HomeMy WebLinkAboutOrdinance No. 3332-2023 MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Gabriel and Council Members
FROM: Shellie Saner, City Clerk
DATE: January 23, 2023
SUBJECT: Ordinance No. 3332-2023 Requested Technical Amendment
The purpose of this memo is to request technical amendment to Ordinance No. 3332-2023.
The following technical amendments are respectfully requested.
Motion
Thank you for your consideration.
Amend Section 1, paragraph c. 1. by replacing the reference to subsection (k), with reference
subsection (h); and
Amend Section1, paragraph c. 3. By replacing the reference to subsection (L), with reference
to subsection (i); and
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. by removing RSL from the listed exceptions and replacing
with RS2.
And renumber the current Sections 2 and 3 to 3 and 4.
MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Gabriel and Council Members
FROM: Meghan Thibodeau, Deputy City Clerk
DATE: January 26, 2023
SUBJECT: Ordinance No. 3332-2023 Requested Amendment
The purpose of this memo is to request an amendment to Ordinance No. 3332-2023 based on
the Planning and Zoning Commission’s recommendations.
The following amendment is respectfully requested.
Motion
Thank you for your consideration.
Add a final WHEREAS that reads:
At its meeting on January 25, 2023, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommended
enactment of this Ordinance with the following conditions:
• That a Planning & Zoning and/or City Council Work Session be scheduled prior to
enactment.
• Include provisions that containment of chickens be restricted to the back of the
house in the rear yard.
MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Gabriel and Council Members
FROM: Victoria Askin, Council Member
DATE: January 26, 2023
SUBJECT: Ordinance No. 3332-2023 Requested Amendment
Ordinance 3332-2023 should be amended to address the number of chicken hens allowed based
on the geographic zone. The keeping of 12 chicken hens on smaller lots within denser areas is
excessive for providing eggs for the average household or as household pets. The raising of
chicken hens could affect or benefit the community and it is important to balance the number of
chicken hens accordingly.
The following amendment is proposed.
1) 3.10.070(h)(1) Allow a maximum of 12 chicken hens in the Rural Residential (RR) zone
and allow a maximum of six (6) chicken hens in the other zones, except in the prohibited
zones.
The RR zone is generally located in the outlying and rural areas. Most of lots in the RR zone
are surrounded by lots greater than 40,000 square feet where livestock are generally
permitted. The keeping of 12 chicken hens would be better suited for lots within the RR zone
based how it is dispersed away from the centrally developed area, where it would not
significantly affect the surrounding neighbors.
The keeping of six (6) chicken hens is a reasonable amount for other zones since it is
estimated that three (3) chickens per two (2) household members is the rule of thumb to
support egg consumption needs. The other zones, specifically the residential zones are
generally located in the dense residential neighborhoods and limiting the number of chicken
hens to six (6) would balance the benefits and minimize the potential nuisance.
Attached is a map of the proposed amendment.
Motion
New Text Underlined
Thank you for your consideration.
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. 1. that reads:
A maximum of twelve (12) chicken hens may be kept on lots in the Rural Residential (RR)
zone and a maximum of six (6) chicken hens on lots in other allowed zones with a permitted
principal structure.
MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Gabriel and Council Members
FROM: Henry Knackstedt, Council Member
DATE: January 26, 2023
SUBJECT: Ordinance No. 3332-2023 Comments and Proposed Amendments
Ordinance 3332-2023, an amendment to KMC 3.10.070-Livestock within City Limits should be
more restrictive to provide low visibility and minimize impacts on the surrounding neighbors and
community.
The following are my proposed amendments to the Ordinance:
1) 3.10.070(h) Add the Airport Light Industrial (ALI) Zone to the list of zoning districts that
prohibits the keeping of any chicken hens.
Lots within the Airport Light Industrial Zone are reserved for aviation-related commercial and
industrial uses. The keeping of chicken hens should be prohibited in the ALI Zone to be
consistent with the intent of the zone.
2) 3.10.070(h)(1) Reduce the number of permitted chicken hens from 12 to 6.
The allowance of raising 12 chicken hens would provide a surplus of eggs for the average
household. Additionally, fewer chicken hens would produce less waste and may be generally
more acceptable to neighbors.
3) 3.10.070(h)(3) and (4) Restrict the location of the enclosed shelters and containment
structures to the rear yard.
The ordinance provides lenient setback requirements for the location of housing and fencing
of chicken hens that may detract from the neighborhood appearance. The Ordinance would
potentially allow fencing of chicken hens in the front yard if a house has a setback greater
than 25 feet from the front property line; therefore, chicken hens may roam in the front yard
under the Ordinance. The potential of unobscured chicken hens in the front yard would
diminish the neighborhood streetscape. To minimize the visual impact and nuisance
complaints, the location of the housing and fencing for the chicken hens should be limited to
the back yard.
Attached is a map of the proposed amendment.
Page 2 of 2
Motion
New Text Underlined; [DELETED TEXT BRACKETED]
Thank you for your consideration.
Amend Section 1, paragraph h as follows:
(h) The keeping of chicken hens on lots less than forty thousand (40,000) square feet is
allowed, except in the ALI, RU, RS1, RS2, and TSH zoning districts, subject to the
following standards:
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. 1. that reads:
(1) A maximum of six (6)[TWELVE (12)] chicken hens may be kept on lots with a permitted
principal structure.
Amend Section 1, paragraphs h. 3. And h. 4. that reads:
(3) Chicken coops, hutches or other fully enclosed shelters must be located in the rear yard
[MAY NOT BE LOCATED IN A FRONT YARD OR SIDE YARD THAT ABUTS A STREET
IN A RESIDENTIAL ZONING DISTRICT] and must have a minimum setback of fifteen
feet (15’) from the side yards, ten feet (10’) from the rear yard, and twenty-five feet (25’)
from residential dwellings on neighboring lots.
(4) Fences, corral, pen, or other similar containment structures must be located in the rear
yard and have a minimum setback of fifteen feet (15’) from the side yards, [TWENTY-
FIVE FEET (25’) FROM THE FRONT YARD,] ten feet (10’) from the rear yard, and twenty-
five feet (25’) from residential dwellings on neighboring lots.
MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Gabriel and Council Members
THROUGH: Terry Eubank, City Manager
FROM: Alex Douthit, Council Member
DATE: February 23, 2023
SUBJECT: Ordinance No. 3332-2023 Requested Amendments
After reviewing the public comments on Ordinance No. 3332-2023, the proposed amendments
are to limit the keeping of chicken hens to primarily laying eggs, determine flock size based on lot
size, and place the burden of proof on the property owner for compliance.
The following amendments are respectfully requested.
Motion 1
New Text Underlined
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. by adding a new line that reads:
(X) The term “laying hens” as used in this section means a female chicken that is kept
primarily for laying eggs and not for the sole purpose of meat.
Page 2 of 2
Motion 2
New Text Underlined; [DELETED TEXT BRACKETED]
Motion 3
New Text Underlined; [DELETED TEXT BRACKETED]
Motion 4
New Text Underlined
Thank you for your consideration.
Amend the following paragraphs in Section 1, where references of “chicken hens” are
replaced with “laying hens”.
(c)(1) The keeping of [CHICKEN HENS] laying hens on lots less than forty thousand (40,000)
square feet will be subject to the standards in subsection (k).
(h) The keeping of [CHICKEN HENS] laying hens on lots less than forty thousand (40,000)
square feet is allowed, except in the RU, RS1, RSL, and TSH zoning districts, subject
to the following standards:
(h)(1) A maximum of twelve (12) [CHICKEN HENS] laying hens may be kept on lots with a
permitted principal structure.
(h)(2) [CHICKEN HENS] Laying hens must be kept in an enclosed shelter or fully fenced-in
at all times.
(h)(7) [CHICKEN HENS] Laying hens may not be kept in such a manner as to constitute a
public nuisance as defined by Kenai Municipal Code.
(h)(8) The keeping of [CHICKEN HENS] laying hens must be consistent with terms of this
title and does not in or of itself constitute a nuisance or a disturbance.
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. 1. that reads:
(1) Up to six (6) laying hens may be kept on lots of 10,000 square feet or greater [A
MAXIMUM OF TWELVE (12) CHICKEN HENS MAY BE KEPT ON LOTS] with a
permitted principal structure. Two (2) additional laying hens are allowed for each
additional 5,000 square feet of lot area to a maximum of twelve (12) laying hens. Laying
hens are prohibited on lots less than 10,000 square feet.
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. by adding a new line that reads:
(X) It is the responsibility and burden of the property owner to provide necessary information
to the City, potentially including a survey performed by a registered surveyor, to verify
conditions of this title are met if reasonably called into question.
MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Gabriel and Council Members
FROM: Meghan Thibodeau, Deputy City Clerk
DATE: February 28, 2023
SUBJECT: Ordinance No. 3332-2023 Requested Amendment
The purpose of this memo is to request an amendment to Ordinance No. 3332-2023 based on
the Planning and Zoning Commission’s recommendations.
The following amendment is respectfully requested.
Motion
Thank you for your consideration.
Add two final WHEREAS which read:
WHEREAS, at its meeting on January 25, 2023, the Planning and Zoning Commission
recommended enactment of this Ordinance with the following conditions:
• That a Planning & Zoning and/or City Council Work Session be scheduled prior to
enactment.
• Include provisions that containment of chickens be restricted to the back of the
house in the rear yard.
WHEREAS, at its meeting on February 22, 2023, the Planning and Zoning Commission
recommended enactment of this Ordinance with further recommended conditions.
MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Gabriel and Council Members
FROM: Shellie Saner, City Clerk
DATE: January 23, 2023
SUBJECT: Ordinance No. 3332-2023 Requested Technical Amendment
The purpose of this memo is to request technical amendment to Ordinance No. 3332-2023.
The following technical amendments are respectfully requested.
Motion
Thank you for your consideration.
Amend Section 1, paragraph c. 1. by replacing the reference to subsection (k), with reference
subsection (h); and
Amend Section1, paragraph c. 3. By replacing the reference to subsection (L), with reference
to subsection (i); and
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. by removing RSL from the listed exceptions and replacing
with RS2.
And renumber the current Sections 2 and 3 to 3 and 4.
Page 45
City of Kenai I 210 !=idalgo Ave, Kenai , AK 99611-7794 I 907.283.7535 I www.kenai .city
Page 1 of 4
MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Gabriel and Council Members
FROM: Shellie Saner, City Clerk
DATE: February 28, 2023
SUBJECT: Planning & Zoning Commission Recommended Amendments to
Ordinance 3332-2023
The Planning and Zoning Commission during their February 22, 2023 Regular meeting
recommended the following amendments:
Planning & Zoning Commission Recommendation 1
Planning & Zoning Commission Recommendation 2
Amend Section 1, paragraph c. 1. to read:
“The keeping of chicken hens on lots less than forty thousand (40,000) square feet will be subject
to the standards in subsection (k). This allowance for the keeping of chicken hens does not permit
commercial activities where otherwise prohibited or additional permitting or licensing is required.”
Clerk’s Note: The recommendation above was approved by vote of: 6-Yea, 0-Nay, 1-Absent.
Commissioner Greenberg was absent.
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. 1. to read:
“Up to four (4) chicken hens may be kept on lots of 24,000 square feet or less [A MAXIMUM OF
TWELVE (12) CHICKEN HENS MAY BE KEPT ON LOTS] with a permitted principal structure. One (1)
additional chicken hen is allowed for each additional 2,000 square feet of lot area.”
Clerk’s Note: The recommendation above was approved by a vote of: 5-Yea, 1-Nay, 1-
Absent. Commission. The Nay vote was cast by Commissioner Glendening.
Page 2 of 4
Planning & Zoning Commission Recommendation 3
Planning & Zoning Commission Recommendation 4
Planning & Zoning Commission Recommendation 5
Amend Section 1, paragraph h as follows:
“The keeping of chicken hens on lots less than forty thousand (40,000) square feet is allowed,
except in the ALI, RU, RS1, RS2, and TSH zoning districts, subject to the following standards:”
Clerk’s Note: The recommendation above was approved by a vote of: 6-Yea, 0-Nay, 1-Absent;
and is in support of the first amendment as proposed in the Knackstedt January
26, 2023 Comments and Proposed Amendments Memo.
Section 1, paragraph h. 3. and h. 4. as follows:
“(3) Chicken coops, hutches or other fully enclosed shelters must be located in the rear yard
[MAY NOT BE LOCATED IN A FRONT YARD OR SIDE YARD THAT ABUTS A STREET IN A RESIDENTIAL
ZONING DISTRICT] and must have a minimum setback of fifteen feet (15’) from the side
yards, ten feet (10’) from the rear yard, and twenty-five feet (25’) from residential dwellings
on neighboring lots.
(4) Fences, corral, pen, or other similar containment structures must be located in the rear
yard and have a minimum setback of fifteen feet (15’) from the side yards, [TWENTY-FIVE
FEET (25’) FROM THE FRONT YARD,] ten feet (10’) from the rear yard, and twenty-five feet
(25’) from residential dwellings on neighboring lots.”
Clerk’s Note: The recommendation above was approved by a vote of: 6-Yea, 0-Nay, 1-Absent;
and is in support of the third amendment as proposed in Knackstedt January 26,
2023 Comments and Proposed Amendment Memo.
Amend Ordinance No 3332-2023 to exclude the Suburban Residential RS Zones:
“The keeping of chicken hens on lots less than forty thousand (40,000) square feet is allowed,
except in the ALI, RU, RS, RS1, RS2, and TSH zoning districts, subject to the following
standards:”
Clerk’s Note: The recommendation above was approved by a vote of: 5-Yea, 1-Nay, 1-Absent.
The Nay vote was cast by Commissioner Glendening.
Page 3 of 4
Planning & Zoning Commission Recommendation 6
Planning & Zoning Commission Recommendation 7
Planning & Zoning Commission Recommendation 8
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. 5. as follows:
“All shelters or containment structures must be constructed of durable weather resistant
materials, secured, and kept in good repair. The siding and roofing must be constructed with solid
and durable construction materials.”
Clerk’s Note: The recommendation above was approved by a vote of: 5-Yea, 1-Nay, 1-Absent.
The Nay vote was cast by Commissioner Coston.
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. by adding a new subparagraph to read as follows:
“All feed for chickens must be stored securely to prevent access from rodents and other non-
domestic animals.”
Clerk’s Note: 1.) The recommendation above was approved by a vote of: 6-Yea, 0-Nay, 1-
Absent.
2.) Each newly added subparagraph will be numbered accordingly, following the
previous subparagraph number. Subparagraph numbering will be considered
technical amendments and completed by the City Clerk.
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. by adding a new subparagraph to read as follows:
“On lots twenty-four thousand square feet or less, a registration for chicken hens must first be
obtained from animal control prior to moving any number of chicken hens onto the property. The
registration will require certification that all provisions of this title are complied with.”
Clerk’s Note: 1.) The original motion was for twenty thousand square feet. It was changed to
twenty-four thousand feet by amendment which was approved by a vote of: 6-
Yea, 0-Nay, 1-Absent
2.) The amended recommendation above was approved by a vote of: 6-Yea, 0-
Nay, 1-Absent.
3.) Each newly added subparagraph will be numbered accordingly, following the
previous number. Numbering will be considered technical amendments and
completed by the City Clerk.
Page 4 of 4
Planning & Zoning Commission Recommendation 9
The Planning and Zoning Commission recommended City Council enact Ordinance No. 3332-
2023 with the recommended Planning and Zoning Commission amendments by the following
vote:
Yes: Halstead, Coston, Glendening, Twait
No: Fikes, Woodard
Absent: Greenberg
Vote: 4 Yes, 2 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
The following four (4) pages show all primary and secondary, approved and failed motions made
during the February 22, 2023 Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Amend Section 1, paragraph h. by adding a new subparagraph to read as follows:
“Chicken coops, hutches or other fully enclosed shelters may not exceed eight feet (8’) in height.”
Clerk’s Note: 1.) The recommendation above was approved by a vote of: 4-Yea, 2-Nay, 1-
Absent. The Nay votes were cast by Commissioners Glendening and Twait.
2.) Each newly added subparagraph will be numbered accordingly, following the
previous subparagraph number. Subparagraph numbering will be considered
technical amendments and completed by the City Clerk.
New Text Underlined; [DELETED TEXT BRACKETED IN SMALL CAPS]
Ord 3332-2023 Motions in order:
#1 Commissioner Glendening MOVED to recommend Council amend Ordinance 3332-2023, Section 1,
paragraph c. 1. to read:
“The keeping of chicken hens on lots less than forty thousand (40,000) square feet will be subject to
the standards in subsection (k). This allowance for the keeping of chicken hens does not permit
commercial activities where otherwise prohibited or additional permitting or licensing is required.”
Commissioner Halstead SECONDED the motion.
Vote on Motion:
Yes: Woodard, Coston, Glendening, Twait, Halstead, Fikes
No: None.
Absent: Greenberg
Vote on Motion: 6 Yes, 0 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
#2 Commissioner Woodard MOVED to recommend Council amend Ordinance 3332-2023, Section 1,
paragraph h. 1. to read:
“Up to four (4) chicken hens may be kept on lots of 24,000 square feet or less [A MAXIMUM OF TWELVE
(12) CHICKEN HENS MAY BE KEPT ON LOTS] with a permitted principal structure. One (1) additional
chicken hen is allowed for each additional 2,000 square feet of lot area.”
Commissioner Halstead SECONDED the motion.
Amend: Commissioner Glendening MOVED to amend the proposed amendment as follows:
“A maximum of twelve (12) chicken hens may be kept on lots in the Rural Residential (RR) zones and
a maximum of six (6) [UP TO FOUR (4)] chicken hens [MAY BE KEPT] on lots in other allowed zones [OF
24,000 SQUARE FEET OR LESS] with a permitted principal structure. One (1) additional chicken hen is
allowed for each additional 2,000 square feet of lot area.”
Commissioner Halstead SECONDED the motion to amend the main motion.
Vote on Motion to Amend the main motion:
Yes: Coston, Glendening
No: Twait, Halstead, Fikes, Woodard
Absent: Greenberg
Vote on the motion to AMEND the main motion: 2 Yes, 4 No, 1 Absent - Motion Failed to Adopt.
Vote on the Main Motion:
Yes: Twait, Halstead, Fikes, Woodard, Coston
No: Glendening
Absent: Greenberg
Vote on the MAIN motion: 5 Yes, 1 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
#3 Commissioner Glendening MOVED to recommend Council amend Ordinance 3332-2023, Section 1,
paragraph h as follows:
“The keeping of chicken hens on lots less than forty thousand (40,000) square feet is allowed, except
in the ALI, RU, RS1, RS2, and TSH zoning districts, subject to the following standards:”
Commissioner Halstead SECONDED the motion.
Vote on Motion:
Yes: Twait, Halstead, Fikes, Woodard, Coston, Glendening
No: None.
Absent: Greenberg
Vote: 6 Yes, 0 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
#4 Commissioner Glendening MOVED to recommend Council amend Ordinance 3332-2023, Section 1,
paragraph h. 3. and h. 4. as follows:
“(3) Chicken coops, hutches or other fully enclosed shelters must be located in the rear yard [MAY
NOT BE LOCATED IN A FRONT YARD OR SIDE YARD THAT ABUTS A STREET IN A RESIDENTIAL ZONING
DISTRICT] and must have a minimum setback of fifteen feet (15’) from the side yards, ten feet (10’)
from the rear yard, and twenty-five feet (25’) from residential dwellings on neighboring lots.
(4) Fences, corral, pen, or other similar containment structures must be located in the rear yard and
have a minimum setback of fifteen feet (15’) from the side yards, [TWENTY-FIVE FEET (25’) FROM THE
FRONT YARD,] ten feet (10’) from the rear yard, and twenty-five feet (25’) from residential dwellings on
neighboring lots.”
Commissioner Halstead SECONDED the motion.
Vote on Motion:
Yes: Halstead, Fikes, Woodard, Coston, Glendening, Twait
No: None.
Absent: Greenberg
Vote: 6 Yes, 0 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
#5 Commissioner Halstead MOVED to recommend Council amend Ordinance 3332-2023, to exclude
Suburban Residential RS. Commissioner Fikes SECONDED the motion.
Amend: Commissioner Woodard MOVED to amend the proposed amendment, to exclude lots under 15,000
square feet in the Suburban Residential RS. Commissioner Glendening SECONDED the motion.
Vote on Motion to Amend the main motion:
Yes: Twait, Woodard, Glendening
No: Halstead, Fikes, Coston
Absent: Greenberg
3 Yes, 3 No, 1 Absent - Motion Failed to Adopt.
Vote on Motion:
Yes: Halstead, Fikes, Woodard, Coston, Twait
No: Glendening
Absent: Greenberg
Vote on the MAIN motion: 5 Yes, 1 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
#6 Commissioner Coston MOVED to recommend Council amend Ordinance 3332-2023, Section 1,
paragraph h. 5. as follows:
“All shelters or containment structures must be constructed of durable weather resistant materials,
secured, and kept in good repair. The siding and roofing must be constructed with solid and durable
construction materials.”
Commissioner Woodard SECONDED the motion.
Vote on Motion:
Yes: Fikes, Woodard, Glendening, Twait, Halstead
No: Coston
Absent: Greenberg
Vote: 5 Yes, 1 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
#7 Commissioner Halstead MOVED to recommend Council amend Ordinance 3332-2023, Section 1,
paragraph h. by adding a new paragraph 9 as follows:
“All feed for chickens must be stored securely to prevent access from rodents and other non-domestic
animals.”
Commissioner Glendening SECONDED the motion.
Vote on Motion:
Yes: Coston, Glendening, Twait, Halstead, Fikes, Woodard
No: None.
Absent: Greenberg
Vote: 6 Yes, 0 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
#8 Commissioner Halstead MOVED to recommend Council amend Ordinance 3332-2023, Section 1,
paragraph h by adding a new paragraph 10 as follows:
“On lots twenty thousand square feet or less, a registration for chicken hens must first be obtained
from animal control prior to moving any number of chicken hens onto the property. The registration
will require certification that all provisions of this title are complied with.”
Commissioner Glendening SECONDED the motion.
Amend: Commissioner Glendening MOVED to amend the proposed amendment as follows:
“On lots twenty-four (24) thousand square feet or less, a registration for chicken hens must first be
obtained from animal control prior to moving any number of chicken hens onto the property. The
registration will require certification that all provisions of this title are complied with.”
Commissioner Halstead SECONDED the motion to amend the main motion.
Vote on Motion to amend the main motion:
Yes: Twait, Halstead, Fikes, Woodard, Coston, Glendening
No: None.
Absent: Greenberg
Vote on the motion to AMEND the main motion: 6 Yes, 0 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
Vote on main Motion as amended:
Yes: Twait, Halstead, Fikes, Woodard, Coston, Glendening
No: None.
Absent: Greenberg
Vote on the MAIN motion as amended: 6 Yes, 0 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
#9 Commissioner Halstead MOVED to recommend Council amend Ordinance 3332-2023, Section 1,
paragraph h. by adding a new paragraph 12 as follows:
“Chicken coops, hutches or other fully enclosed shelters may not exceed eight feet (8’) in height.”
Commissioner Woodard SECONDED the motion.
Vote on Motion:
Yes: Fikes, Woodard, Coston, Halstead
No: Glendening, Twait
Absent: Greenberg
Vote: 4 Yes, 2 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.
#10 Commissioner Halstead MOVED to recommend Council amend Ordinance 3332-2023, Section 1,
paragraph h. by adding a new paragraph 13 as follows:
“All enclosures, coops, hutches, pens, or appurtenances for chicken hens must be fully screened
from public view and neighboring properties with fences, walls, obstructions, or natural screening not
less than six feet (6’) in height.”
Commissioner Coston SECONDED the motion.
Vote on Motion:
Yes: Halstead, Fikes, Coston
No: Glendening, Twait, Woodard
Absent: Greenberg
Vote: 3 Yes, 3 No, 1 Absent - Motion Failed to Adopt.
#11 Commissioner Halstead MOVED to recommend the City Council enact Ordinance No. 3332-2023 with
the recommended amendments from the Planning and Zoning Commission. Commissioner Glendening
SECONDED the motion.
Vote on Motion:
Yes: Halstead, Coston, Glendening, Twait
No: Fikes, Woodard
Absent: Greenberg
Vote: 4 Yes, 2 No, 1 Absent - Motion Passed.