HomeMy WebLinkAbout1994-07-20 Council Minutes. AGENDA
KENAI CITY COUNCIL - REGULAR MEETING
JULY 20, 1994
7t00 V.N.
KUM CITY COUNCIL CH!l XR8
p LM - ADJUSTMENT 1=119 - Appeal of Marion Nelson
1. Pledge of Allegiance
2. Roll Call
3. Agenda Approval
4. Consent Agenda
*All items listed with an asterisk (*) are considered
to be routine and non -controversial by the Council
and will be approved by one motion. Theke will be no
separate discussion of these items unless a Council
Member so requests, in which case the item will be
removed from the Consent Agenda and considered in its
normal sequence on the agenda as part of the General
orders.
+E, pCHgQ, BD FALIg cQW= (10 Minutes)
C. PUHIIC 8�=�TaB
1. Ordinance N0. 1599-94.- Increasing Estimated Revenues
and Appropriations by $81,584:in the,Airport Front
end Loader Capital Project Fund.
2. Ordinance No..1600-94 - Increasing.Estimated Revenues
and Appropriations by $210,000 in a New Capital
Project Fund Entitled 'Airport Sander/Plow Truck.u.
3. ResolutiOn No. 94-44 - Awarding the aid for a One,
Ton Truck for the Water &.Sewer Department to
Craycroft Chrysler for the Total. Amount of $28#529100
Which Includes the Basic Bid of $25,889.00 Plus a
Truck Plow of $2'640.00.,
4. Resolution No. 94-45 - Transferring $9,588 in the
Water and Sewer.Fund to'Add a Plow and Crane to the
Pickup Truck which is Appropriated in the FY95
Budget.
D. CQMMI8820N/CsQ,,TTS14� ORT
1. Council on,Aging
2. Airport Commission
•
6
•
3. Harbor Commission
4. Library Commission
5. Parks & Recreation Commission
6. Planning & Zoning Commission
7. Miscellaneous Commissions and Committees
S. 11IMMES
1. *Regular Meeting of July 6, 1994.
1. Discussion - Acquisition of City Property for Habitat
for Humanity.
i. Bills to be Paid, Bills to be Ratified.
2. Purchase Orders Exceeding $1,000
3. *ordinance No. 1601-94 - Prohibiting the parking or
operating of motor vehicles in any state or city
maintained road right-of-way which has been
landscaped, seeded or improved in a manner not
intended for vehicular traffic.
4. Approval - Change Order No. 3, Thompson Park Water &
Sewer Project/Poster Construction - $795.380
5. Discussion - Schedule Board of Adjustment Hearing -
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission denial of
application for variance on Lot 1, Block 3, VIP Park
Hstates, regarding requirement of 40,000 square foot
minimum lot size.
6. Discussion - Proposed construction of permanent KPB
transfer site at Redoubt landfill location.
l._•.t _ _J ! '. A • I. _L .77777
1.
Mayor
2.
City Manager
3.
Attorney
4.
City Clerk
5.
Finance Director
6.
Public Works Director
7.
Airport Manager
-2-
I.
MAYOR18 REPORT
JULY 20# 1994 COUNCIL MEETING
CKWORB
REMOVE:
C-2 Ordinance No. 1600-94: Grant not yet received.
ADD t
16
H-2(b) Approval of purchase order fox marketing video.
H-7 Discussion - Acquisition of Cheater Cone property
(see documents now at Information item A).
I-4 Telephone poll for approval of purchase order to
Statewide Petroleum to replace gasoline fuel pump
for the city dock for $1,540.
Add Information Umst
10. Alaska Journal of Commerce article, 7/18/94,
Ki-dre-IS-Seeks u oOre-Project
11. 7/11/94 Dorothy McCard'letter to Mayor Williams
regarding Russian Orthodox Church paving project.
12. 7/8/94 Laura Measles to 4th of July parade
participants.
13. 7/5/94 Valerie Edmundson letter to Mayor Williams/
Council regarding Cityls donation toward July 4th
celebration.
14. 7/13/94 Becky Gay letter to Mayor Williams
regarding Resource Development Council membership.
ADD AS
•. Executive Session.
77slij.: !�
.BROWN
WILLIAMB
WILLIAMB
CLERIC
MA�I�TIN�1
IIiLLIAMB '
WILLIAMS
WILLIAM0
WILLIAMB
•.
• i� . : J
0:\WPSI\MINUTESUGENDA\NRY6R.RPT
KENAI CITY COUNCIL REOMM MEETING
JOLY 20, 1994
7100 PeNo
KENAI CITY COUNCIL CMAK NRB
MAYOR JOHN J. WILLIAMBt PRXBIDIMO
Mayor Williams called the meeting to order at approximately
7:04 p.m. in the Council Chambers in Kenai City Hall..
A-11 PLED-01 OF ALLLGXUQI
Mayor Williams led those assembled in the Pledge of Allegiance.
A-2.
ROLL CALL
Roll was taken by the City Clerk. Present were: Measles,
Bannock, Smalley, Williams and Bookey. Monfor arrived at
approximately 7:15. Absent was Swarner (on vacation).
A-3.
Mayor Williams asked to change the agenda as follows:
REMOVE: C-2 Ordinance No. 1600-94: Grant.not yet received.
ADM: H-2(b) Approval of purchase order for marketing
video.
H-7 Disouseion - Acquisition of Chester Cone
property.
1-4 Telephone poll for approval of purchase order to
Statewide Petroleum to replace gasoline fuel
pump for the city dock for- $1, 540.
Add Information Items:
10. Alaska Journal of Commerce article, 7/18/94,
ee
11. 7/11/94 Dorothy McCard letter to Mayor Williams
regarding Russian Orthodox Church paving
project.
12. 7/8/94 Laura Measles to 4th of truly parade
participants.
13. 7/5/94 Valerie Edmundson letter to Mayor
• Williams/Council regarding City's donation
toward July 4th celebration.
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 2
14. 7/13/94 Becky Gay letter to Mayor Williams
regarding Resource Development Council
membership.
MOTION:
Councilmember Smalley MOVED for approval of the consent agenda
as presented and requested UNANIMOUS CONSENT, Councilmember.
Bannock SECONDED the motion. There were no objections. 80
ORDERED.
A-3., CONSEIPI' AGENDA
There were no changes to the consent agenda. (Mayor Williams
stated that during the Mayor's Report he would ask for an
executive session.)
(No Motion or Action taken.)
Mayor Williams was reminded of the Board of Adjustment hearing
scheduled for this evening. He asked for a temporary
adjournment of the Council meeting.
MOTION:
Councilmember Measles MOVED for a temporary adjournment.
Councilmember Smalley SECONDED the motion. No objections., SO
ORDERED.
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT: 7s10 p.m.
BACK TO ORDERS 7s32 p.ae
ITEN e_s SCHEDULED PUBLIC_COF
None.
�T� BUH_LZC �7,�RINOS
C-1. Ordinance No. 1399-94 - Incsreasing Estimated Revenuers
and Appropriations by $81,584 in the Airport Front-
end Loader Capital Project Fund.
MOTION:
i member Smalls MOVED for adoption of Ordinance No. 1599-
Counc 1 y p
94 and Councilmember Measles SECONDED the motion.
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 3
There were no public comments.
VOTES
Measles: Yes Williams: Yes Swarn4
Bannock: Yes Bookey: Yes M0nf03
Smalley: Yes
NOTION PABSED ONANIMOUSLY.
0-2, Ordinance No. 1600-94 - Deleted from agenda.
C-3. ROAOlutiOu No. 94-44 - Awarding the Bid for a One
Ton Truck for the Water & Sewer Department to
Craycroft Chrysler for the Total Amount of $28,529.00
Which Includes the Basic Bid of $25,889.00 Plus a
Truck Plow of $2,640.00.
NOTION:
Councilmember Smalley MOVED for approval of Resolution No. 94-
44 and Councilmember Bookey SECONDLD the motion.
.There were no public comments. Councilmember Bannock requested
perkission to abstain because he works for Craycroft Chrysler,
Mayor Williams accepted his abstention.
CouncLlmember Measles stated that he was a little upset by the
fact that we are only 20 days into the new budget year and we
are already being asked to transfer almost $10,000 out of
contingency to cover a budgeted item. He asked why this wasn't
thought of during budget time.
Manninen stated that the original spec was not to include the.
plows, but the truck that was purr 'used required a different
plow.
Measles asked if when the item was budgeted there was a pre-
conceived notion as to make, model and type of vehicle it was
going to be.
Xanninen said no, only that the plow would be re -used. The
difference is that the flatbed truck and the crane weren't
anticipated. He now feels that in the long run the crane will
benefit the City.
k'
P,
•
•
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 4
Measles stated that his argument isn't with the fact that the
City needs the equipment. He said, "If we need it now, why
didn't we need it three months ago when we were putting the
budget together?" He stated it seems not enough thought goes
into budgeting these items.
Bookey agreed. He stated that
mentions a safety problem and,
have been addressed long ago.
the memo from Public Works
if that is the case, it should
Manninen stated that when this equipment was being anticipated
it was believed it could be acquired for under budget.
Williams asked if this water and sewer expenditure comes under
machinery and equipment. He said the Council had budgeted 1/2
the cost from machinery and equipment ($13,000) and the other
half was going to come from the airport budget.
Kornelis said no. One's from water; one's from sewer. $26#000
is in the budget. The $2,640 snow plow was not bid because he.
had anticipated using the existing snow plow. However, there
had been a change in the Dodge mounting so the old plow didn't.
fit this particular truck. As far as the crane, he had
anticipated using the sliding -bar type mechanism like the
existing one. The retired sewer foreman didn't put in for a
new crane. But when they began discussing this, the shop
foreman and other employees said they had gotten their hands
caught in the old mechanism. Kornelis said the new crane will -
be much better. That's where the extra $7,000 came from. He
apologized for not having this in the budget, but stated, "We
missed it."
Bookey stated he agreed with Measles. He said that this is the
public's money, and it's the Administration's job to find these.
problems before they go into the budget.
Williams stated that he agrees with what has been said, but
that he also is looking at some other concerns. It appears .
that only one company bid on this truck because one company
couldn't find their bid specs and another company changed halide
during the bidding process. Having only one bid makes it
difficult to judge the true value of the item. He suggested
investigating whether other companies offer the same product
and consider rebidding.
•
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MSBTING MINUTES
JUI.Y 20, 1994
PAGE 5
Williams stated that, unless Council
directed
from commenting orotherwise, he
would ask Councilman Bannock to abstain
voting on this matter.
Smalley asked for clarification aegear$nthats94u44odea1s9withand
Resolution 94 45. He stated it pp
the purchase of the truck and the snow Kornelis safd, and this is-45 deals
correctB
with the issue of the crane.
He also stated that the $25,Cidiover
y
adi oe fully It
is a one -ton 4X4 truck with government ra
equipped with flatbed and tool boxes under the flatbed.
Smalley stated that the City is not responsible for the fact
that there was only one bidder.
Mayor Williams stated that if the Council chooses to vote at
this time it should consider the additive alternates in the
resolution. Measles asked if the $25,889 includes additive
.alternates 1 and 2? Kornelis said it does not. Measles asked
if the resolution is just asking for the basic bid. Kornelis.
said yes.
Williams read the resolution aloud for clarification. He
stated that the resolution needs to be amended. Measles,stated
that the bid is being awarded on the truck; the plowis
ait
separate purchase and should not be a part of this package i
was not one of the additive alternates). He stated that the
plow should have been handled separately.
Williams suggested an amendment to eliminate all references to
any other items aside from the basic bid for the truck at
$250889.
NOTION:
Councilmember Measles MOVED to amend Resolution No. 94-44 in
the heading to read: "A resolution of the Council of the City
of Kenai, Alaskay awarding bid for a one -ton truck for the
water and sewer department to Craycroft Chrysler for a total
amount of the basic bid of $250889." The lower portion of the
resolution should read: "Now, therefore, be it resolved by ,the
Council of the City of Kenai, Alaska, that the.bid for a one
ton truck for the water and sewer department be awarded to
Craycroft Chrysler for the total amount of the basic bid of
$25 889." Councilmember Smalley SECONDED the motion. Williams
•
�J
•
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 6
asked if there was any objection to unanimous consent on the
amendment. No objection.
Williams asked if there was any further discussion on the body
of the resolution. No further discussion.
VOTB:
Measles:
Yes Williams:
Yes
Swarner: Absent
Bannock:
Abstain Bookey:
Yes
Monfor: Yes
Smalley:
Yes
C-49
Resolution No. 94-45 - Transferring $9,588 in the
Water and Sewer Fund to Add a Plow
and Crane to the
Pickup Truck which is
Appropriated
in the FY95
Budget,
Councilmember Measles MOVED for adoption of Resolution 94-45.
Councilmember Smalley SECONDED the motion. No public comment.
Councilmember Bannock asked to abstain from this resolution
because it is related to the last one. Williams said it wasn't
necessary because it's a separate item from the truck. Bannock
said he would vote after all. No further comments. Monfor
asked for unanimous consent. Bookey objected.
VOTE:
Measles: Yes Williams: Yes Swarner: Absent
Bannock: Yes Bookey: No Monfor: Yes
'Smalley: Yes
**Recess (8:15 to approximately 8:30)
eoMM M COMMITTEE REPORTS
D-1.6 Council on Aging
Pat Porter reported the next meeting is scheduled for Monday,
July 25. In the packet there is a request to approve two
additional members because of the nine -member rule. Williams
stated that Loretta Breeden and Lucille Billings have been
recommended to this Council for approval. No comments or
objections. Mayor Williams made both appointments.
RENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
DULY 20j 1999
PAGE 7
D-2. Airport commission
Councilmember Measles reported no meeting.
D-3. Harbor Commission
Councilmember Bookey reported no meeting, no quorum.
D-4. Library commission
Councilmember Monfor reported no meeting; the information is in
the packet; and the Friends of the Library received a $3.000
*donation from ARCO.
0-30 parks i Recreation Commission
Councilmember Bannock reported no meeting.
D-6. Planning i zoning Commission.
Councilmember Smalley reported a copy of.the agenda is in the
packet. He said Attorney JimButler would about the Cheater Cone on
to the
Council later in the meeting p
Beaver Loop. The planning resolution regarding Watergate Tray
failed; planning resolution regarding McLennan variance passed;
and because the Watergate resolution failed, the resolution
regarding Donald Aase was moot. The situation on the Watergate
resolution involved changing lot size in an area that spoke to
40,600 square foot lots. The applicant wanted those reduced.
Mr. Rodes spoke to Planning & Zoning. There were 12 or 13
items under code enforcement items;. he stated he would bring -
.one of those items up under 'Concerns" this evening.
D-7. Miscellaneous Commissions and Committees
a. Beautification: Meeting rescheduled. Bob Frates
stated there is a question of what to do. with the remaining
flowers donated by Lyndon Transport. There are 200 to 300
flats remaining to be planted; about that many have already.
been planted. He asked if Council had any suggestions about
what to do with them. There were no recommendations..
b. sister City Program: Williams stated.that today was
the last full day here for the Russian delegation. They will
be leaving tomorrow morning. There will probably be a return
0
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 8
trip to Russia in September if funding will allow. There is
about $3 million for the purpose of meetings and visits back
and forth from the Dept. of International Affairs to the State
of Alaska next year. We will be applying for an additional
grant to bring a doctor and maybe a school teacher or other
professionals here and to send ours there. While the governor
of Sakhalin Island was here, he signed some agreements with
Governor Hickel that will allow for training here in our fire
safety programs and other service areas. The U. S. Dept. of
International Development has indicated that $80 billion will
be spent to promote development within Russia. We also will
apply for some of that money.
Also, a very large fuel contract has been signed
between Petro Marine and the Far East, utilizing fuel being
produced by our local refinery. Williams stated he has
personal knowledge of a $9 million grocery contract now in the
making. He stated that the Sister City program is a major
factor contributing to the opportunities of the future.
Sakhalin Island offers approximately $40 billion in
opportunity. We will be helping to blend the economies of the
two regions and perhaps will be importing money and, possibly,
jobs in the future. He stated, "For my money, I think it's
better to spend $1 billion on this sort of thing than to
develop one more S-1 bomber."
E-1. Regular Meeting of July 6, 1994.
Approved by consent agenda.
None.
IT -am a s OLD 8VOIN168
1. Discussion - Acquisition of City Property for Habitat.for
Humanity.
Council members reviewed the information in the packet, and
Williams stated it didn't look like there was anything
available at this time. Williams stated he is working with one
of his partners on a major business transaction that may allow
t
•
•
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 9
them to donate several lots in the Mommson Subdivision to
Habitat for Humanity. He stated he has discussed this with
them and it may happen in about two weeks. No further comments.
or discussion.
8-1. Bills to bs Paid,? Bills to be Ratified
MOTION:
Councilmember Smalley X0V89D to pay the bills over $1,000 and
Councilmember Bookey SECONDED the motion. Councilmember
Measles asked for unanimous consent. There were no objections.
00 ORDBRND.
R-2. purchase Orders Exceeding $1,000
a) Councilmember Measles MOVED for approval of purchase
orders exceeding $1,000 as submitted. Councilmember Smalley
BECONDED the motion.. Councilmember Measles XOVLD to amend by
adding a purchase order to Craycroft Chrysler for a snow plow
in the .amount of .$21 ,640 and asked for unanimous consent.
Councilmember Monfor 8ECONDRD the motion. No objections.
Councilmember Bannock asked permission to abstain. Denied.
Councilmember Measles MOVED to momentarily table this motion
until Item H-2b is addressed. No objection. 00 MOVED*
Monfor asked if they could stand at ease for a moment. So
ordered.
Mayor Williams brought the meeting back to order,
b) Councilmember Measles MOVED that the marketing video
contract be awarded to Vantage Point Productions.
Councilmember Bookey.BEGONDED the motion. Councilmember asked
for unanimous consent. No objections.
Measles asked if someone would be working with Vantage'Point
during the production.of the video. Williams asked for three
volunteers from the Council. Councilmembers Monfor,, Bookey and
Smalley volunteered.
Monfor stated that a purchase order is on the list to Maloney &
Haggart for $10,000, and another payment was approved to them
• KENAI CITY COUNCIL
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE SO
MEETING MINUTES
for $5,096, a total of $15,000. She stated that she will go on
record as stating that this is probably the last time she will
vote for any money for them. ". . . the cost of this firm is
getting close to exceeding what we are ever going to get in
return." She asked why it appears on two different lists.
Brown answered that the money on H-1 is payment for services
already rendered. H-2 is purchase orders for future services.
We are in the bankruptcy stage of this case. Monfor asked how
Such money we have paid this firm so far. Brown said he will
let her know.
(Rotvrn to N-2a) Councilmember Measles MOVED to bring Item
H-2a back to the table. Councilmember Smalley SECONDED the
motion. Councilmember Measles MOVED to further amend Item H-2a
by inserting Vantage Point Productions on the purchase order
for production of the marketing video. Councilmember BMALLEY
seconded the motion. No objections. No discussion.
Councilmember Measles asked for unanimous consent. 80 ORDERED.
Ordinance No. 1601-94 - Prohibiting the parking or
operating of motor vehicles in any state or city
maintained road right-of-way which has been
landscaped, seeded or improved in a manner not
intended for vehicular traffic.
Approved by consent agenda.
N-4. Approval - Change Order No. 3, Thompson Park Water &
Sewer Project/Foster Construction - $795.38.
Councilmember Smalley MOVED for approval of the change order.
Councilmember Measles SECONDED the motion. No objection. 80
ORDERED.
Discussion - Schedule Board of Adjustment Hearing -
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission denial of
application for variance on Lot 1, Block 3, VIP Park
Estates, regarding requirement of 40,000 square foot
minimum lot size.
Councilmember Smalley reported that he attended the Planning &
Zoning meeting. He stated that several individuals spoke, in
addition to Mr. Aase. The subject of covenants came up; it was
10 explained that the City does not deal with covenants. The
people who spoke stated they had moved to the neighborhood
E
•
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 11
because of the lot sizes; Mr. Aase wants the City to break one
lot into two. As it presently sits, he can easily build a
four-plex in there. The residents expressed also that the
potential is there for another Thompson Park if lot sizes are
reduced and additional homes are put on the water and sewer.
If lot sizes are reduced for others, there could be twice as
many homes in the neighborhood. They are concerned about the
devaluation of property. The Planning & Zoning vote was 3
to 1.
Mayor Williams stated that apparently the City Engineer
recommended approval upon waiver of ADEC. Williams asked if
the applicant has asked ADEC for that waiver. Smalley stated
he did not. Smalley stated that Aase brought up the point that
the covenants allow for changes to be made after 10 years;.he
has had his property for 12 or 14 years. He was told that the
City does not deal with covenants.
Mayor Williams asked if Council wishes to schedule a Board of
Adjustment. Councilmember Measles MOVED to schedule the Board
of Adjustment hearing prior to the regular council meeting on.
August 3, 1994. Councilmember Smalley BECONDBD the motion.
Councilmember Smalley asked if the applicant will be advised to
seek that waiver from ADEC. Kornelis stated that Mr. Aase
states in his letter (in the packet) that he has the document..
$-6. Disauaeion - Proposed construction of permanent KPB
transfer site at Redoubt landfill location.
Smalley stated that this was an item that came up at the
Planning & Zoning meeting under the City Engineers report.
Smalley said he (Smalley) requested that it come before this
body. He said that what this is is a request by the Borough to
make a permanent transfer site on the existing site in Kenai.
Smalley said one of the concerns is that the Borough would
close the site and Kenai residents would have to haul their
trash to Soldotna.
Williams stated that he remembered attending a Borough meeting
in which the issue of the Borough transfer site was brought up,
They were planning on removing the transfer site and starting a
fee schedule. At that time Williams stated he was directed by
Council to advise the Borough against closing the transfer
site. There was also discussion about a fee schedule.
Williams said he told the Borough Assembly then that Kenai
LJ
r
•
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 12
didn't mind being charged a fee as long as a fee was being
charged everywhere.
Monfor asked if Katherine Mayer from the Borough could co", up
and answer a few questions. Williams stated that she could.
Monfor stated that she supports the transfer site. She then
asked Mayer if the Borough is planning on charging a fee for
all the transfer sites and what is the usage daily of this
site.
Mayer stated that she is the solid waste director for the
Borough. She has been with them for approximately 10 years.
She stated that at this time the Borough does not have a fee
proposed. There is a limited user fee for disposal of
construction demolition wastes that are going directly into the
landfill, but these are items that are not accepted at the
transfer sites. There will probably be a fee for disposal
within the next few years. The solid waste program is heading
toward revenue funds, special revenue funds, and enterprise
funds for the solid waste program. There will not ever be just
a fee for Kenai. If there is a fee, everyone will pay the
same, she said.
Mayer asked if she could do a brief overview of this plant
facility. She passed around photographs of sites where the
Borough has already made improvements. She stated that the
current facility has many problems that will be corrected with
the new transfer site. The new facility will be fenced,.Qo
access will be restricted during closed hours. Someone will be
on site during open hours. There are now an average of 745
trips per year made to haul the current dumpsters out when►
full. The larger trailers and more effective transfer system
will reduce that number to about 160 trips per year. The new
site will be aesthetically better, as well. The transfer
trailer will be inside a building, not out in the open.
Monfor stated that she is in favor of the new transfer site.
She stated it is one of the few things besides the school
system that Kenai residents get for their tax dollars. She
believes a majority of Kenai's nearly 7,000 people still use
the dump, and that improvement of the site would probably
enhance the neighborhood.
M
KENAI CITY COUNCIL
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 13
MEETING MINUTES
Smalley stated he concurs with Monfor's comments. Bannock
stated that, as a neighbor, he thinks it would be a great
improvement.
Williams summarized saying it appears that Council has no
objection to the permanent transfer site on Redoubt. He asked
about rezoning. Graves stated that the Borough has filled out
the application and it is scheduled to go before Planning &
Zoning.
2-7. Discussion - Acquisition of Chester Cone property.
Smalley asked if it would be appropriate to ask Jim Butler to
speak at this time. Williams stated it would.
BUTLER (vsrbatin)s Mr. Mayor and members of the Council, as
Councilman Smalley has indicated, my name is Jim Butler, and I
an an attorney in town. Over the last several months, I have
been working with Mr. Chester Cone who, as I am sure you are
well aware, owns some property along Beaver Loop Road.. In'
fact, the parcel that we are talking about this evening
includes a parcel that the City of Kenai attempted to purchase,.
.I believe, twicte,.and whom other people have purchased and have
given back to Mr. Cone due to their inability to develop the
property.
Mr. -Cone came to me trying to find some resolution to his
dilemma of having 100 acres on one of the most pristine rivers
in Alaska and he can't do anything with it. We looked through
a couple different options and elected to put together a
proposal for the Exxon Valdez Trustee Council Small Parcel
Acquisition Program.
Let me give you a little bit of background on the Exxon Valdez
Trustee Council and what they are doing and what we are trying
to do with this proposal and how I think the Council might
follow the lead of the Planning & Zoning Commission to offer
some support Lto that. After the spill, Exxon entered into a
consent decree .with federal and state government to settle the
civil damage claims that both the state and federal government
brought against Exxon. That was.done under CIRCLA. A $900
million trust fund was established for.the purpose of
attempting to restore property impacted by the oil spill, to,
develop a habitat protection acquisition program, to provide
monitoring and research funds for the spill -impacted area, and
6r
•
•
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 14
also to provide public information and administration of the
fund.
What I want to do, I guess, at this point is reinforce
sometimes a common misconception of what the Council is about,
and dispel maybe the misconception. And that is that this is
somehow a -- this program is somehow currently impacting either
Exxon or other oil companies in the area. That money, the
money that we're talking about tonight, is money that has
already been paid into a fund and the administration and
disposal of those monies, the use of those monies, is not going
to directly impact any industry people in our area or in any
area around the state.
We put together a proposal to the Trustee Council under the
Small Parcel Acquisition Program. in order to fit under that,
the parcel has to be less than 1,000 acres and has to be
located in the spill -impacted area. To just sort of give you
an orientation of what the spill -impacted area is, it's from
Bligh Reef south to Chignik, and all the way up north to the
forelands, including the west side of Cook Inlet down to,
Chignik and all the Kodiak area. So the Council put out a
request for proposals to acquire property in the spill -impacted
areas. The Kenai River is specifically identified as an
impacted area, primarily because of the over -escapement of
sockeye in 1989.
Mr. Cone's property meets the acquisition program criteria in a
number of areas, primarily because his property includes -
rearing habitat for both sockeye and pink salmon, Dolly Varden,
bald eagles, common murre and any tidal organisms that are
important to the support of those particular species. The
restoration fund is set up to acquire parcels of property to
offset those properties that were significantly impacted.
One of the other things that the Council can do is deal with
restoring services that were impacted. Now services that - were
impacted include commercial fishing and sport fishing. Because
areas were closed during the spill, people had to go to other
areas to go pursue their sport fishing; and as a result,
significant impacts were indirectly incurred in those areas,
So they are looking at acquiring this property, or this type of
property.
One of the things that I an sure you are all aware of is this
piece of property in particular has been studied to death.. I.
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MI
JULY 20, 1994 MINUTES
PAGE 15
know that, when the City of Kenai proposed to build a boat
launch on an 11-1/2 acre parcel along this particular tract of
land, Fish and Wildlife, D.N.R., Fish and Game -- everybody
went through that piece of property with a fine-tooth comb.
Essentially what we have done is we have taken a large stack of
agency research and turned it around and said, "This property
has been defined as critical by you and, therefore, we think
that the public should own this property as opposed to havin
an individual own this property." The Commission had the g
opportunity to review the proposal; and I don't know if any of
the Council members have had an opportunity yet, but the
Administration staff has that .proposal and we can make sure
you've got copies if you're interested in seeing how the
specific elements of the criteria that are going to be
evaluated -- how this property ranks with that.
quite confidently that the I can say
;. property ranks quite high. The Fish
,.;;.. and Game has also requested that this property be srously
' considered for acquisition because of the importanceeci
protecting habitat along the Kenai River which, as you know, is
a growing concern in our area.
Support of the proposal is, I guess, what we would like to see
from the Council; and, not just for the
ut support
of an expedited review. Tonight Mr. conerturned, I believe, So
years old, and his ability to wait around and haggle with the
state and the fads is much shorter than it was 15 years ago.
And because his property has been researched, were trying to
keep it out of the consultant trap (unintelligible).
So I would like to request the Council consider supporting the
proposal -- the acquisition proposal -- and an expedited review
of his proposal, which the Council -- my understanding is
they've got the authority to do that. Valuation, those sorts
Of issues, can be worked out. The mechanism for holding the
property, how title is vested, is something that Mr. Cone is
very open to working with the Council on. The use of the
property in the future could be something that, not only
whoever holds the property, but the City of Kenai, could play
an instrumental role in deciding how services like tourism and
the rest of that are going to be -- maybe mitigate any impacts.
I donut know if your packet includes a letter that Chairman
Walker signed. If you've got any questions at this would be glad to help you out with those. time, I
(end of verbatim)
. RENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 16
Smalley stated that Walker's letter oad astatement thatthe
sdhe packet. He aB
aid
that Planning & Zoning also wanted t
City had attempted to purchase this property and to seek out
the necessary required permits to developthe it property;
and the
property went back to Mr. Cone w Y w
Bookey asked what happens to the property once it's acquired -�-
does it go into a land bank situation where there is no project
development or will there be any eestatedethat hetisrsaid that
willing to
is an open question right now. H
work with the City in working with the Trustee Council on
finding a workable solution for the property. Butler said the
Council's restoration plan istwith
Peninsula Coastal Plan and the KenaiRiverComprehensive
Management Plan. He stated that a small piece of the property
abuts the river, but most of it is upland. He would like to
see maybe a bird sanctuary where People could pull off this would take somethe of the
and observe the wildlife. He said
pressure off the river bank. Butler stated that once the
Trustee Council acquires the property, it can be transfered to
anyone.
Smalley stated that Mr. Cone said at the Planning & Zoning
meeting that, after 20 ' years of tryinhto e sell this pro tyts i,
is
this is a last ditch effort in which 9
support.
MOTION:
Councilmember Smalley MOVED that the City Administration work
with Mr. Butler to draft a letter or resolution supporting this
proposal and to request an expedited review. Counnciilmemabrio
Measles 8ECONDED the motion and stated, This is
where federal and other agencies havo issuepermits for
made a ,property
useless with their regulations and refusal t
property owners to develop this property. I an certainly in
favor of this thing happening." He also stated that he feels
this is perhaps a stretch of the intent of the Oil Spill Trust.
Fund; though not as far as some have stretched it.
Williams stated that the Council feels compassion for Mr. Cone
and his long battle. He said that at one time the City thought
it could use the land, but that didn't happen. Now the City
wishes the best for Mr. Cone.
4 y
•
0
KENAI CITY COUNCIL
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 17
MEETING MINUTES
Smalley offered that maybe the City would have some influence,
in the State legislature as to how the land will be used.
Butler stated again that he is willing to work with the City.
Bookey stated that maybe somebody in the State might listen to
this: It seems that the State is so concerned about the impact
on the Kenai, yet they build these horrendous roads to get
here; but they're not as concerned about the impact on the
Kenai River when they deny access.
Butler stated that he will be glad to let the City Council know
if some opportunities arise. Williams directed the Clerk to
prepare a resolution in support of and for expedition of the
review. Butler said that the review process could go from
October, 1994 into early 1995. Williams directed the Clerk to
issue a letter immediately and follow it with a resolution to
Council at the next meeting.
Councilmember Smalley asked for unanimous consent. No
objections. So ORDERED,
1-1. Mayor
a. Townsite Nistoric Board Attendance: Williams stated
that he sent a letter to members of the Board indicating his
concern that they had not -attended the meeting. Three of the
members contacted Williams personally stating they had not been
notified of the meeting. Williams said he would like to know.
if the addresses are correct and if any of the letters came
back to City Hall before he sends out a letter like that again.
=-2. City 'tanager
a. BDD Lease: The lease is due on August 12. A meeting
was held with Carr-Gottstein last week.
b. MIDRNZ: He stated there are articles in the Journal
of Commerce and in today's Dispatch that cover progress so far.
I-3. Attorney
No report.
• KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINOTES
JgLY 20j 1994
PAGE 18
I-4. City Clerk
Acting Clerk Paulsen read into the record the findings of
a telephone poll taken on June 13, 1994 requesting council
approval to issue a purchase order to TransAlaska Title, Inc.
to perform a preliminary commitment report on lots pertaining
to the MSM proposed settlement. The purchase order would be
for an estimated cost of $1,400. Approval of the purchase
order would enable the City Administration to provide a report
on the MSM proposed settlement'tc the Council at the July 20
meeting. The telephone poll was authorized by the city manager
and signed by the finance director; those signatures were
attested by Acting Clerk Paulsen. The vote was four yes
(Measles, Smalley, Bannock and Monfor) and three absent
(Swarner, Bookey and Williams). The poll was taken by Sheryl
Paulsen.
Acting Clerk Paulsen read into the record the findings of
40 a second telephone poll taken on June 18, 1994 requesting
council approval to order a replacement gasoline fuel pump for
the dock and to issue a purchase order for $1,540 to Statewide
Petroleum. The fuel pump at the dock burned out on Friday
afternoon (July 15, 1994). The telephone poll was authorized
by the city manager and signed by the finance director; those
signatures were attested by Acting Clerk Paulsen. The vote was
five yes (Measles, Smalley, Bookey, Bannock and Monfor) and two
absent (Swarner and Williams). The poll was taken by Kathy
Woodford.
is
I -so Finance Director
No report.
I-6. public Works Director
Kornelis stated he wanted to draw attention to Info Item 03
regarding the Basin View paving RFP's. Also Item #6 is the new
schedule from Glacier State regarding the soils contamination
at the courthouse. Info Item #9 is the packet of material
which was mailed to the Thompson Park residents having to do.
with water and sewer services.
I-7.
No report.
Airport Manager
•
E
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 19
UNCUTIVH ONOSION: ' 9 t 3a p.n.
BACK TO ORDER $ 10135 Pon*
Measles reported, "Ths'purpose of the executive session was to
discuss the status of settlement on the Inlet Woods properties
litigation. The Council instructed the Administration to.
proceed with the settle�aent issue in hopes of drawing it to
some conclusion in the near future."
J-1. Citizens
None.
J- 2. council
Bookey - Nothing.
Nonfor Nothing.
Measles - Nothing.
Hamock - He stated that he was glad to see the new ordinance
introduced this,evening regarding parking in rights -of -way. He
asked about the on -street parking of "For Sale" items on
Frontage.Road and. -asked how, it. 'con. be.dealt with. He suggested
that maybe if there were signs there stating "No overnight
Parking" people would not -park there because of the
inconvenience of moving the vehicles every evening. It was
suggested that that is alreadya no overnight parking sane.
Bannock stated that maybe the same people who tow cars from the
airport parking .lot couldtow the cars from Frontage Road.
Williams stated that proper signs need to be in place to warn
people. Bannock said that if.the rules are there, they need to
be posted; and once they are posted, they .must be enforced.
a. He stated he had'o-phone.call concerning the lack of
restroom facilities at the beach. Bob Frates said he.would
make a phone call tomorrow; they were caught off'guard..-
b. Smalley also said he is concerned about RV Is parking
in parking.lots such as..K-Mart and Carrs without conditional
use permits. He said we have privately owned facilities that
0
•
KENAI CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
JULY 20, 1994
PAGE 20
are not full, and these vehicles are being allowed to use these
parking lots.
Williams stated that he had a discussion with the manager of
K-Mart about this subject. The K-Mart manager asked Williams
if it would be permitted to put in electrical hook-ups in the
parking lot for the RVIs. Williams told him there is nothing
against it provided they were put in according to code.
Williams told him there had been complaints before the Council
about the subject.
Smalley stated that the problem also extends to river guides
who live within the City who are allowing people to park their
RV's in their yards along Spur Highway, down by Thompson Park,
down Angler Road, off Lawton, and other areas. Smalley asked
if this could be turned over to Jack to be investigated for
Planning & Zoning.
Graves suggested maybe we should look at the definition of a
recreational vehicle park. Bannock said the intent of the
original ordinance was to have commercial operations.
c. Smalley said he also received a call and a visit from
Merle Feldman regarding the City's flower beds. She is
concerned that the Watering of the beds is not as frequent as
it needs to be.
Williams: He thanked Council on behalf of the members of the
Sister Cities for the financial support of the program. They
served more than 100 people at the picnic and had a good time.
The meeting adjourned at approximately 10:30 p.me
s transcribgA and sybmitted by:
• cca•sic.�a•,
D AWPS1\NI NUTES\1994\72094 AIN
0