M Y"MMMM • r miEwa.w3xmaILUrQamL X V11nMMM 0'_ l-rr/'-r1-1-►-rF m }}}} } .Q O xxmmm o QCCQaaaQCQaaaaa O wwwww i C LL. 00000 U J J J J J J J J -1J J J J J J LL z z z Z Z YYYYYYYYY YYYYYYYY r1-rrr NNInUI tl1U1NN NllINNNUIU] x0:m(x 0� ��a•a•�Oi O: a' Q��O: IY a' lY a' O: m MM►"►oM lIl ►"►"MMMM•"Man r"an M"n•.M ►" In 00000 ' W W WW W W W W W W W W W W W W W W J In in inU11n J u Ls L3 o L3 Ls c3 L2 L3 c3 0 L3 (3 ca 0 J F"1"rrr ] r JJJJ JJ-1-iJJJUJJJJJ Q 0.4*.4. "«" Q W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W Q Q Q¢ Q Q U1 U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U H » »> r J .1 J J J J J J J J J J J J J O �} o o r En r r loners groundwater below a critical level, the stabilizing plants will die. On the other hand, if by the building of groins or any other tangential construction the littoral drift is arrested, the source of sand to sup- plement the dunes will be denied. The final point has already been mentioned —that this critical vegetation, the dune grass, is most vulnerable to trampling. We now have a code of basic prohibitions for human use. Thou shalt not walk on the dune I grasmes. Thou shalt not lower groundwater 4 below the critical level. Thou shalt not inter- rupt littoral drift. These proscriptions will merely ensure the perpetuation of a natural sandbar and its native vegetation and expres- von. This will merely sustain a public re- source. We must now consider the matter of the people who would like to develop this resource. What can we say to them? Perhaps the most reasonable approach would be to investigate the tolerance or intolerance of the various environments to human use in T.."al and to some particular uses. The first zone is the beach and, fortunately for us all, it a astonishingly tolerant. It is cleaned by t*e tides twice a day of the debris that men Katie, n even the most vulgar residues acl-eve a beauty when handled by the sea. Tie creatures that live in this area do so mostly in the sand and th5lS-escape_struc ran from humans. So Le beach is tolerant to all the happiest of uses —swimming and c-icking, the making of sand castles, fish-' r-? and sunbathing. ITie next zone, the primary dune, is abso- �,, , 1 I,.Wy different: it is absolutely intolerant. It cs^not stand any trampling. It must be t r/ if trohibited to use. If it is to be crossed, and crx� it must be to reach the beach, then t1,is nest be accomplished by bridges. More- over, if the dune is to offer defense against scams and floods, then it must not be broached. As a consequence no development ,Id be permitted on the primary dune, The trough is much more tolerant; develop- ment can occur here. It is of course, more protected than the dune —from storm, wind and blowing sand. The problem here is groundwater. The vegetation that occupies this zone exists only because of the relative abundance of fresh water. Should this water level be lowered the plants would die. This could happen through withdrawals from wells, but it could also result from roofs and paving that divert runoff into drains and piped waste -water systems. The inland dune is the second line of defense and is as vulnerable as the primary dune. It too is intolerant and should not be devel- oped. The backdune, however, reveals a more permissive location and this is perhaps the most suitable environment on the sand- bar for man. Normally this supriorts woody vegetation —red cedar and pine. The shade of these trees is a welcome relief from the blinding light, glare and heat that char- acterize the other zones. Fresh water is more abundant in this environment than any other --an important for development. The final zone is the bay. 1' is not well known that estuarine md hayshore environ- ments are among the most productive in the world, exceeding those hetr«rknown ex- amples of rice pa�',I� �n�� ;��gaic�+ne farms. It is in these nutr that the infantile stage of most of tii,, important fish takes place and ffvv,�ii 'hc -lost valu- able shellfish. Thee ott , the hr;!-,cdiny ground: and homes of the -ost inujorr,int In our society it would rippear that there is an implicit law that r�njoim all disposers of rubbish and garbaftn, all those who would gratify their heart's desire by filling land, to choose marshes and hayshores for their fulfillment. This reveals o profound ig- norance of the values of nature; the marshes and bays are among the most productive areas that we have. Thou shalt not fill or dump here. ,no walking should be allowed and it should 1 not be breached at any point. ____; It takes only the shortest of reflection to realize that those environments port aquatic and semi -aquatic ve normally occupied by water or it. Plants reveal variety in ban( distance from the water's edg this, it is not difficult to con( environment is owned by water , not. If, in disregard of this princ grass flats on either side of the I filled, it is clear that the capacit to contain water will be redu( assume that winter storms an( will continue with their normal but the water storage capacity c will have been diminished. Th, then occupy that area which inevitably covering the prior a cupied by building. Moreover, ii of filling and building it is likely will tend to fill the lagoon, ma shallow and reducing its storm- ity. This will lead to a larger built-up land being inundated i Thus we can say: if you wish t tion that is likely to be floode( means fill in the marsh on eith bay and build there. If you wi certainty of this eventuality, v the lagoon with sediments. Ir these expectations you will assurance of the least stable possible. Consistency is not virtue, but it is the: only one in logue. Sure1v this is not the w; us rather sav that marshes wer be filled, t!iey constitute a pre! a real dander to human habitati Development should not occt rowest sections of the sandb where breaching is most like search for a suitable environ we have disclosed a most fortu The width of a dune tends to of its height and the angle of bilized sand; therefore the secondary dunes do not occur but the flatter backdune area widest of all the components ;u SECONDARY DUNE BACKDUNE BAYSHORE BAY ,!,y INTOLERANT ";!PANT No passage, breaching or building •+c'k3•hn rn� TOLERANT Most suitable for development d then' dwelopment is permitted on the dune. sive recreational use, but without building. pproaches to it would be by bridges across nd sea' We pow have the broad outlines of an eco-tA the dunes, which would be prohibited to 3 matte` IoTul analysis and a planning prescriptionuse. Limited development would be per - ndwate ' bwd upon this understanding. A spinal road mitted in the trough, determined by ground- but tht r as wit could constitute a barrier dune and be water withdrawals and the effect upon Noted in the backdune area. It could vegetation. A positive policy would suggest ,n. The co^tain all utilities, water, sewer, telephone accelerating the stabilizing processes, both of tribute and electricity and would be the guardian dune formation and of vegetative growth. To er fror Mense against backflooding. At the widest do this the appropriate vegetation for the .ctor tc po'"ts of the backdune, settlement could be associations would be planted. Particular )roblem- able fa: Mxated in communities. Development would attention would be given to marram grasses loymen" elr be excluded from the vulnerable, narrow on dunes and to planting red cedars and lute actions of the sandbar. The bayshore pines on the backdune. r id a sear wov+d_-i�nrinci be I inviolate. The befENr y : beach would be available for the most inten I In the Netherlands, confronted with a sim- j \o Qac k I. INTOLERANT TOLERC No filling Intensive recreF ilar situation, it became a matter of nati resolve to reclaim land from the sea a positive policy was developed towards end. If this were applied to the New JE Shore it would involve the creatioi continuous dikes and dunes facing the There would be locks at these Iota where the lagoon was connected to ocean. Fresh -water flow from the land into the bay would be regulated as v% incursions of salt water from the ocean. straints would be exercised to mai dunes and dikes, groundwater withdr and native vegetation. Sadly, in New Jersey no such planning