HomeMy WebLinkAbout1999-02-10 p&z packetCITY OF KENAI
PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION
KENAI CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
February 10,1999 - 7:00 p.m.
http a/www. c i. ke n a i. ak. u s
1. CALL TO ORDER:
a. Roll Call
b. Agenda Approval
c. Approval of Minutes: January z7, 1999
d. Consent Agenda
*All items listed with an asterisk (*) are considered to be routine and non-controversial by the
Commission and will be approved by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these
items unless a Commission Member so requests, in which case the item will be removed from the
Consent Agenda and considered in its normal sequence on the agenda as part of the General
Orders.
2. SCHEDULED PUBLIC COMMENT:
3. CONSIDERATION OF PLATS:
4. PUBLIC HEARINGS:
5. NEW BUSINESS:
6. OLD BUSINESS:
7. CODE ENFORCEMENT:
8. REPORTS:
a. City Council
b. Borough Planning
c. Administration
9. PERSONS PRESENT NOT SCHEDULED:
10. INFORMATION ITEMS:
a. KPB Administrative approval NealSand Subdivision
b. KPB extension for Original Townsite of Kenai Rainbow Addition
c. "Planning Commissioner's Corner" from Jan.IFeb. 1999 "Western Planner"
d. Planning Commission Raster
e. ADOT&PF 1~ lyer
11. COMMISSION COMMENTS & QUESTIONS:
12. ADJOURNMENT:
AMENDED AGENDA
CITY OF KENAI
PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION
KENAI CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
January 27,1999 - 7:00 p.m.
htt :1/www.ci.kenai.ak.us
1. CALL TO ORDER:
a. Roll Call
b. Agenda Approval
c. Approval of Minutes: January 13, 199
d. Consent Agenda
*All items listed with an asterisk (*) are considered to be routine and non-controversial by the
Commission and will be approved by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these
items unless a Commission Member so requests, in which case the item will be removed from the
Consent Agenda and considered in its normal sequence on the agenda as part of the General
Orders.
2. SCHEDULED PUBLIC COMMENT:
3. CONSIDERATION OF PLATS:
4. PUBLIC HEARINGS:
a, PZ99-O1--Conditional Use Permit--Charitable Institution and Governmental Building for the
property described as KN T06N R11 W S33, that portion of the W 112 SW 114 SE 114 lying
South of Kenai Spur Road (9711 and 9775 Kenai Spur Highway}. Site proposed for the
Challenger Learning Center and Multi-Purpose Facility. Application submitted by City of
Kenai, 210 Fidalgo, Suite 200, Kenai, Alaska.
5. NEW BUSINESS:
a. 99-03--Landscape/Site Plan Review--Lot 4, Block i, Gusty Subdivision, Add. No. 1, 11536
Kenai Spur Highway, Kenai, Alaska. Application submitted by Zecee Crow, Crow's
Construction and Development, 1006 Craw Court, Kenai, Alaska.
b. Right-of--Way & Easement Vacation--Lots 3 & 4, Shaginoff Subdivision, 5584 & 5616 Kenai
Spur Highway, Kenai, Alaska. Application submitted by Roy Whitford, P.O. Box 4032,
Soldotna, Alaska. Property owned by DeWayne J. Benton, P.O. Box 2646, Kenai, Alaska.
6. OLD BUSINESS:
a. Annual Reports -Gravel Pits -Discussion
7. CODE ENFORCEMENT:
$. REPORTS:
a. City Council
b. Borough Planning
c. Administration
4. PERSONS PRESENT NOT SCHEDULED:
10. INFORMATION ITEMS:
Planning & Zoning Commission
Agenda
Page 2
January 27, 1999
a. KPB Administrative approval Original Townsite of Kenai Laddville Replat No. 3
b. 1998 Planning & Zoning Commission Yearly Report
c. KFB Plat Committee action of 1111199
d. Letter dated 1118/99 to Ron Goecke
e. Ordinance No. 1804-99
f. "Zoning Bulletin" -January 10, 1999
11. COMMISSION COMMENTS & QUESTIONS:
12. AD.IOURNMENT:
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY OF KENAI
PLANNING 8a ZONING COMMISSION
JANUARY 27, 1999 - 7:00 P.M.
KENAI CITY HALL
CHAIRMAN CARL GLICK, PRESIDING
*** MINUTES ***
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Glick called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.
a. Roll Call
Members Present: Ron Goecke, Barb Nord, Donald Ervvin, Phil Bryson,
Carl Glick
Robert Newbry arrived at 7:02 p.m.
Members Absent: None
Also Present: Councilman Duane Bannock, Adnninistrative Assis-
tant Marilyn. Kebschull, Contract Secretary Victoria
Askin
b. Agenda Approval
GOECKE MOVED TO APPROVE THE AGENDA WITH
INCLUSION OF HANDOUTS PRESENTED AT MEETING AND
ASKED FOR UNANIMOUS CONSENfi. BRYSON SECONDED.
AGENDA WAS UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED AS PRESENTED.
c. Approval of Minutes: January 13, 1998
GOECKE MOVED TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF THE
MEETING OF JANUARY 13, 1998 AND ASKED FOR
UNANIMOUS CONSENT. ERWIN SECONDED. MINUTES WERE
UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED AS PRESENTED.
2. SCHEDULED PUBLIC COMMENT -None
3. CONSIDERATION OF PLATS -None
4. PUBLIC HEARINGS
a. PZ99-O1-Conditional Use Permit-Charitable Institution and
Government Building for the Property Described as KN T06N
R11W 533, That Portion of the W ~/~ S ~4 SE ~4 Lying South of
Planning & Zoning Commission
January 27, 1.999
Page 1
Kenai Spur Road (9711 and 9775 Kenai Spur Highway). Site
Proposed for the Challenger Learning Center and Multi-
purpose Facility. Application Submitted by City of Kenai, 210
Fidalgo, Suite 200, Kenai, Alaska.
NORD MOVED TO APPROVE PZ99-O1, CONDITIONAL USE
PERMIT. GOECKE SECONDED.
Discussion
Glick opened the floor to public hearing.
Rick Ross, Kenai City Manager, stated he was at the meeting to
answer questions regarding the property. He continued, the
parcel was located working in conjunction with the Borough and
School District and determined to be the ideal location for the
Challenger Learning Center as well as athree-sided, covered,
outdoor recreational facility. The parties involved don't see the
piece of property ever being developed as residential property or
for commercial purposes. Facilities are co-located with
educational facilities with ingress and egress. Cooperative
agreements are in place with the school for the use of ingress and
egress of the parking facilities. It is felt at this time the parking
facilities are adequate for anticipated use. If there is to be
expanded use of the facilities, the City is prepared to work with
the State in putting in signals to expedite the flow of traffic.
Glick asked if not adding further ingress/egress is adequate.
Ross responded affirmatively, further stating he didn't think the
Challenger will add a lot in the way of traffic because it will be
used primarily during the school day, with perhaps one or two
buses. Increased need may present itself if there is another major
high school event scheduled at the same time, such as a hockey
game. This is something the City will monitor. Based upon
anticipated uses and hours of use, the City doesn't foresee a
problem at this time.
Debbie Sonberg, 410 Cinderella, Kenai, Alaska -Stated she
feels a tremendous amount of thought has gone into the planning
of the facilities. These are the types of facilities she had hoped
would go in that area, something very educational and community
oriented. She is pleased to see the existing tree buffers will
remain. She feels monitoring the traffic and possibly putting in a
traffic light if it becomes hazardous, is a good idea. Sonberg
stated she lives in the neighborhood across from the high school
and approved of it being in her neighborhood. She expressed her
appreciation for all the effort that has gone into the project.
Planning 8v Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page 2
Kebschull noted the recommendation that a Landscape Site Plan
be required. Normally it would not be required in a residential
zone but because it will be a commercial type development, she
believes the Commission should have the opportunity to review a
site plan.
Glick went on to state the Commission had received a letter from
Nathan Kiel requesting it be read into the record because he
couldn't be in attendance. The letter stated:
"I am writing to urge you to issue aconditional-use permit for the
property adjacent to Kenai Central High School and Rogers Road.
As a thirty-year resident of Kenai and immediate resident of the
neighborhood in question I am concerned that our city take a
conservative approach to development. I can assure you that this
property will be developed in a positive and responsible manner,
I live approximately one city block from the property in question.
I have visited with several neighbors in the Rogers Road area and
feel confident this project has their support. As a teacher at
Kenai Central High School, I can attest that the majority of faculty
and students are strongly supportive of said facility. As a parent I
lack forward to the numerous opportunities this facility will offer
our children and community.
The request before you this evening is a culmination of efforts by
local residents and city officials to secure the aforementioned
parcel for the purpose of a multi-use recreational facility. The
benefits of this facility have been well documented at City Council
meetings and in press releases. Over twenty user groups have
expressed support of the project. As a member of the Site
Planning and Facility Design team, I can assure you that every
effort was made to find the ideal site for this facility without
causing a negative impact on residential areas. This indeed is
the perfect location for such a facility. Thank you for your time
and consideration."
Bryson noted for the record he would be abstaining from the vote
because of involvement in the civil engineering of bath projects.
VOTE
NORD Yes BRYSON Abstained
ERWIN Yes NEWBRY Yes
GOECKE Yes GLICK Yes
MOTION PASSED.
Planning & Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page 3
5. NEW BUSINESS
a. 99-03-Landscape/Site Plan Review-Lot 4, Block 1, Gusty
Subdivision, Add. No. 1, Kenai Spur Highway, Kenai, Alaska.
Application Submitted by Zecee Crow, Crow's Construction
and Development, 100b Crow Court, Kenai, Alaska.
GOECKE MOVED TO APPROVE RESOLUTION NO. 99-03,
LANDSCAPE/SITE PLAN REVIEW, LOT 4, BLOCK 1, GUSTY
SUBDIVISION, ADD. NO. 1. BRYSON SECONDED.
Discussion
Kebschull noted the artists' rendition is not accurate as the trees
at the back of the building are not currently there. The vacant lot
is cleared at this time.
Bryson understood this rendition was for conceptual approval.
Glick answered affirmatively, this rendition was presented to the
City Council to obtain the lease.
VOTE
ERWIN Yes NEWBRY Yes
GOECKE Yes BRYSON Yes
NORD Yes GLICK Yes
MOTION PASSED.
b. Right-of--Way & Easement Vacation -Lots 3 & 4, Shaginoff
Subdivision, 5584 8s 5616 Kenai Spur Highway, Kenai, Alaska.
Application Submitted by Roy Whitford, P.O. Box 4032,
Soldotna, Alaska. Property Owned by DeWayne J. Benton,
P.O. Box 2646, Kenai, Alaska.
GOECKE MOVED TO APPROVE THE RIGHT-OF-WAY
EASEMENT VACATION. ERWIN SECONDED.
Discussion
Bryson clarified the motion was to approve the right-of--way
vacation and was separate from the walkway, he expressed his
preference to address them separately.
Goecke stated he moved only to approve the right-of--way and
would probably have moved for both had he thought it through.
Planning & Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page 4
However, since Bryson had noted his preference to separate them,
he asked for concurrence from the second and it was left as the
right-of--way only.
Glick clarified the Commission was discussing the right-of-way
vacation only.
Bryson noted he felt the right-of--way vacation was appropriate.
VOTE
NEWBRY Yes BRYSON Yes
GOECKE Yes NORD Yes
NEWBRY Yes CLICK Yes
MOTION PASSED
BRYSON MOVED FOR APPROVAL OF THE EASEMENT
VACATION. GOECKE SECONDED.
Discussion
Bryson noted there is probably not a walkway utilized through
that area and for pedestrians, from the point the easement leaves
Phillips Drive, there is a 2,000' walk to get to the highway rather
than 500'. Even though it's not constructed and not supposed to
be constructed, he asked the Commission to keep in mind it is an
easement and not aright-of--way and it should remain.
Glick stated it appears to follow through on the other side of
Phillips Drive, back to the other property.
Goecke stated the problem he had with not vacating the easement
is if there is an easement through that property, the landowner is
responsible at this time of the year to make sure it is open to get
through. He added, a case in point would be the owner of the
commercial property cleaned everything out up to the road and
now has to keep the road open even though he no longer utilizes
the commercial property in order to give others an opening
through his property to get to the property behind him. Goecke
stated he would vote in favor of this vacation based on that
premise.
Nord asked for clarification if the 40' frontage road is vacated,
would it eliminate the walkway 40' from the Kenai Spur.
Planning & Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page S
~1ack La Shat suggested if the 40' frontage road were to be vacated
and the 10' easement retained, that it be extended to the Kenai
Spur.
Glick clarified since the walkway has not been built, there is just
an easement there and it doesn't have to be kept clear unless a
walkway is built.
La Shat stated he wasn't sure the property owner had the respon-
sibility to plow snow but did have the responsibility to keep the
area clear of structures, etc.
Glick asked for an amendment to the motion to extend the ease-
ment to the Kenai Spur Highway. Bryson proposed to vote an the
motion and if it failed he would then introduce a new motion.
Erwin noted his being in favor of keeping walkway easements as
they allow a way for young people to get back and forth. The
easement makes it easier for people in the back rows to walk to
either the highway or other access. He added, he wanted to see
foot traffic encouraged, not blocked.
Goecke stated his concern whether or nat the 10' easement is
being used because it if is not plowed, there is a berm, which
means the people are going to be coming out of their regular
driveways because they are plowed. He stated he would still vote
to vacate because he didn`t feel the easement was necessary at
this point.
VOTE
BRYSON No ERWIN No
GOECKE Yes NEWBRY Yes
NORD Yes GLICK No
MOTION FAILED.
BRYSON MOVED THE 10' WALKWAY EASEMENT EXTEND TO
THE KENAI SPUR HIGHWAY IF THE RIGHT-OF-WAY IS
VACATED BY COUNCIL. NORD SECONDED.
VOTE
GOECKE No NEWBRY Yes
NORD Yes BRYSON Yes
ERWIN Yes GLICK Yes
MOTION PASSED.
Planning 8v Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page 6
6. OLD BUSINESS
a. Annual Reports -Gravel Pits -Discussion
Kebschull stated the staff had provided the Commission with a
map that depicts the gravel pits currently in operation by permit
with the City of Kenai. Aiso shown is the Cone property which
was in grandfather status; he does not have a gravel pit permit.
In addition, the City is trying to clarify if the Beaver Loop
Partnership is an operational pit. Site visits have been conducted
and a iot of information accumulated. Pit owners have been
contacted and asked to respond to some of the City's concerns.
Ross reiterated information Kebschull related and stated he would
like to receive insights from members who had been involved with
the gravel pit issue, particularly regarding buffers. He stated he
was not asking for pre judgment on anything, just insights on
what issues and concerns had been presented in the past, both
from their point of view and from citizenry.
Ross went on to designate the Krogseng to State DNR and up to
Zubeck Pits as rear buffers. The buffers between the pits are
designated side buffers. Front buffers are those that join any-
thing but the City of Kenai or other property and are intended to
be marked to assure their compliance and enforce compliance.
Rear buffers adjoin City property.
Ross added, the City believes there are some encroachments of
that buffer. The City needs gravel but doesn't believe they will be
able to access or develop this area for gravel. He would like to
look at the rear buffer, come behind the property line
approximately 200' and make it available for buffer and sloping to
the privately operated pits. The pit owners could now operate up
to their existing property line, and purchase buffer from the City
of Kenai. One issue not yet resolved is this proposal involves a
section line on both sides of the properties, as well as other
issues. Ross asked the Commission for information in their
dealings regarding buffers.
Another issue to possibly be brought before the Commission is
the side buffers between pits. Right now, a 150' buffer is required
to be maintained with 2-to-1 sloping between the pits.
Eventually, when reclaimed in that area, reclamation will
probably be ponds, lakes, etc. There have already been some
encroachments on the side buffers on the Krogseng property.
From the City's perspective, the question has been raised
regarding the need for side buffers between pits, i.e., if pit
Planning & Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page 7
operators come to agreement between themselves, what would be
'~ the ramifications if they were allowed to work the property line
into one continuous pit. If no cooperative agreement exists
between the owners, then sloping would occur.
Ross' questions are: Why do we have side buffers? What has tes-
timony been in the past? What issues and concerns can he
expect to hear from the Commission as well as from citizens? He
asked the same questions regarding the rear buffers as well.
Goecke related the most important issue he had heard in the tes-
timony was about the setbacks on the front side. No one has
expressed concern about the back side. He personally stated he
felt elimination of the side buffers was a good idea. The biggest
concern citizens living on Beaver Loop have expressed is truck
traffic. He thinks Foster has allowed Krogseng to use his
driveway rather than put in an. additional driveway to Beaver
Loop. As long as the two pit operators can get along, he believes
it's a good idea. He feels with very little work Doyle could came
out of Foster's driveway as well. He added, he feels the Beaver
Loop right-of--way should be cleared back further than it is
because of the moose and caribou.
Glick related he remembers before he was on the Commission
there was work setting up the buffer zones. In most cases the
gravel pits weren't side by side, but there were a few scattered
ones and that was when the buffer zones were established. He
added, he recalled there being a side buffer already gone between
two owners and didn't recall there being a problem. Personally,
he had no problem with side buffers, but they should be retained
where there is adjoining property that isn't a gravel pit.
Bryson stated he remembered the side buffer that was eliminated
was agreed to by the two parties. He added, he felt side buffers
could be eliminated and be administratively approved. He noted,
he was not in favor of eliminating front buffers.
Glick stated he felt setbacks should be established from Beaver
Loop Road and most public comment had reflected that concern
as they help to screen out noise, dust and sight of the pits.
Erwin agreed with Glick's comments regarding the noise and dust
and establishing front setbacks.
Nord expressed not being in favor of eliminating the side buffers
but if there was a cooperative agreement between the two pit
owners, then it wouldn't seem to be a problem. If such an
agreement were filed, it could be handled administratively and not
Planning & Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page 8
be in violation. Testimony she has heard had been concern
regarding the noise, dust and traffic from the area. She added,
she felt she would like to see the front setbacks maintained and if
the City could acquire gravel through an agreement with the
property owners for land and sloping, it would be a good deal.
Newbry stated he lives off Beaver Loop and expressed his agree-
ment with Nord regarding the noise, dust and traffic issues.
Ross stated, he believed all the buffers were required by code so a
change of code would eventually be needed. He asked if there had
been any testimony in the past regarding the rear of the pits,
either from adjoining property owners or ones who could observe
the pits from higher elevations.
Glick and Bryson stated they didn't recall any concerns in the
past. Bryson asked if there had been encroachments onto private
property. Ross answered he didn't know because they were using
aerial photography to review and didn't have any marking of
buffers at this time. He added, if a program could be put
together, one of the things the City would want is clear, delineated
property lines so front buffers could be maintained and enforced
and if rear buffer problems were approved for this type of
resolution, which works to the advantage of the City for gravel,
then it could be enforced.
7. CODE ENFORCEMENT
8. REPORTS
a. City Council
Duane Bannock directed the Commission to the Agenda of the
City Council January 20 meeting. He addressed the highlights:
Wm. Nelson & Associates presented a proposal for the
Cunningham Park improvement to be funded primarily by the
Kenai River Classic up to $100,000. There was considerable
debate regarding the boat launch proposed. Majority of the
Council felt it was not in the best interest of Cunningham Park
and a proposal had gone back to Nelson 8~ Associates to tailor the
ramp down to perhaps a "hand launch," i.e., rubber raft, canoe,
etc. Council felt by putting in a first-class boat launch it would
completely change the flavor of what Cunningham Park was
intended for and its present use.
Ordinance No. 1809-99 -Beginning the middle of February,
anyone applying to the Planning & Zoning Commission on an
Planning 8~ Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page 9
issue requiring public hearing will have to have the subject
property posted. There was some debate as to the size of the sign,
with consensus it be the same size as a real estate sign. Bannock
stated he will ask for review of this ordinance in one year to see if
it has been successful.
Resolution No. 99-3 -- The Council feels the new term "Optimum
Yield" is not in the City's best interest for a healthy Kenai River
salmon run.
Ordinance No. 181,0-99 -This came from Planning and Zoning
regarding City owned property located in Soldotna deemed not
required for Public Use. Tt was on the Consent Agenda and will
comae up at the next scheduled Council meeting.
Item H-4 -Renewal of the Health and Social Services Lease -
This will hopefully be the last lease passed because by the time
this lease is up, the Public Health Clinic should have their own
building in the City of Kenai.
Iteyn H-6 -Anew ATM machine will be going in at the Kenai
Airport. Cast will be $2.00 to use it.
item H-7 -Discussion regarding a Future Economic Outlook
Forum. A couple of years ago, aone-day Economic Forum was
held. The Council is looking at expanding on that and having
another one this spring.
January 26, 1999 Special Council Meeting -- The Council met
on January 26 in a special meeting to interview the six remaining
council candidates running for appointment to the Kenai City
Council. Council will be making that appointment at the next
regularly scheduled meeting of February 3rd with the new
member being sworn in on February 17.
Bannock related he would not be at the next scheduled Planning
& Zoning meeting. He added, he was not aware of who the
Planning 8~ Zoning liaison to the Council will be.
b. Borough Planning
Bryson stated the Borough Planning meeting was held January
2Ca at City Council Chambers in Homer. There was a request to
vacate a portion of Bay Ridge Road bounded to Emerald Highland
Estates. This was carried forward from approximately a year ago.
After testimony was taken, the request to vacate was denied. This
involved two adjacent lots wanting to vacate the entire right-of-
way and create a cul-de-sac situation.
Planning 8s Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page 10
A public hearing was held on Ordinance 9833 repealing KPB
21.13. This has the potential of coming before the Assembly at its
next meeting. There were several recommendations from both
public and the Planning Commission. They will go the Assembly
in an advisory manner and a substitute ordinance has been
proposed.
Item E-3, a utility easement vacation was denied upon recom-
mendation of the Borough staff.
Item E-4, a public hearing to vacate the 33' wide roadway and
utility easement of Marysville Too Subdivision was postponed by
request of the petitioner. That portion was opened to the public
and additional testimony was taken.
Public Hearing items included a new petition to vacate a portion
of Ptarmigan Heights Drive right-of--way. This was postponed by
request of the staff in order to collect additional information.
Vacation of a 66' section line easement of Sections 12 and 13,
Township 6 South, Range 14 West was proposed to be worked out
between a group that wished to maintain a ski trail through that
area as it is across private property but is a section Iine easement.
There will be some negotiation taking place.
A proposal was presented to name an unnamed private road
"Taxidermy Road." There was protest and the issue will go to staff
to be worked out with the petitioner and protester. Hopefully,
something compatible for all three groups will be developed.
Item F.4 - a land use permit application to operate a gravel site in
the Homer area, was rescheduled.
Item F.5 -naming two unnamed bays near Halibut Cove, near
Ismailof Island to Rosie's Bight and Rusty's Lagoon, was
approved.
Bryson added, the remainder of the agenda was not addressed
because it was after midnight.
c. Administration
Kebschull drew attention to the yearly report that was provided.
If there any question, direct them to her and she will provide any
additional information.
Planning 8v Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page 11
9. PERSONS PRESENT NOT SCHEDULED
Bill Popp briefly addressed the Commission, thanking them for the
positive vote on the permit for the Challenger Learning Center site and
the multi-use ice rink. He noted, this is an exciting project and they are
moving along at a rapid pace on design and development and look
forward to beginning construction in the very near future.
10. INFORMATION ITEMS
a. KPB Administrative approval Original Townsite of Kenai Laddville
Replat No. 3
b. 1998 Planning & Zoning Commission Yearly Report
c. KPB Plat Committee action of 1 / 11 / 99
d. Latter dated 1/18/99 to Ron Goecke
e. Ordinance No. 1809-99
f. "Zoning bulletin" -January 10, 1999
g. Letter from Nathan Kiel
h. Map of existing gravel pits in Beaver Loop area
i. Information on Planning Commissioner Training Seminar
11. COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS /QUESTIONS
Commissioner Glick asked Kebschull if wanted names of
commissioners interested in attending the Planning Commissioners
Seminar referred to in the handout they received. Kebschull answered it
was for informational purposes as the City does not fund training far
Planning Commissioners but thought some of the Commission may be
interested in attending on their own.
Commissioner Nord thanked Kebschull for providing information on the
Seminar.
12.
GOECKE MOVED TO ADJOURN. MEETING ADJOURNED AT 8:00
P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
Victoria Askin
Contract Secretary
Planning & Zoning Commission
January 27, 1999
Page 12
OR
AGENDA
KENAI CITY COUNCIL -REGULAR MEETING
FEBRUARY 3, 1999
7:00 P.M.
KENAI CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
http:/ /www.ci.kenai.ak.us
ITEM A: CALL TO ORDER
1. Pledge of Allegiance
2. Roll Call
3. Agenda Approval
4. Consent Agenda
*All items listed with arz asterisk {*) are considered to be routine and
non-controversial by the Council and will be approved by one motion.
There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a Council
Member so requests, in which case the item will be removed from the
Consent Agenda and considered in its normal sequence on the agenda
as part of the General Orders.
ITEM B: SCHEDULED PUBLIC COMMENTS { 10 minutes)
ITEM C• PUBLIC HEARINGS
~~~/ ~. 1. Ordinance No. 1810-99 -- Finding That Certain City-Owned Land,
Described as Lot 1-B, Block 2, Pavilion Subdivision, is Not Required for
a Public Purpose.
2. Resolution No. 99-5 -- Transferring $35,822.15 to the '98 Water
System Improvement Capital Project Fund.
3. Resolution No. 99-b -- Awarding a Professional Services Contract for
Engineering Design and Inspection on the Project Entitled Crow Court
Street Improvements to Wm. J. Nelson & Associates for the Not-To-
Exceed Amount of $7,9Q4.
4. Resolution No. 99-7 -- Requesting Safe Communities Funding From
the Department of Community and Regional Affairs.
S. Resolution No. 99-8 -- Supporting the Establishment of Public Access
to State Lands on the West Side of Cook Inlet.
~1-
ITEM D: COMMISSION COMMITTEE REPORTS
1. Council on Aging
2. Airport Commission
3. Harbor Commission
4. Library Commission
5. Parks 8~ Recreation Commission
6. Planning 8s Zaning Commission
7. Miscellaneous Commissions and Committees
a. Beautification Committee
b. Historic Dzstrict Board
c. Kenai Visitors 8~ Convention Bureau Board
d. Alaska Municipal League Report
ITEM E• MINUTES
1. *Regular Meeting of January 20, 1999.
ITEM F: CORRESPONDENCE
ITEM G: OLD BUSINESS
~~.~Y~-zP_.'' 1. Discussion -- Appointment of Council Member.
2. Discussion -- Multi-Use Facility Update (Peter Klauder)
ITEM H: NEW BUSINESS
,Q~,~,p~~~ 1. Bills to be Paid, Bills to be Ratified
~} e,,~~ 2. Purchase Drders Exceeding $2,500
/~'~ 3. *Ordinance No. 1811-99 -- Deleting the Age Requirement in KMC
23.40.095 for Eligibility for the Supplemental Retirement Program.
4. Discussion -- Council Liaison Assignments (Boards, Commissions and
Committees)
5. Discussion -- Airport Terminal Restaurant/Draft Request far Proposals.
6. Discussion -- Sewer Treatment Plan Expansion/Parking Area.
-2-
~) ITEM I: ADMINISTRATION REPORTS
1. Mayor
2. City Manager
3. Attorney
4. City Clerk
5. Finance Director
6. Public Works
7. Airport Manager
ITEM J: DISCUSSION
1. Citizens (eve minutes)
2. Council
EXECUTIVE SESSION -None Scheduled
ITEM K:
-3-
~:
. 3 ,~ ^~
KENAI PENINSULA BOROUGH PLAT COMMITTEE
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
BOROUGH ADMINISTRATION BUILDIN
144 NORTH BINKLEY
SOLDOTNA, ALASKA R~C~jV
IA
Members:
Peggy Boscacci
Seldovia City
Term Expires 2000
Elils Hensley
Mikiski
Term Expires 1999
Brent Johnson
Kasilof Area
Term Expires 2000
Ann Whitmore-Painter
Moose Pass Area
Term Expires 2000
ALTERiVATES:
Philip Bryson
Kenai City
Term Expires 2001
Robert Clutts
Anchor Point
Term Expires 2007
Leroy Gannaway
Homer City
Term Expires 2001
B
C.
February 8, 1999 5:30 P.M
Tentative Agenda
CALL TO ORDER
ROLL CALL
~D
F~ 3 ~
cry
~~NfNG~ rK~!yAl
APPROVAL OF AGENDA ,EXCUSED ABSENCES, AND
MINUTES
1. Agenda
2. MemberlAlternate Excused Absences
a. Bab Clutts
D
E
3. Minutes -None
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
1. Resurrection Peak SID; Exit Glacier Road
Preliminary; Johnson Surveying/M. Fisher
KPB File 99-003
Carried forward from January 26, 1999
CONSIDERATION OF PLATS
1. Seaman Subdivision; Kachemak City;
Preliminary; ImhofflSeaman
KPB File 99-013
2. Kings Creek SID Urban Addn No. 3; east of Fritz Creek
Preliminary; lmho'fflUrban
KPB File 99-014
3. Winding Trails; Kachemak City
Preliminary; SeabrightlCalkinslBeachy
KPB File 99-015
E. ADJOURNMENT
"s" ..
~ ;
1
•s ..
i,
,r..
Then xt regularly scheduled Plat Committee meeting is February 22,
. 9 5:30 p.m. in the Planning Department {top floor}, Borough
d#nini tration Building, 144 North Binkley, Soldotna.
,~
.~
ri
~~)
KENAI PENINSULA BOROUGH PLANNING COMMISSION
BOROUGH ASSEMBLY CHAMBERS
144 NORTH BINKLEY
SOLDOTNA,ALASKA !`~
February 8, 1999 7:30 P.M. ~4 CE'~
~~
.fohn Hatnmelman
Chairman
Areawide
Term Expires 1999
Philip Hryson
Vice Chairman
Kenai City
T'errn Expires 2001
Ann Whitmore-Painter
Parliamentarian
fvloose Pass Area
Tenn Expires 2000
Peggy G. Boscacci
PC Member
Seldovia City
Term Expires 2000
I Wayne Carpenter
PC Memher
Seward City
Term Expires 1999
Robert Ciutls
PC Member
Anchor Point
'term Expires 2001
Wes Coleman
PC Member
Soldotna City
Term Expires 1999
Leroy Gannaway
PC Member
Homer City
Term Expires 2001
Ellis Hensley. ,ir.
PC Memher
1~fikiski
Term Expires 1999
Hrent.lohnson
1'C Memher
KasilofArea
Term Expires 2000
,lim Skogstad
PC Memher
~ Hope
'term Expires 2001
Tentative Agenda F~
A. CALL TO ORDER
B. ROLL CALL P~NN,e ~ ~`~ ART ~
'}'~FN
C. APFROVAL OF REGULAR AGENDA AND ADOPTION OF CONSENT
AGENDA
Ali items on the consent agenda are considered routine and nnncontroversiai by the Planning Commission and
wi[! be approved by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a Planning
Commissioner or someone from the public so requests, in which case the item will be removed from the
consent agenda and considered to its normal sequence an the regular agenda.
]fyou wish to comment on a consent agenda item or a regular agenda item other than a public hearing, please
advise the recording secretary before the meeting begins, and she wilE inform the Chairman o1 your wish to
comment.
I . Time Extension Requests -None
2. Plats Granted Administrative Approval
3. Plats Granted Approval Under 20.04.070 -None
4. Plat Amendment Requests
a. McNeil Point SID Lot 5 Replat; Plat 98-50 Homer
Recording District;; KPB File 99-16 [Carlos Freeman];
Location: East of East End road, west of McNeil Canyon
5. Coastal Management Prograrn
a. Coastal Management Program Consistency Reviews
I) Timber Harvest; Greg Stout Logging, Inc.; KK
99-01; Location: Ninilchik
b. Conclusive Consistency Determinations Received from
DGC -None
c. Administrative Determinations
6. KPBPC Resolutions -None
7. Commissioner Excused Absences
a. Bob Clutts
•~
! ,
- • ~5~ _
'; i~~~ i
~,:~-~~
v :-
:;
t
8. Minutes
4
a. The January 26, 1999 Planning Commission minutes will
• ; be on the February 22 consent agenda.
s
D. PUBLIC COMMENT/PRESENTATIONS
(Items other than those appearing on the agenda. Limited to three minutes per speaker unless previous
arrangements are made.)
E. UNFINISHED BUSINESS
1. Time Extension Request; Vacate access easement; B.E. Uminiski
Lots 27-C and 28-B (Gov't Lots 27 & 28); Section 14, Township 6
South, Range I3 West, Seward Meridian, AK; Location: City of
Homer; KFB 97-109 [Carlos Freeman]; carried forward from
January 11, 1999
2. Public Hearing; Aland-use permit application has been received by
the Borough to operate a gravel site; Location: Homer area, off
Eagleaerie Avenue near Skyline Drive. The entire parcel is 112.71
acres, of which 2.5 acres is proposed for a material site. The
applicant has received a Material Site Permit fora .625 acre
portion of the parcel in November 1998; Douglas & Sandra Stark;
carried forward from January 26, 1999
3. Plat Waiver Application; Rolco Pacific; KPBPC Resolution 99-04:
Granting a platting waiver for certain lands within Sections 3 and
10, Township 4 South, Range 14 West, Seward Meridian, Alaska;
KPB File 99-004 [Rolco Pacific]; Location: Anchor Point area;
carried forward from January 26, 1999
4. Plat Waiver Application; Johnson, George E & Alice; KPBPC
Resolution 99-05: Granting a platting waiver for certain lands
within Section 1, Township 5 North, Range 9 West, Seward
Meridian, Alaska; KPB File 99-012 [George Johnson]; Location:
Swanson River Road area; carried forward from January 26, l 999
5. Time Extension Request; Laubner Addition to Seward Goresen-
Carlson 1996 Replat; Second and Van Buren Avenues; KPB File
97-007 [Integrity Surveys]; Location: within the City of Seward
carried forward from January 26, l 999
6. Coastal Management Program Considerations; Barge/Floating
a
Facility; Bay Barge Company; AK9812-O1 AA; Location:
Resurrection Bay/Fox Island; carried forward from ]anuary 26,
1999
F. PUBLIC HEARINGS
1. Vacate a portion of the 40 foot wide frontage road dedicated by
Shaginoff Subdivision (Plat 78-188}; AND, vacate the ten foot
walkway easement within Lot 4 of said subdivision. Portion of
frontage road petitioned for vacation is bounded by Lots 3 and 4,
Shaginoff Subdivision; being within Section 6, Township 5 North,
Range 10 West, Seward Meridian, Alaska; Location: City of
Kenai.
2. Proposed Reclassifications of Certain Borough Parcels in the
Moose Point and Gray Cliff Subdivisions; Location: Nikiski
3. Proposed Reclassification of Tract 1-B, Exit Glacier Subdivision,
filed as Plat Number 97-12, Seward Recording District, Containing
8.138 acres more or Iess; Location: Seward area
4. Land-use Permit Application to Operate a Gravel Site; Mile 40 of
the Sterling Highway. The parcel is 120.0 acres; NW 1/4, Section
16, TSN, R2 W; KPBPC Resolution 99-]0; Location: Cooper
Landing/Quartz Creek
G. VACATIONS NOT REQUIRING A PUBLIC HEARING -None
H. SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS
Time Extension Request; Original Townsite of Kenai Rainbow
Addition; KPB File 97-167 Integrity Surveys/Sunland Corp]
Location: Main Street and Highland Avenue; Location: City of
Kenai
L CONSIDERATION OF PLATS
Four plats are scheduled to be reviewed by the Plat Committee.
J. KENAI RIVER HABITAT PROTECTION (KFB 21.1$) -None
K. COASTAL MANAGEMENT PROGRAM CONSIDERATIONS
L. OTHER/NEW BUSINESS
Resurrection Pass Trail System; Outfitter/Guide Use
M. ASSEMBLY COMMENTS
N. DIRECTOR'S COMMENTS
1. Results of the advisory vote for Ordinance 98-47; Establishing an
Advisory Planning Commission in the Greater Seward Area
2. Resolution 99-009: Establishing an Economic Analyst Position in
the Planning Department
O. COMMISSIONER COMMENTS
P. PENDING ITEMS FOR FUTURE ACTION
1. Permit Application for a Sand, Gravel or Material Site; Anchor
Point; Clif Shafer, carried forward from June 8, 1998.
Postponed until the Coastal Management Program consistency
review is re-started and concluded.
2. Proposed Residential and Preservation reclassification of borough
land located in the Cooper Landing area described as Tracts B
through N, Sunrise View Subdivision (preliminary plat} and a
portion lying within the S'/z of Section 25, TSN, R3 W, S.M.,
Alaska, pursuant to KPB Code of Ordinances, Chapter 17.10.080;
carried forward from December 14, 1998.
Postponed until brought back to the Commission by staff.
3. Naming an Unnamed Private Road to Taxidermy Road, within
Section 32, TSS, R14W, S.M. Unnamed road is located 1,700 feet
west of the intersection of the Old Sterling Highway and the
Sterling Highway, south of Anchor Point; carried forward from
January 26, l 999.
Postponed until brought back to the Commission by staff.
4. Public Hearing: Vacate the full width of the 33 foot wide roadway
and utility easement as shown on the plat of Marysville Too (Plat
86-93 Homer Recording District); and further described in the
federal patent. Said easement, within the westerly 33 feet of
Marysville Too Subdivision is located within Section 4, Township
S South, Range 15 West, Seward Meridian, Alaska; carried
forward from December l4, 1998 and January 26, 1999.
Postponed to March 22, 1999 per petitioner request.
Ordinance 99-01 Enacting Chapter 21.30 Providing for the
Creation of a Residential Subdivision District Regulating
Commercial and Industrial Uses Composed of All Residential
Subdivision Districts in the Borough Outside of Home Rule and
First Class Cities; carried forward from ,lanuary 11, 1999.
Postponed to February 22, 1999.
6. Ordinance 99-02 Re-enacting Definitions in lndividual Chapters of
Title 21 and Adopting a Single Chapter of Uniform Definitions for
Title 21; carried forward from January 11, 1999.
Postponed to February 22, 1999.
7. Petition to vacate twenty feet of the I 00 foot width of a portion of
Ptarmigan Heights Drive public right-of--way. Vacate the easterly
twenty feet lying adjacent to Lot 3, Block 4, Birch Side Acres
Subdivision Unit 3 (Plat 73-1019 HRD}; being within Section 11,
Township 6 South, Range 13 West, Seward Meridian, Alaska; and
within Kachemak City; KPB File 98-277; carried forward from
January 26, 1999.
Postponed to February 22, 1999.
8. Vacate the sixty-six foot wide section line easement centered on
line common to Sections 12 and 13, Township G South, Range 14
West, Seward Meridian, Alaska; and in the Hamer Recording
District. Portion petitioned to be vacated lies between West Hill
Road and a point approximately 1300 feet westerly of West Hill
Road; KPB File 98-226; carried forward from January 26, 1999.
Postponed to February 22, 1999.
Q. ADJOURNMENT
PLAT COMMITTEE
The Plat Committee will meet at 5:30 p.m. on February 8, 1999 in the Planning
Department (top floor), Borough Administration Building, 144 North Binkley,
Soldotna.
FUTURE MEETINGS
PLAT COMMITTEE
The next regularly scheduled Plat Committee meeting is February 22, 1999 at
5:30 p.m., Planning Department {top floor}, Borough Administration Building,
144 North Binkley, Soldotna.
PLANNING COMMISSION
The next regularly scheduled Planning Commission meeting is February 22, 1999
at 7:30 p.m. in the Borough Assembly Chambers, 144 North Binkley, Soldotna.
MISCELLANEOUS INFORMATIONAL ITEMS
NO ACTION REQUIRED
1. March 1 I-13, 1999 Planning Commissioner Training, Anchorage
2. Community Planning Workshop; Anchor Point, Happy Valley, Stariski,
Nikolaevsk
3. January 28, 1999 Letter from Roberta Highland Regarding Ordinance 98-
33
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
Phone: 907-262-4441, extension 260
Phone: toll Tree within the Borough 1-500-478-4441, extension 260
Fax: 907-262-8618
e-mail address: planning@bvrough.kenai.ak.us
web site: www.borough.kenai.ak.us/planningdept
OTHER MEETINGS
Funny River Advisory Planning Commission
Moose Pass Advisory Planning Commission
Kachemak Bay Advisory Planning Commission
Kachemak Bay Advisory Planning Commission
Cooper Landing Advisory Flanning Commission
February 2
February 3
February 4
February 18
February 18
G
~~
CITY QF KENAI
" C?,cl C?cy~r,~l o~ y4lc.~ha
210 FIDALQQ AYE., SUITE 200 KENAI, ALASKA 99811-7784
TELEPHONE 807-283-7535
FAX 907-283-3014
II
~~:
MEMO:
TO: Planning & Zoning Commission ~
FROM: Marilyn Kebschull, Planning & Zoning Administration
DATE: February 5, 1999
SUBJECT: SETBACKS -ADMINISTRATIVE EXEMPTIONS
Bob Springer, Building Official, would like the Commission to reconsider a passible
code change for administrative exemptions for setback requirements. In June 1998, the
Commission passed a resolution amending the Development Requirements Table, which
included an administrative exemption. The Council passed an ordinance adopting the
new Development Requirements Table but removed the exemption.
Mr. Springer has drafted an amendment and would like the Commission's input as to
whether they feel it is appropriate to hold a public hearing and attempt to amend Title 14.
The suggested draft is,
ADMINISTRATIVE EXEMPTIONS:
Setbacks:
The administrative official may reduce,setback requirements up to twelve
(12) inches after submittal of a plot plan or an as-built survey stamped by a state
registered land surve. or and investigation and finding that the resulting lesser
setback would meet the purpose.of the standards. This exemption would not
applj to variances and encroachments previously granted by_,_,the Planning and
Zoning Commission.
A review of the past year's activity shows that there was only one case wherein this
exemption would have applied. This was PZ98-63, which was for 1.2".
Does the Commission feel it approuriate to consider drafting. an amendment for
administrative exemptions?
~v~
KENAI PENINSULA BOROUGH
144 N. BINICLEY • SOLOpTNA, ALASKA ' 99669-7599
BUSINESS (907) 262-4441 FAX (907)262-1892
:-
j~~
MIKE NAVARRE
MAYOR
ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVAL
Subdivision: NealSand Subdivision
KPB File 98-i94
The Kenai Peninsula Borough Planning Commission has reviewed the above subdivision plat.
Administrative Approval has been granted by the undersigned on 3anuary 21, 1999. The time
limit for Piing the plat with the District Recorder will expire one yeaz from approval date.
~.J~-C-~
Mary T` 11
Acting Platting Officer
NOTARY ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
Subscribed and sworn before me this day of hLl (L , 1999.
Notary P lic for State of Alaska
My Commission Expires: ~ 2.- I Q - BUD 1
SURVEY FIRM HAS BEEN ADVISED OF ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS, iF ANY, TO
BE COMPLIED WITH PRIOR TO FILING PLAT WITH DISTRICT RECORDER.
SAN 2 T ~qpq
J~~
P KENAI PENINSULA BOROUGH
144 N. BINKLEY SOLDOTNA ALASKA 99 -
669 7599
qA.~~ BUSINESS (907) 262-4441 FAX (907)282-1892
.~.' ~~.
MIKE NAVARRE
MAYOR
January 21, 1999
Marilyn Kebschull
City of Kenai
210 Fidalgo Avenue, quite Z00
Kenai, AK 99611-7794
Re: Original Townsite of Kenai Rainbow Addition
KPB File #97-167
Referenced plat has been scheduled before the Kenai Peninsula Borough Planning Commission
on February 08, 1999 for an extension of the August 11, 1997 preliminary approval.
The Kenai Planning Commission approved the plat on July 23, 1997 by adoption of PZ
Resolution 97-37.
Think you~~
// ~
R¢bbie Harris
Platting Officer
RF~~ v O
~2S'~w l
;,::
10~
Planning
Commissioner's
Corner
Meeting fhe Mob
Bill 7owfer
Community Development Director
Coconino County, Arizona
Once or twice a year, every planning commission has a
request that seems to generate a room full of angry
neighbors. Our commission is no exception. We have seen
two in the last I$ months or so: one for a gated golf course
community for luxury second homes which was proposed
to be built in an environmentally sensitive area known as
Dry Lake; the other for a clustered subdivision of t00
homes on 1 ~0 acres in an area of 2.5-acre lots. The
former has since spawned a very active citizens' group,
Friends of Dry Lake, which will continue to fight the
development as proposed and would like to raise the ~5
million necessary to purchase khe land to preserve it as
open space. The latter caused the formation of another
citizens' group, Coconino County Rezoning Watch, which
filed enough petitions (over 5,000 signatures) to put the
rezoning request to a county-wide vote in November 2000.
}wer 100 people attended both hearings before the
planning and zoning commission.
How do you deal with a large crowd? First, the
chairtnatl needs to lay some ground rules. This can either
be done at the beginning of the meeting if there are other,
preceding cases on the agenda, or immediately prior to the
controversial hearing when that case is called. 'I'lte chair
should discuss how the hearing will be conducted. Usually
the case is called, staff presents its report with analysis and
recommendation, the commissioners have an opportunity
to question staff, the applicant makes a presentation,
public comments are taken, the applicant may be given an
opportunity to respond to questions from the commission
to clarify concerns, the public hearing is closed, and the
commission deliberates in open discussion and renders a
decision.
F'or the public comment portion, it is desirable to
limit each person's comments to about five minutes. This
can be done rigidly with a time clock, or by gentle
reminders by the chair after four and a half minutes to
have the speaker "wrap it up." Our commission prefers to
hear from proponents first and then opponents. The chair
should instruct people not to duplicate prior speakers'
testimony, but just to say "ditto" or say they agree with so
•tnd se's comments. The important thing is to give every
,arson who wants to speak an opportunity to do so, even if
that takes four hours. The chair should state that every
person will be heard, and that the comments arc important
to the commission in reaching a decision.
During the hearing, the chair needs to retain tight
control over the conduct of the meeting. Applause should
not be allowed, nor should boos or jeers. The hearing
should be kept civil at all times. There should not be debate
between the parties or between individuals in the audience.
A[I testimony should be directed to the commission. [f
speakers have questions, they should be addressed to the
chair, which should write them down and promise a
response at the end of the hearing, whether that be from
staff or the applicant. Commissioners should write down
speakers' names so that they can say, "Thank you, Mr.
Opponent," at the end of Mr. Opponent's testimony, or ask,
"Mr. Opponent, where do you live in relation to the
proposed project?" Commissioners should write down
concerns as they are raised duri~tg the testimony, so that at
the end of the testimony, they can have the applicant back
to the podium to address each of the concerns.
How should a planning commission decision be
reached? The commission should not make a decision
based on a c_o_unt of su____-__p a~orters vsiop~one~l_s. E- I ed
officials can~do that if they choose. In our cluster
subdivision case, the commission voted 8- I to deny based
solely on neighborhood opposition (the board later
reversed the decision and approved the case, hence the
referendum). Instead the commission_shouid be relying on
findin s, such as confor_mance_ to t}ie comprehensive plan,
public health, safety, and welfare_issu_es, compliance with
the zonin and subdivision ordinan~es,_and_impact_on_the
ne_ i~hborhood based on fa_c_ t_u_a1. information about traffic,
noise, dust, lights, etc.
It is important not to get caught up in the emotional
nature of a highly charged hearing, but to stick to the
findings and make a good record by referring to the
findings in the motion. When the case is referred to the
city council or county board of supervisors, the council or
board members need to understand why the
commissioners made the decision they did. To have a
record that says, "We denied it because we didn't like it,"
or "We denied it because the neighbors didn't want it,"
isn't good enough.
The most important thing is to have the audience leave
the hearing with the feeling that they had an opportunity
to comment, that their questions were answered, that their
comments were listened to, and that the hearing was
conducted in a civil and fair manner. They should be told
where the case goes next; i.e., the date and time of the
council or board meeting, or what their appeal rights are if
the commission decision needs to be appealed to bring it
ttp to the elected officials. Similarly, applicants in a
controversial case need to feel like they got a fair hearing
even if they are denied.
Chairing a raucous meeting is an unenviable task, but
if civility and order are maintained, and the hearing is
conducted very deliberately with all points of view made
known, commissioners will be able to leave the meeting
feeling good about their decision regardless of the vote. ^
~~''~ R 4 lan~tarv/Febrtaarv, 1999
I C~ c~
PLANNING 8s ZONING COMMISSION
Meets Second and Fourth Wednesday - 7:00 p.m.
Donald R. Erwin
1603 Fathom Drive
Kenai, AK 99611 283-7570 (home) 283-1303 (work)
drerwin#marathonoil, com
Carl Glick
P.O. Box 528
Kenai, AK 99611 283-7644 (home)
Phil Bryson
P.O. Box 1041
Kenai, AK 99611 283-4428 (home) 283-4672 (work)
Robert J. Newbry
3055 Kim-N-Ang Court
Kenai, AK 99611 283-9349 (hom:e) 283-7616 (work)
gizm.o@eagle.ptialaska.net
Kenai, AK 99611
Ron Goecke
P.O. Box 3474
Kenai, AK 99611
Barbara A. Nord
690 Sycamore
Kenai, AK 99611
283- (home) 2$3- (work)
283-9436 (home) 283-7070 (work)
283-9678 (home) 262-3958 {work)
Ad Hoc: Duane Bannock
2000
2001
2001
2002
2002
1999
2000
1105 First Street
Kenai, AK 99611 Telephone: 283-3158 (home) 283-3949 (work)
Contract Secretary: ASAP Answering Service
170 Corral Street, Suite A
Soldotna, AK 99669 (262-5000)
{2/4/99)
. >.
r.
;.
- ..-_.U ~-.._ .
3 - -
'N/we~ .gfiCy~4~ .,tom ,7~.N.- - - -.f ,} .- - .. -. ~-_e .:..' ..
~._~ r .ihe Alaska Department of Transportation
~; v
~ ~ ~- - --
~_
k.us - .: 't
.~
r. - ~,
state.alc.tisl. -
.~ ~-
~ ..... -S}-.
O ~ ~+
N 3
• ~ O
~ ~ N
~ ~
H
Oyu yd 1~~, rijy7 fj/~svj IlGILf ~ /~ rLY'
vv u~ rv • ~~~ 5f~• ~c~' . u s / a ~.r~iu.~.~ /a f~f~ ~~d e/p/.crrira/a/.sf~,~oa~z
nf,„~
~~ ~ 't3
~~~~
~, ~ ._
~ ~~=~
..__ o -
~ ~-
~ .. ~ ~ v
4~ Q ~ ~ ~'
L L _. ~ ~ ~ ~
.. ~ ~ ~ ~
~ i a
-- F-
a
E
a
m
0
m
N
N
A
L
Ol
Y
o chr o o cV,ap o o vw o 4 co v, o a o 0 0
0 0
CC'7] fh N
N 0
M 0
N OD r C C
A
N A N CV
fV C
N O
O [V r
~ T C O
d
p pj
O O
O
O N N [? i
7
~ ~
LL
LL
O O C 0 0 O 0 0 d 0 0 0 0 GD N O
p) O O O 0 0 O 0 0 O Q O O O
Q f G ~
!~ p
O
0-
a = i z ~ `n
2
a z z z m Z
m
~ N a
N c
N
N [7 '~f
N [•] Q
a
~o vm
m !9 ~ m
p
a is m m
m~ L m
p ~ °: v
m :4 L m
p
e ~ °~ v
~~ L iv
O ~ °:
~ .c
,?
W a~i~O t- ro ~~0 1- ycn p F m
~ ~ vCn p H N
~lAq H
U ~ O '~ .y C ~~ C t O
d ~ d C d V .y f3. 0. a
U
m _N
~ ~
W U ~
~ w C
C
G] ~ C ~ ~ ~
C 7 C ~ ~
Y DS ~ y
C ~ = G
`~ L~
Q ~ ~
~ N
m U c
C
~>. ~ /~
l O
wUr ro
` c ~ c O c °~ m
7 ~
m 9 7 Q C ~9 L
E Q d
~
of o a
.- c
o ~~
m n
a. ~
a
E m c m rn ~
F" g d~ c•~
C ~ C .N J N~ O Q
C
~i `-° w d ~ `~ -°
`~ `~ n
~ c
rn ~,
q n o
~~~ ..
y
c~.Q
~~ Ln,~~ZC
p c~
d m d~v
~
C~ aD
S
d
d d~
C
~ ~
E ~ C
pi G7 y N L O
y L p
~a ~
~ m `
c
~ } ~ _~ ~+~ ac ya
ti~
~
O v ~~
c
'- o o
a Qum
O D Y L
N ~.rn
C a C~
' ~ C ~ C C N N~
~
y ~ 7Q
.O ~
o ~ Y
W p m ~ fd ~?
, «
~ E
tp
O m ~
a V m o ~ ~ u
~~~ 'M ~' ~ ' ~
U
m u vi :° O ~
uy -a
Y 47 T ~ T'V ] C C fn a ~ l9
p~ p~ ~ C a V ~ 'a '1" ~ m
C O3 GEf = ~ ~ ~ ~ ,O ~ ~ ~ O
~~ IC ~
V 3 y ~+ ~ LL ~ U C C U
~ 3
m ~ 01 C
L c m W
6.5
W~ ~ ~ Q7 ~
~ ro E_ ~ X J
a~,
Ul ~$
VJ v L
V~
~ 3 Q ~
N m c
yam ~c._
~ oi3io ~~-~~
eve 4v, o
~ _ ~a~' m~-
~c~ 0~.5 O'y '~~m~ Y~y
10 ~N N f7 ~ ~ {0 N ~ S d ,}
~ L ~ ~
q
O 01 'X
wom Of ~ Q-
way' ql
w~ N U C
C7a[.5~ d
z[[~
C 7 7 3 ^J
~
y
C
~ N
Y
~ ~ ~ ~
L
OI
T.
L
O
7
O
O
m
- a N W N ~
Z ~ ~ ti N ~
p
Q
m
a
C
O_
U
i
N
4C
T
7
41
41
.j
O
?.
R
O
t
rn
('1
C
Ol
.y
Q7
a
N
N
G/
N
t
4
,~
R
C
E
a
N
Q
E
O1
0
a`
d
H
N
~a
3
t
2
a
i ~
0
0
0
N
Q)
m
0 0
do 0
0 0 0 o
~ C~., W N o 0 o i o of
c
I 00 ° °o ctOV n $ oc d o7
o N VS ID N O1
f O Oi p Q
I n
LL ~ r
0 0 1n 1n q o o n co ° o N CO a o co a o N
IO
N C
G ~O S•1
M r G
N pp
In 8 f~ (V O
~ O fh N
N C 1
17 O a In h
4f n h 1
S m ~ C~0 N
a0 ~ N CNO m
yl r p r Q
lL #I
LL r n
i
U7 ~
a Z N Z 2
d
ZN ~ N (7~ NCS a N 7
4
~ ~ Ol « ~ (6 ~ d W ~ ~ y ea N ~
c y 1v 'c O a~~ p `y b L O `m ~~ O
o
m ~O H
°
~N CAF
-
~ ina
F
~ ~nO
H O
I-
_
y
Cy LL ~ CN•1 C (
}
~ Oi f
,1
~ ~ _,1
t W
o a~ 0 ~ L
a Oi
p ~
a ~ ~ a m a` a o
`
rn ~'. y
m A a
~~ ~° ,
3 " °o
; Z
G
N 01 .iC
4 2 ~ C O
~ O C
~ ~
~ ~
a t ~
Y~
N
m w
f/l ~ y N .~ J 6~~1
~ p) T N
~
'y' ~ cq ~
r E c
a
.
rn` a m
w o '~ 2 ~ c •~ Y
01
r
al ~ u ~ ~ v .. ._
N
d of 'y
c ~
w ~ ~m
L V
~
`_~ .
~,1
. E v
m o ro
H y m
- N
~ itl
y T ,~ p
' V V d
a o m ~ ~
~ w e N
v rn
~' `~ rn ° o ~ ~ ~
~ n1°.
~
~ o ~
~
o~=m C '
~ C
~ C
~ ~
NT O ~ ~ ai
(n ~
m ;
C G
m
41 N G .
+
NJ y -.i
c ~ O
~ ~' V
a
a~ m
~3~t ~
~~,G OC
m~ O
r
Z# 3 1n n m m o a~ ~ c
k# U
~
° ~ L C 7 S7 ~~ r 0
U
+
.z~ ~aev ~Q woe
c
a ~
~
~ ~
J _
~
C
a
N ~ 7 y0 3
~ N o o
~ ~ v
N
:
~
O
N
3
`
O1 O
O L
O
m •~
~
e
rn
_
N
uyl
N
I
j m
a
~
~y I!
A ^
N m
I n
m
d!
Z I `v `u
1
a
a
v
a
0
0
N
W
O
o rn~ o a rn ~ o o .~-orn o o ou~ u~ Q o0 0
o ~ ao`.'D- g g ~N ~ oo uu'iu~,rn $ a ir cv
r o 00 0
p N +- N [ri N O h o c~'? N eh
} ~ ~
LL
O u! l(3 O
4 a, r- O 4 ~O h h Q O u7 u? 4 0O
4 c*? h p
~ ~~ p
IOCI O W W o
8 ¢r O (NO C~7 O ~ C~ IOA p
p p n N O
~ N N ~ f7 ~ Q O
~A f7 N ill EO
U] W W
t
F
F
a
F
~
a
~
a
a v
i u
i t
n ~
m
N N a
L N f7 7 N C~ ~ N V' N (7 V
a
O ~ N h C7 f7 L p
Q
C7 p ~
~
~ O O O ~ l~ O7
ao
of
A .- ~ ~
G1 ~ L 0 d~« O m m~ ~ L
W ~
ai
~~O
F-
y~O
F- y
~
m m~0 O
F .
~tnp O
F N .
=
acn0 0
F
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o LL LL ~ ~ ~ ~' o ~ ea
2 d m
o c
~ d
Q ° ~i
~~
`
> y
o
.y a a ~ a m a o a
c
~ .a ~
o y
`~
O ~
~
C
O
. w
O
LL
.
~ ~
0 E
0
a
X7. 3
~
N
~
+~
U a
~ VJ c
~ ~
C
~ a ~ ~' d
m ~ ~ ~- ~
~
y ~ c
ea a m
r a
~ ~ °' aC
N ~ d ~ N ~ ~
~ W N ~ }i N
OI y
7
~ ~ 7+
~ y p
O « ~
cd ~
b
~ ° S
o c O
a s y t
''-~ E
ti ~ a~ E m 3 m
~ N C N p1 O L C
a ~ c ~ 'N 9 `m ~
.`
V O O ~ Q
O C ~ ~ t6 ~ C .~ a
s ~° S~ ~y ~o
~
01 ~ ~ ~i J a C~
O c ~
o
[a a
m
C
~ ~
p~ N
~ ~*i di
C
°~ ~
7
C p N 7 d ==
~ 4 d C
~~ L
~
V ro y
L .
a N
F- ~~ G
Q ~ ~ m 43 `i
G
v a c
e~ _
~ 3 ~« o
~ [~ m D y
'm ~ # c 3 c ~ .~ m ~ E E
p r,~ ~~
~- ~ ~ ~~
,
~ g~~
~+
= C _
~. ~ _
,
.
i+ N N
J
Y
~ }
~ ,
.V
V ~ ~ ~ L _
~ '~ ~ Q N
)
~ ~v ~ v_ ~ ~ G
~ ~ o
L~ ~ L7
~ U' a g
N
rtL ~ ~¢
~ _
7
+s 2 7 m
~ 7 p
W ~ 7 L N
~ mr ~' ~- a
..ACn
~ ~ ~ o ~ a ~ '~ a c ~ c
~[~ tea` ~~ x~m ~¢Y
c*~
n
~ ~ h
O m
M
d-
~ (p
h
<n
M
N m
N
o,
a.
c
N
E
c
m
E
E
fti
0
a
a
U
Q.
F-
tl}
d
O
N
O)
QI
O 0 0 O O Cry n O C1 00 N O O p ~a cD O p p
g
r of
rn
o o
o
cv ~
m
d
+ri
sh
of
ch
ui
e
o
of o
o
p p O
~
n ~ ^ n u~ ~ N m ~
o' " e~
00 0 0 0~ o p mN o o tin 4 0 o vcp
O O
G ~
CNry N
~ ~
M C]
~
~
O
k
7 C
~p CD o
Iff
N N N~ ~ ~~ ~p
~
b
~ y O N W p
y {V n p p!
LL
C
Q N ~ c)
fA
r
~
N
d
~ N (D ~ N [*S 7 N N S7 a M 7
a
~ N o I I I~ I I l l 1~ N I I I
'q 47 N L G 01 :6 L O D1 YO L O D7 ~ L ~ (` y6 L +n}
m m~Of' ~NOF- mtnO~ ~cnO h acnQ FR-
m ` ` ~ c r ~ ~ ~ o
a a ~ a N
~ a
C
N 41
7 ui
C
O O y
~ 31
~ U tG
(,~ tq
d
;~
NN C
~
C 9 C
U U c6
~ # = Q
O
.4
S
O
L
C d1~
C
~. 0.
7 C O C U ~ c~
y
y tq O y N
~ ~ G
c
c
v
~, ~
.~ ~ .
c
cC ~ o
'O
~ N
G O. ~ G) p
0
0,
a L_
v 9
EmE~
m ro
0 n m
0
N ~ ~ m ~ o_ ~ 'a ~ c
C m of ~ o~E c a~iL ~
_ of 7 m
~ ~
`~
Y
7 O
LL G m ~ N a
i W
C
O
O
CO
o ~
a c U
o d~
v ` Y
~,
~ Q1
~
.a ~ ~ o ° ~
ors .
m
a ~ o¢
N ~ x c~
~ ~ a
i o ~,
`~ Q ~ ~v ~ ;~
d ~
U
q am fn
~ aa ~
¢~'~"
O C
~ i t ~ ~,
C C m
~
v 'N m N "' U
O~Y O m ot1 61
~
Y Y
O
o ~ ~ ~ r ~ a m N
~ ~ ~ o
a -
~~
~
~ c
^ ~ m .~
°
`
° v y
~ O1 a
~
~ N
a
~
ti N.
C c
J
C ~ ~7 O W d N
N
O
d ~ <O ~
y p C p~ Ri Oa
O y .
~~~ O ti C 0_
D C
~
yy rU
C N
?
~ V O
L
~
~_ a e
C
~
Q~
a
~ E~ N
?
~~
77 ?' ~.
~ f6 .~ C
~ .O ~ O t
-. N m
C W
~ O
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Y n7 tT ~ ?
~ Q
, d"
ED .
N ~
`
w SO
N ~ A
~v ~ D C
_ ' a
7
~ ~ ~ #
~
a ~ c
C w
G S T N
y m
a 7 c
LL o _
~ G7 ~
Y
` 'o
D ~
~ ~ N ~ i0
~ tG
C
~
m
yy
'
N ;; ~
~
W O .
O {L
l(pp
OI y Y U ~f
V
10 L ~~> d ~ 'C N v
«
~ O ~ ~
4 f
V1 N V
1 ns osro y ~.ca
w p rn
N vMi
~ i j
d e`~~
N
~ t
p ..] N
N
r-
M
7
a
a
U
N
c~
01
C
._
N
ap
C
O
U
N
O
U
d
m
O
ro
3
O
t
rs
c
v~
.y
m
N
N
Ol
VJ
td
L
d
C
G)
a
c
m
E
E
m
d
a
x
a
o n m Q v v o o m N o u~ u~ o o a 4
c° °o
g ~~ N o o c g ui
`~~ o
$ o co ri
aT o
~ o a o
n ~n~ n ,n
r r
W
o n m o v o rn ~ a • a v o v o rn ~ o 0 0 .- w c
Ol N G N N 0~0 N l~fi ~~fl O O G G O QV O n N p
Q ~ p
Y $ m ~
Oi N N N N N
^ N ~ N (y ~
} r
LL
~
Q ~ ~ ~ ~
f9
N m~ N ~ ~~ N m a N m <r N m~
~ ~ U ~ ~ ~
w ~ ~ ~ ~
~
~ ~
~
«
~
m cn p
h- ro
~ cn p o
I-
m cn p
Fp- w m
~~ p
~ ;g r
a~ O ~
~ IL ~,~
~ u- U A
0) ~ V p
a1 ~ ~f ~c
F lL V
N ~ N
`
` g
N 01
~
a ~ a
o a
~ a` U a
`,
~
~
`°
?~ c
x
N L G ~ U
b ~ y Q 61
= -o Y
~ C
~
fl
'
r
~
` dl
Y
O O
19
C ~ pp
N ~.
~i °' ~ ai a ~
Y
~ Q 0
~ m m
v t
' y
eC ~
._ a
o
,
a
e - ~
-
m r
~ ~ ~
LL ~ ~ } N
o y a C
a ~ d Q
x cn 3
a Q c ~ ~
~ 2 ~
: i
c a
~ #
m c
.
V ~ l0
N ~ t
Y ~ ~
•` Y ~
~
~ ~ ~ ~' ~ y Y ~
c
p
ao
_
N
V ~
t3
~ ~ m
t
~' ~~ c o ~ a ~ a
~ ~ Gf Q ~ ~ ~ d 4
O
. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a H 3
~ ~ 't`
08 da a ~
~ E~'
~
d 3
rn n ~
~ a ~,~
3
u
i
~ } m ~ x p Y a
C~
d
N
~ ~ 'c d C
o
T v m N m ~
't
~
~ '_ Qp
~ U C a ~~ ~ 4
~ '6 Y
~ v~
m m C d
d '~ ~ ~
Q w
~i ~ td 4' x U Y U Y
2
N
w ~~
O
a~
N
a~
N _
~~
~ N
~ o j m .~ W o W o W o
~ U ~^^ Y U ~C U Y U
~ ~ ~n
o N
~ co
a 0
~
Z +o m cn N c
n
T
m
ro
c
f
N
~ O
~ N O ~6 O O
j O W
O O O O
O O O q
G X 0 0 0 r r 0 0 0 0 0 - 0 0 0 0 ~
} C
O
V u
~
.- N ~[]
,D O7
LL'f fit
i1f 0 0 0
cO ftf
d N~
If
n 0 0 If) 1(j p p
G
C n
~
[O
A
l[7 .- ~C V
~ r
f N
OI V
~
N
m
O l
m S
ED M o n
N ~.
(7 N
r-
~ ~ ~ cf r rp l[7 f0 y..
G LL
d
Q b
p 90 O N O O
V O
7
O a N O 00 p
m O V a 7 0 0 0
~ ~ a' O ~ O (p Q O t
0 O N C
c [
C
t
n V N r 0 f
O
a O O r o ~ O N C C7 QQ
tp O~
r
~
N N
N
N
c0
f7
GO ,-
CO N r a0 I
H
f0 r ap
~
LL
C
a d
a ~
a ~ ~
~ a
4
a
a z = ~ ~ _ _
d ~
U
4 N r] a N a ¢ ~n
C ~,~ Q
L? a
`m ~ t o m ~ ~ '~ ~ `~ ~
~ .61c '.3 b :: `m is m m d W
y~0~ ~~0~ i ycn
a~ p F~. ~ yt~o~ vmu~]O~
~ ~ _
LL m m
~ ~
$ ~.
`~ ~ d
u- u
m
~
' ~
O O ~ O O p •q
4 d N 6 ~ q. d
N
d tp
D
~ m '°
T
a
N m
'~ ~
(l1
c
C tL ` b Y
~ ~ Ctl ~ U
~ X
E Y C
~ p i ~
a •~ Y
~~ c
m
~ , O .
. :
V N ~ 9 ~ ~ ~ ~U
C ~ W= LL
1L1 0 t~ ~ 4 c
`
°
cc
w u
d o a~
1O v u~
o c w
•
$ a
Y
E
~
~
a ~,
N ,
Z O ~
a
E ~
~ a ~
Y b
+
m
f% ~, ~ o~ Q ~ . ~ .E ~
Z, ~
.c c m ~ ~ p ~ 2' r3~ Q n a_
=~ ~ p
= Y m Z
m ~
c W m
°U E
~~
2 ot
, ~ `~ ~ °
~
v 0 ~ ~ ? m
a u'
c H w ~ v,
c ~ in z o
N U y
~ W
V1 U ~, [
Y U $
10G ~
c
~
b
i+
m
~ ~
c
3 Y Y
J
C
"77
(!7 8
d W
y
4 Y Y
C
O
V
~
~
Q~ D
S U
N
O _
O L pi y
DI ~
y
.
~ ~ ~ R O ~~
a o
a 0 0
m
rA°
o`
L U ffl
O ~ ~ N d ~ ~
~
U C
~ ~
C7
~
s
~ a c c rn
O ~ ~~ y ~ '
y ~ cLi v C7
~ Q ' X ~ ~ ~
1~ d
O [~ 'O
N
X (O
V li7
v
~
n
O
N
~ 61
a co m ao ~ wv m m
rn z ~,
rn ~
r ~
C
Q~
E
c
a~
E
Q
ro
c
0
.~
U
N
N
a
c
J
U
a
° o 0 0 0 0 c 0 0 0 0 0 0 o
' O
g o $o g oo c o0 0 ~°~ o
oo o, do 0
a o o co ~
ao rh
}
I1 Sri ~fi ~i
LL
~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O O Q O O 0 0 N O {6 0 0 °° p
oo c i°n°o ra~o c°g 00 o g° ~ n cmo°~° n $ ~° o
Y a „- . v ~n rn
u- -
~
ri
ri
e~ ~
a ~
v us
~
c
a
Q
C~
4 O
p
Q- a a ~ cn ~ a
a
d
~ ~ N '~f N ~ N 7
d
~ a~+ N ro c~ .~. 61
ro 1~ (b ~ N
;v
` ~ ro ro ~~+ N ~ W r `
`
L
~, ~
~ o
F y
t
v~p p
H m
t
inp o N d ro~
cnO
'
' 0 m
~
' Q
~
O - ~ ~ F-. ~
g h ~fis0 1-
LL ~ lL u
~Y LL. V LL 11. y {l, ~
0! EI N
d ` ` ~ `
~ a a a a ~
ro
s a
~
u~ 'c
m
h ~ ~
~
L ~'
~ ~i U
3
o e a
i
N E
m
o
r
~ ~ ~ p ~ Z
m
~ v ¢
~ ° U
LL ~ ~ ~ .u O
O ~ m
~ w
~
C
c. Y
~ O1 «
y
aci w
_~ ur
~
~
~
~ ~ ~
~ ~3
cq }
g o ~
C
ro
r-
O d ti ~
4 N ~ t
V m ~ 1
1
QI C C
G 41 G ~ v 0
O C n a~ ro'C ~ N ~~
~
m et ro o ~ _~ R ~ ~ a
ro an 2 °- W ~ ~~E
C
3 roo
y
7 V ro Oi N N 41 67 N
Y t
? z
O!
O '- ~
`n ~ ~ LL1 :d
- .rot _ _
_
2 ~° Y
-
~- cro
°
~9 ~
y~
x m c
~ ~ro
c c
~c g EL i° ro ~ ~~
"
~ m ro
d [L rn
~ lZ. O m
2 Q Y s
N d « as
c~
N ~ U.
C
O
~
y
U }' O
UJ x
~
3j N
L
OI ~
_
_ ~
y 10 ~ (b
N ~ 7 7 ~
~ ~
~ C C C Z
~
0
o G
a C
a C
a y~ ~
ro
c
m C C C C
d Y X Y li
D
~
In
~
O
N
,~ .S ~
~
J N
W
la cn
~
Z O [O Q
j
rn
as
_N
T
O
r
Q
m
Q.
m
c
'o
U
~_
O
Q1
p
m
O p
p O
6
O 0 0
0 0
c0 ~ 0
O
O 0 0
O O
~D ~ V 111 O
~D [7 O
7 r ~(7 C
O O
O p O O
90 [V
~D V p p
Q C~ 0 0 Q
O
7 Q
O G 4
O
n 1L1 f7 r
pp
~ M N p
~
Q
} N .- N l4 r u'i r
h f~ M (9 r G
h CO f
0
N C
1~S 111 N
.- Op N N r
lL
W r r a
~ O O O 0 0 0 0 0 O lt1 l[7 O 0 0 O O O O O O O
O O O 0 4 0 C O
1n O 111 a
v C
In O Q G C 0 0 G O C
~ y
LL
o m¢ m~ m= dm ~m
.
a ^m Qm oz =a za
a
~
t
N C
N a
1~1 V
N [7 V
M 7
4
m ~ ~
~v m
0 m ~n m ~
~a R i m ea ~ L
ov ~ % ~ ~ a
a iv
O ~ 'm ip °' m is
L °
°1 iv
0
u7p
a s F
- Ulp
a s H -
1nO
a s H ~
~~?
a ~i F
- ~ ~~
~i a O ~ F-
LL LL ~ LL lL ~ LL ll, u
dj lL LL ~,1
@ ~ C _
LL 1L
~ E
`
`
`
` ~c ,~ i m
a a a a o~ a o
¢Y a
n3
~ ~
~
~ c ~
T
~ a-
X ~
a c
~ N ~ Vl
~ ~ ~ o
.,
~
a ~>
~ ~
~ U
m
C ~ _ a
~ L y
U 0 N
L ~ U
~
3 _
~ .y
a ~ .c
~
~ t
O O a
fd ~ O
g nL
~ ~ N c~ _
d acaE
c ~ 3 a c ~ a
3 '~ i`c ~ c o ~
m
Z ~ a w ~ ~ a a
o a c
O
' o
C
a o ~ rn
~ l6 q
a
' ~ a ao c a am
`"
C x `S
~ a ~ ~
x m'
y
~ N
aQe ~ e E
~ c ~ T
~ ~ C[
y w, c
O~p m ~
01~
~ i3
Y
~ ~c
a 1
~ 'C7
m m 2
~a
~ 2
v
a
c
~; ~ rn~ . rn
x
.
aa~i =~y ~~ ~
rn~ °~ac
m~ ~ m~ N C ~~ 'fl
~ -°r ~r Cis ~.~
m o a
W N _
~ C ~~ t Y ~~ t~G
^
c a
C y ,~
m g o
a ~ c
N ~ o E
c
~ ~ ..
U C j
C
~ o
Vl `~
c d1 ~
~
~
> a
i
~a _a
5x1
c
O ~ .
~ O ~ y # QO d
e ~ O
G r ~ a
y
_C1 C
i
_
E ! .
~ N d
C1 ~
C ~ F
y
= d C
U S d Y a b1 ~ Cn O
~~ ~.E
a e~ v°
. ~-o~`~
QLL .~
V S/}
[7~ ~ o.
Y ~ m r n
r/la[X.5
D
'a N 'a O cNp n ~' ~,
Z W (O n ~ N ,
~
er
A
Q
m
O1
ro